“Old-Time Hockey” is Killing the Game

There is an epidemic in today’s NHL.

Stars are dropping left and right and it is taking away from the game’s overall appeal.

Sidney Crosby hasn’t played for the better part of two years due to concussions. Chris Pronger is out for the year, same reason. Claude Giroux was out with a concussion. Danny Briere too. Don’t forget Toews is currently out due to the “C” word. Pierre-Marc Bouchard on IR. Jeff Skinner, last year’s Calder Trophy winner, missed 16 games. Why? You guessed it, both were concussed.

Now, Pittsburgh Penguin’s star defenseman Kris Letang received his second concussion of the year after getting hit in the head by Dallas StarsEric Nystrom in a game last Wednesday.

The league has decided not to discipline Nystrom, sending a message to the rest of the league that not all hits to the head are created equal, so keep at it.

With all these star players missing time, it means the fans are forced to watch a game that isn’t as good or exciting as it should be.

The NHL is not the NFL. Not in revenue. Not in popularity. And not in protecting their star players, which in turn, is the same as protecting the product they put on the ice. The same product they are trying to sell to the fans or would-be fans.

In football, a hit to the head is a hit to the head. Intention is not factored into the discipline decision. This ensures that the star players, namely quarterbacks and wide receivers, who help sell tickets and merchandise by being on the field…stay on the field. The NFL protects its interests.

The NHL, however, subscribes to the “Old-time hockey” theory. A theory that seems to have been skewed over the years and is more outdated than floppy discs and VHS tapes. It seems that hockey’s brass would rather protect and keep around their “tough” and marginally talented players than ensure their skill players stay on the ice.

Sidney Crosby sells tickets and jerseys. Some fourth line winger doesn’t.

Old-time hockey used to mean playing a tough, physical game. Giving it everything you had. Fighting for the puck in the corners. Going to the net. Toughing out injuries. Never wanting to quit on your team and respecting your fellow player. Lets say that again…Respecting your fellow player.

Somewhere along the way, however, old-time hockey has brought on a meaning of getting blind-sided and not whining about it.

Playing tough, physical hockey doesn’t mean leading with your elbows or hitting a guy in a vulnerable position. It doesn’t mean launching yourself into a man at full speed. It doesn’t mean knowing you are out-skilled by another player, so the only way you can compete is by crossing the line.

Player’s respect for one-another seems to be at an all time low. This is reflected in most team’s injury reports.

Respecting the game and its players should be part of old-time hockey, but sadly isn't. (photo courtesy of SI.com)

There is a difference between playing tough and playing reckless. Steven Stamkos and Phil Kessel manage to play tough without dueling out concussions. Same with Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin. Same with Patrick Kane too, and so many others.

All of them are star players. All of them are tough players. None of them are dirty players. These are the players who truly encompass the old-time hockey definition. Nothing they do takes away from the game.

Those who hide behind ‘old-time hockey’ when hits like Nystrom’s happens like to say things like, “It was a clean hit. That’s the game of hockey.”

The problem with this is that they are right. Right now, sadly, that is the game of hockey. Hits to the head are part of the game. They shouldn’t be.

A clean hit shouldn’t put a player’s life or career at risk. In today’s NHL they can.

The league claims that they are trying to remove these hits from the game. They need to take a page from Nike’s book and “Just do it”.

Outlaw all head shots, be they intended or accidental.

Will there be the occasional player that gets suspended after a purely accidental play? No doubt. However, this also guarantees that you won’t drop the ball on the guys that knew what they were doing. Sometimes extremes are necessary when trying to change a culture.

Strict enforcement will help players keep better control of their hits, as well as make them think twice before they decide to not play the puck, as Nystrom chose not to do, and instead opt for torpedoing themselves into another player. Hip checks aren’t the problem. The problem stems from the player who comes from the opposite side of the ice, full speed, in order to deliver a flattening hit.

These types of hits usually are blind-sided and uncontrolled. They leave no time for the hitter to alter their body if needed and are only meant to be devastating.

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell has taken large steps towards taking head shots out of football despite complaint from fans and players (photo courtesy of SI.com)

The NFL dealt with all kinds of backlash from players and fans alike when they instituted their firm stance on banning head shots. Now, cracking down on those who violate their rule is a part of their game. Just ask Pittsburgh Steeler James Harrison.

The NFL is not worried about being fair. The NFL is worried about the safety and well-being of its players and, probably to a greater extent, the viability of its product.

It doesn’t help the NHL that Crosby wasn’t at the All-Star game, or in last year’s playoffs, or on any nationally televised games. What it says to those would-be fans is, “look at how goonish and dangerous our sport is.”

The distorted view of old-time hockey, and the refusal for some players to change, is moving hockey closer to the UFC rather than the NFL in the minds of sport fans.

It’s not like player’s can’t change. Look at Matt Cooke. Last year he was considered to be on of the dirtiest players to ever play the game, and rightly so. His 129 penalty minutes last year solidified that view. Cooke has a total of 26 penalty minutes this season. Change is possible.

Will the league ever take the hard stance it needs to? We may need to wait a generation or two for personnel changes within the league’s head offices where younger, more progressive thinkers could have a say.

Until then fans can only hope that their star players don’t get injured and their favorite sport doesn’t loose complete relevance.

Michael Viola
Michael writes on the business of hockey and how it impacts the fan's enjoyment of the game. He is a PR and Marketing professional with a background in journalism and a love for hockey.

12 Comments

  1. Kane a tough player?  Malkin? I’ve missed something, somewhere. Dude, I understand your feelings about injuries, but I believe you’ve misunderstood the concept of tough hockey. Just because someone is a professional hockey player doesn’t make him a tough representative of his trade. In all likelihood he’ll be somewhat harder than your average joe, but thats about it. Kane, Datsuk, Zetterberg, Giroux, Stamkos, all superb players but not exactly ferocious hitters or feared because of their prowess when it comes to fisticuffs.

    Anyhow, you can seriously hurt someone with a perfectly clean hit. It doesn’t have to be dirty, and that has been the game of hockey for as long as anyone can remember, I believe. However, w/ the post lockout rules, size, speed and skill of players these days, two players ramming into one another tends to be more harmful than it was 20yrs ago, and that’s clearly hurting the game. I mean, I hate the Pens and I think Crosby is a nob, but without such a gifted nob things just aren’t right. What to do? How about an automatic on game penalty like there is with a high stick drawing blood, and for the clearly malicious hits suspensions/fines etc. If hitting the head is an automatic, say, 5min penalty then surely the players would take notice, because games would be lost due to this. Or am I just daydreaming? Would players be fishing for these penalties? And moreover, what’s a Kronwall going to do when linig up a Voracheck, eh?

    I dunno.

    And, it says nowhere that you’re supposed to play the puck when you’re hitting. What you’re trying to achieve is separating the opposing player from the puck. It’s an added bonus if you get the puck in the process, non? Or do you remember coach yelling at the defenseman when practising 1-on-1’s: “Play the puck, take out the puck!! ,”  Or was it rather: “play the man, take out the man?”

    It’s a contact sport at the end of the day, innit?

    End of a ramble/

    I’m off to eat something light

  2. wow finally.  the culture has to change.  if nystrom or anyone knows they are getting 5 or 10 games (or better 25K or 50K) if he hit’s letang in the heat then i guarantee he plays the puck and lets up there.  that simple.  to use a sport that’s just as relevant as hockey, in soccer some plays have been completely removed from the game since they will result in immediate ejection regardless of circumstances.

  3. Bobandterry says:

    Nothing will change as long as the Canadian Stone Heads and their leader Don[ if you cant beat em in the alley you cant beat on the ice]Cherry have their way. This is so obvious its scary. The best player in the game is one concussion away from ending his career. Letangs hit should have drawn 5 games as Nystrom had no intent to play the puck. Icing rules need changed to whistle blown when puck crosses the line. The only sport that not only condones fighting but promotes it. until a modicum of intelligence prevails and I hold out no hope the NHL is on its way to rack and ruin.

  4. I agree with all of the points presented here, but only in terms of intentional hits to the head. There was a time when being a “star player”meant that you also needed the ability to skate with your head up. If you can stick handle, shoot, and skate, but have to look down to do so…you’re not a superstar. You’re a dead man walking.

    I agree that players who are out head-hunting deserve stiffer penalties, but let’s not kid ourselves…Semenko may have been there to protect Gretzky in case of an indicent, but the real reason no one ever hit Wayne is that he was able to think 4 steps ahead of everyone else on the ice. Knowing when NOT to make a pretty play and simply ducking out of the way is a dying skill with the finger being pointed at the hitter every time.

    Intentional headshot = stiff penalty.

    Accidental contact to the head because the puck carrier leaned forward/looked down/turned into it=learn to watch where you’re going.

  5. I disagree Chrisalexo42.  It’s the instigator penalty.  Back in the day your enforcer kept creeps in line with the possibility of a pounding if you took a cheap shot at a star player.  Now with the  instigator penalty the enforcer can’t start the pounding, thereby allowing the creeps to head hunt with no risk.

  6. Canitleaver says:

    Steckel is gonna get his. If I were him, I ‘d stay out of dark alleyways.

  7. Chrisalexo42@gmail.com says:

    I couldn’t disagree more. Hockey has been the same for decades and the reason people watch this sport instead of golf is because of the physicality of the game, not just the skill. There is definitely room for regulations and making sure people don’t get hurt, but to attack the entire idea of “old time hockey” is ridiculous. As a die-hard Red Wings fan, I can say that more rules and regulations would make not only the Wings, but other physical teams in the league much less interesting to watch. Think about the controversy surrounding the rule changes a few years ago… people want to see a good physical game that the players invest in emotionally, not a shootout. 

  8. Chrisalexo42 says:

    I couldn’t dis

  9. Awesome article!  Our son is still recovering from a concussion he received in September of 2009.  It is lif changing.  Young people see these players as their idols and changing the way he hit each other may very well change lives!  Excellent topic to address!

  10. The Steckel hit on Crosby was clearly unintentional. Just thought I would point that out. And not mention of Backstrom? That cheap shot had one of the league’s top centers on longterm IR. 

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required Email Address * Name Email Format html text mobile