Canucks Corner Editorial – The Low Point

To the frustrated Canucks fan,

We are all Canucks, and right now, we are all feeling the pain.

The Canuck image, reputation and brand, has been tarnished & humiliated. This could arguably be the lowest point of its 44-year existence in the NHL, perhaps much lower than the Stanley Cup collapse in 2011.

When did it all go wrong? Many pundits would think that it started right after the Canucks lost in Game Seven to Boston. But in my opinion, the freefall started earlier than that, about twenty years ago after the Canucks lost in Game Seven to the New York Rangers.

Before his death prior to the start of the 1994 Playoffs, Canucks owner Frank Griffiths ran a steady ship. The Canucks made two trips to the Stanley Cup Final under his watch, the first one being in 1982. Frank’s son Arthur Griffiths sold the Canucks to John McCaw & the Orca Bay Sports & Entertainment in 1997. In my opinion, the Orca Bay “Regime” was truly the start of the Canucks’ longstanding free-fall with their brand.

Source: Wikipedia

Source: Wikipedia

The Orca Bay “Regime’s” List of Mistakes:

  • Changing the team logo to a whale (remember this, Hartford?)
  • Signing Mark Messier
  • Trevor Linden “relinquishing” his captaincy to Messier, a move Messier would later say he regretted taking
  • After a miserable start in the 1997-98 season, GM Pat Quinn gets fired
  • Coach Tom Renney also gets fired, replaced by Mike Keenan who takes over as Coach and subsequently does GM duties
  • Given the division within the dressing room between the Linden and Keenan/Messier camp, Keenan traded Linden to the New York Islanders for…Todd Bertuzzi
  • Enter Brian Burke as GM

Under Burke, the Canucks didn’t fare well as fans had expected. The team had a serious dry spell under Messier’s watch, with no appearances in the post-season. Things eventually improved under Markus Naslund’s leadership, and they managed to grab first place in the Northwest Division on more than one occasion. In the playoffs however, the Canucks couldn’t advance past the second round. For six seasons and one lockout, fans could only watch in constant disappointment.

The Brian Burke “Regime’s” List of Actual Improvements:

  • Firing Coach Keenan and hiring Marc Crawford
  • Drafting Henrik and Daniel Sedin in the 1999 Entry Draft (initially controversial)
  • Burke traded disgruntled player Pavel Bure to the Florida Panthers for Ed Jovanovski
  • Alex Mogilny is traded to the New Jersey Devils for Denis Pederson and Brendan Morrison, thus completing the West Coast Express Line (Naslund/Bertuzzi/Morrison)
  • Burke traded for Trevor Linden from the Washington Capitals in November, 2001

But then came Todd Bertuzzi/Steve Moore Incident.

As a result, Bertuzzi was suspended for a long time, is currently facing a class-action lawsuit by Moore, and Naslund was never the same. The West Coast Express was broken up when Bertuzzi was traded for Roberto Luongo. The trade meant that the Canucks had a solid first-rate goalie not seen since Kirk McLean. And after falling short of making the playoffs in 2006, Coach Crawford was replaced by Alain Vigneault. Despite these drastic changes, the Canucks still couldn’t get past the second round.

Fans’ patience was starting to run out, not that this was anything new. Then came the Mike Gillis “Regime”. This list of mistakes speaks for itself:

  • Mike Gillis was hired by new owner Francesco Aquilini. A player agent, Gillis had no GM or front office experience
  • After Linden retired at the end of the 2007-08 season, he wasn’t offered a front office position by Gillis
  • Naslund and Morrison became free agents, leaving Vancouver on a sour note
  • Gillis named Luongo team captain
  • Mats Sundin signed with Vancouver half-way into the 2009-10 season. He had the lowest scoring output and eventually retired after the Canucks lose to the Chicago Blackhawks
  • Gillis signing Luongo to a 12-year, $64-million contract extension
  • Do we need to revisit 2010-11?
  • Do we need to revisit the early exit in 2012 and 2013?
  • Questionable trades starting with rookie Cody Hodgson for Zack Kassian
  • The hiring of John Tortorella
  • Inability to deal with the goaltending soap opera, which led to the disastrous trades of Cory Schneider and Roberto Luongo away from Vancouver
  • Vancouver is still paying 15% to Luongo after his trade back to Florida
  • Short on young talent and wasted draft picks
  • Do we need to revisit the various disasters of 2013-14? (i.e.: Torts going ballistic against the Flames, Canucks blowing a 3-0 lead against the Isles, seven-game losing streak, Torts sitting Luongo in the Heritage Classic, Ryan Kesler’s trade demand, Gillis throwing Torts under the bus)
  • This list can go on and on…

Final Retrospect:

With the firing of Mike Gillis and the introduction of Trevor Linden as President of Hockey Operations all in the same week, you have to wonder what’s next for this tarnished hockey club. Why would he join a dysfunctional organization that had scorned him on several occasions? It’s going to take more than him to regain the trust of many season ticket holders and disgruntled fans.

Back where he belongs? You be the judge.

Another concern is why would the Aquilini’s go after a legendary Canuck who by the way was doing well for himself in his retirement years but has no front office experience. Does this sound familiar? Comparing him to Boston’s Cam Neely is like comparing apples to oranges. Neely learned inside the front office after his retirement, and worked his way up to President to turn his Bruins into Stanley Cup contenders. Thanks in part to GM Peter Chiarelli, the Bruins have managed to make the Stanley Cup Finals twice in the past three seasons. And they have just captured the Presidents Trophy in 2014, heading into the postseason as Cup favorites once again.

Was the hiring of Linden as President a desperate PR move? The Aquilini’s won’t admit that, but for the sake of Linden, let’s hope he can get the help he needs to make the Vancouver Canucks relevant again. I wish Mr. Linden the best of luck in pulling the Canucks out of current laughing stock of the NHL.

Postscript: Mr. Linden, please get rid of the whale. The “killer” instinct is no longer there…

Peter Chau

Peter Chau

A former novice/atom player, timekeeper and fan of the game, Peter has lived and breathed hockey throughout his life, covering hockey happenings in Edmonton, Vancouver, and currently in Saskatchewan. He is now a contributing writer for the Hockey Writers.
Peter Chau
RT @1310news: NOW: #Carleton looking into possible relationships btwn students & #Ghomeshi, #RCMP police warning, #Halloween http://t.co/e9… - 1 hour ago
Peter Chau
Peter Chau

Latest posts by Peter Chau (see all)

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required Email Address * Name Email Format html text mobile