The Montreal Canadiens: Atlantic Division Favorites?

Put simply, the Montreal Canadiens—the last remaining team in the Atlantic Division last season—got better this summer.

Obviously it’s all a tad more complicated than that. Defenseman P.K. Subban and forward Lars Eller still need to be signed. And a lot can happen over the course of an entire regular season, for example injuries or trades made by other teams to get better.

However, that is in part the point. Other teams need to get better or the Habs need to get worse in order for Montreal not to have a very realistic chance at winning the division this coming 2014-15 season.

As things stand now though, on paper the Habs are the best team in the Atlantic, especially taking into account how each rival’s offseason has gone.

Here’s a team-by-team breakdown of the Atlantic’s top projected contenders (excluding the rebuilding Florida Panthers and Buffalo Sabres) in order of how each has fared so far this offseason:

 

6. The Boston Bruins

Cash-strapped, as far as the salary cap is concerned, the Bruins have failed to sign any unrestricted free agents this offseason, with the most notable being one of their own in Jarome Iginla.

Former Boston Bruins forward Jarome Iginla

Former Boston Bruins forward Jarome Iginla – (Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports)

The Bruins are now faced with the unenviable task of replacing a top-line 30-goal scorer from within. While that is indeed possible for a team that boasts the likes of Loui Eriksson and revelation Reilly Smith, Boston’s depth nevertheless took a serious hit this summer.

Bottom line: If they didn’t sign any one to improve their chances at winning, they only improved their chances at losing, even if only slightly. After all, these are the reigning Presidents’ Trophy winners we’re talking about. It’s not like they became bad overnight. So the question becomes did the Bruins get as bad as the Canadiens improved?

It’s a fair question. However, since they were 3-1 against Boston last season (7-4 with the playoffs), even as dependent on goalie Carey Price as they may have been, the Habs were arguably already better. A goalie is still a part of the team.

Boston is probably still most everyone’s pick to repeat as division champions, but it wasn’t too long ago, just two seasons in fact, that Montreal finished atop the old Northeast, ahead of the Bruins. It can happen again.

 

5. Detroit Red Wings

The Wings have had a slightly better offseason than the Bruins, if you can call re-signing three non-key players—including depth defenseman Kyle Quincey for over $4 million per year—better. Quincey’s barely good.

Detroit Red Wings defenseman Kyle Quincey

Detroit Red Wings defenseman Kyle Quincey – (Andy Martin Jr)

Joining Quincey are goalie Jonas Gustavsson and left-winger Dan Cleary, both of whom would be lucky to see the ice consistently and positively affect Detroit’s chances next season. That’s because Gustavsson is a mere back-up and Cleary, in just 52 games “last year, he didn’t bring anything,” according to head coach Mike Baccock, via NBC Sports writer Mike Halford.

Still, despite the team’s less-than-stellar performance last season (eliminated in five games in the first round) and this summer, there is realistic hope the Wings can bounce back.

Stars Henrik Zetterberg and Pavel Datsyuk aren’t getting any younger—in fact they’re getting very much older at 34 and 36 years of age respectively. But they are also in the midst of passing the torch to the team’s impressive group of youngsters from last year: Riley Sheahan, Tomas Jurco, Gustav Nyquist, and Tomas Tatar.

If each of those key players can continue their development, the Wings will be a force with which to be reckoned. If none of them do, Detroit’s front office will likely become ground zero for the reckoning after a presumably horrible season.

Chances are good neither scenario will unfold. It will be somewhere in the middle and the Wings’ season will likely play out much like the previous one did, with slight disappointment, promise for the future, and, yes, yet another playoff appearance.

 

4. Ottawa Senators

The Senators didn’t fare as badly in the Jason Spezza trade as many might believe. For a player they likely would have lost anyway at the end of this coming season (and Ludwig Karlsson), Ottawa got a potential top-liner in the making in Alex Chiasson and three futures. However, the key word there is ”futures.”

Ottawa Senators forward Alex Chiasson

Ottawa Senators forward Alex Chiasson – (Ross Bonander / THW)

That “in the making” part likely means a few years at least and in the here and now Kyle Turris is now the team’s de facto number-one center, because free-agent pick-up David Legwand certainly isn’t one, and Mika Zibanejad isn’t ready yet. It still remains to be seen if Turris is himself, in all honesty.

Add in the loss of Ales Hemsky to the Dallas Stars, and you can expect the team’s relatively potent offense from last season (2.79 goals per game) to take a hit. The Senators’ hopes now lie in the team’s goaltending (which allowed 3.15 goals per game) and its defense (which allowed 34.7 shots per game).

Considering the previous season, the Sens allowed just 2.08 goals and 31.3 shots per game with much the same personnel—minus Norris Memorial Trophy winner Erik Karlsson due to injury—it’s very much possible Ottawa rebounds nicely. Unlikely, but possible.

 

3. Toronto Maple Leafs

Summing up the Toronto Maple Leafs offseason: Their top free-agent pick-up has a broken leg, while their second-best had been allowed to leave for the Kontinental Hockey League because he was so gosh darn valuable the first time around.

 

 

That may not be fair to either Stephane Robidas, who’s actually pretty decent possession-wise according to Extra Skater, or Leo Komarov, an admittedly effective bottom-six forward. But the fact remains neither Robidas, who’s 37, nor Komarov, who’s just 5’10” and 187 pounds, are in the best position to spark far-reaching systemic change on a team that allowed 35.9 shots per game last year.

No, that would be head coach Randy Carlyle, who is back despite a disastrous end to the season—and who helped to implement that very same system in the first place.

Toronto had a decent offseason in all honesty, due in large part to the non-signing of Dave Bolland, who ended up with the Florida Panthers for $5.5 million per year for five seasons. A contract like that can cripple a cap team like Toronto, and they should know having signed David Clarkson just last summer.

However, the Leafs were nonetheless prepared to give Bolland “a five-year deal deal in the neighborhood of $5 million per year,” before Florida swooped in and saved the day according to TSN’s Bob McKenzie on Team 1040 (via The Score).

The Leafs only lucking out as a result of Bolland’s history with Panthers general manager Dale Tallon (and Florida’s huge amount of cap space) points to a need for a serious intervention. The first step for the Leafs is admitting they have a problem. Until they come to that realization, they are likely to keep on missing the playoffs.

 

2. Tampa Bay Lightning

After the Habs exposed Tampa’s defensive-zone coverage time and again during their first-round sweep of the Lightning this spring, general manager Steve Yzerman addressed the problem by acquiring underrated blue-liner Anton Stralman.

 

 

While he should no doubt help, one has to wonder just how effective a single top-four defenseman will be in curbing what had become a very serious concern the last quarter of the season: goals against.

The simple truth of the matter is Anders Lindback, while mediocre against Montreal during the playoffs, was not the whole problem—certainly not a problem replacing him with 39-year-old Evgeni Nabokov will fix. Even Vezina Trophy nominee Ben Bishop had started to come down to Earth after defying gravity most of the season.

Tampa Bay Lightning forward Ryan Callahan

Tampa Bay Lightning forward Ryan Callahan – (Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports)

Prior to going down due to injury in early April in a game against the Maple Leafs, Bishop had played 18 games since the Olympic break. On 526 shots against, he had allowed 51 goals (.903 save percentage). Seeing as he finished with a .924 percentage, it’s clear how well he had been playing beforehand and perhaps indicative of how lucky Tampa was to get as far as the first round.

In any case, Yzerman nonetheless improved his lineup in other ways, adding depth forwards Brenden Morrow and Brian Boyle on the cheap, while re-signing glorified depth forward Ryan Callahan for not so much ($34.8 million over six years).

All in all, it was a decent, but curious offseason, especially in regard to the acquisition and then trading of Sam Gagner for lack of cap space. The Lightning, according to capgeek.com, are now $1.88 million over the ceiling. One can’t help but wonder if hanging onto the younger, more dynamic offensively, and cheaper Gagner instead would have been a better way to go. Fans will soon see.

 

1. Montreal’s Offseason so Far

Without a doubt, Montreal’s biggest departure from last season is Thomas Vanek, but it almost constitutes addition by subtraction.

While Vanek is a top-line player who’s more than capable of putting the puck in the net, he became a fourth-liner making $6.4 million by the end of his tenure here, making Habs fans in turn nostalgic of Alex Kovalev’s final season as a Hab when he was making just $4.5 million.

Minnesota Wild forward Thomas Vanek

Former Montreal Canadiens forward Thomas Vanek – (Gary A. Vasquez-USA TODAY Sports )

With the money that would have potentially gone towards re-signing Vanek, the Habs instead turned their attention to signing the underrated Tom Gilbert to shore up the team’s defense and potentially improve its power play.

They also signed depth forward Manny Malhotra to center the team’s fourth line and jettisoned previous fourth-line center Daniel Briere, getting a top-six forward, P.A. Parenteau, in return (and a draft pick!).

Montreal did admittedly lose both Brian Gionta and Josh Gorges, two heart-and-soul players. However, that is often just a nice way of saying they lack talent.

Gionta is an aging winger who no longer has his scoring touch, netting just one goal in 17 playoff games. He was no longer worth his previous $5 million salary.

Gorges meanwhile never had scoring touch to begin with, and, while he was an undeniably valuable player, he will be turning 30 next month. Considering his self-sacrificial style of play, the Habs probably made the right move, pre-emptively trading him before the wear-and-tear really started showing in his game.

Losing Gorges also opens up a slot on the left-side for either Nathan Beaulieu or the towering Jarred Tinordi. Gilbert, the re-signed Mike Weaver, and the soon-to-be-re-signed Subban also even things out by finally giving the Habs three right-handed shots on defense.

The Habs essentially cost-effectively addressed all their needs entering this offseason, perhaps losing leadership in the process, but gaining youth instead, and with it increased mobility and size.

That should be a scary thought for opponents of a team that reached the Eastern Conference Final and arguably improved to a much greater degree than their competition in that series, the New York Rangers. But that perhaps leads into a story idea for another day.

Ryan Szporer

Ryan Szporer

A Montrealer born and raised, I first became a Canadiens fan when I was eight and my parents plopped me down in front of the television set to watch the final moments of the Habs' 24th Stanley Cup victory over the Los Angeles Kings. Little did they know how much heartbreak they would cause me over the years as a result. Professionally, I work in marketing and own a journalism degree. Personally, hockey, whether writing about it or watching it, remains my No. 1 hobby all these years later.
Ryan Szporer
Montreal Canadiens off to best start since 1961-62! http://t.co/VTPORbiCjl via @thehockeywriter - 5 days ago

6 Comments

  1. “Even Vezina Trophy nominee Ben Bishop had started to come down to Earth after defying gravity most of the season.”

    That’ll happen when you tear a tendon in your wrist and continue to play for 2 months. TWO MONTHS with a torn tendon and still played very well.

    • Ryan Szporer Ryan Szporer says:

      Hi, Jochen,
      You’re right. I neglected to mention Bishop’s tendon. But my point wasn’t that he sucked. I mean, even though you and I clearly have vastly different definitions of “playing very well.” A .903 save percentage is not good. It’s mediocre.

      My point was that the Lightning gave up a lot of goals over that last third of the season and into the playoffs (16 in four games against Montreal). Bishop wasn’t playing during the playoffs, and, while, yes, Lindback isn’t an NHL starter, I don’t think he can be faulted for the series sweep.

      Montreal outplayed the Lightning in their own zone. That’s my point. And I think Anton Stralman will help correct that, but not to the degree that the Lightning will become the beasts of the East everyone seems to think.

  2. Horrible post says:

    I like how you talk about Gorges, saying “never had scoring touch to begin with”. Well to be honest I think Habs lost A LOT when it comes to leadership, and penalty killing. Gorges has been one of the best shot blocker in the game for a while now.

    Anyways that’s not the point. I don’t really like how you disregarded the Tampa Bay Lightning, saying Ben Bishop “came back to earth”? How about playing with a torn ligament in his wrist since January 5th.

    Let’s see how the Montreal Canadiens would do with Carey Price playing with a bum knee, or yet again see how good Montreal is without Carey Price…It was pretty obvious vs. the Rangers.

    Anyways calling the TB Lightning “lucky” for making the playoffs is non sense considering MTL won 3 games by 1 goal with the Lightning having to put Anders Lindback and his .874sv% in net. Every single game he allowed 1 bad goal to start the game.

    Anyways this goes to say that your bias is showing, and mine as well. You might want to stick to making Habs fan happy, by only talking about the Habs.

    This was brutal for any team other than the one you ARE cheering

    • Ryan Szporer Ryan Szporer says:

      You said a lot of things I disagree wholeheartedly with. I’ll try and address them one by one:

      1) Josh Gorges: You’re right in that Gorges has been a valuable penalty-killing defenseman for years. I don’t know what you think scoring touch has to do with that, but whatever. However, he makes $3.9 million per year, and all that shot-blocking he does will be replaced in theory by Mike Weaver for much less money. Weaver actually led the Habs in shots blocked during the playoffs. Montreal needed right-shooting defenseman, because once they signed Markov, they only had five under contract for next season (all left-handed shots, including Gorges). Gorges, based on his age and his salary, was the best bet to be traded in order for Montreal to get extra space to resign Subban.

      2) Regarding Bishop: As I said in another reply to a comment on this page: “You’re right. I neglected to mention Bishop’s tendon. But my point wasn’t that he sucked. My point was that the Lightning gave up a lot of goals over that last third of the season and into the playoffs (16 in four games against Montreal). Bishop wasn’t playing during the playoffs, and, while, yes, Lindback isn’t an NHL starter, I don’t think he can be faulted for the series sweep. Montreal outplayed the Lightning in their own zone. That’s my point. And I think Anton Stralman will help correct that, but not to the degree that the Lightning will become the beasts of the East everyone seems to think.”

      3) Regarding Carey Price: Save for Game 1 against the New York Rangers, I really don’t know what you’re talking about when you say “see how good Montreal is without Carey Price.” Dustin Tokarski played incredibly for the Habs the remainder of the series and one of the main reasons the Habs lost the first game (in which Budaj, not Tokarski, relieved Price) was because they were so drained from their series against the Presidents’ Trophy-winning Boston Bruins.

      4) Regarding calling Tampa “lucky” for making the playoffs: I was only referring to the fact that Montreal outplayed Tampa in the series. You can blame Lindback all you want, but if you put the series squarely on his shoulders you and most everyone else were watching different series.

      5) Regarding your comment that “This was brutal for any team other than the one you are cheering”: Please read the following snippets:
      -Re: Boston: “these are the reigning Presidents’ Trophy winners we’re talking about. It’s not like they became bad overnight. So the question becomes did the Bruins get as bad as the Canadiens improved?…Boston is probably still most everyone’s pick to repeat as division champions, but it wasn’t too long ago, just two seasons in fact, that Montreal finished atop the old Northeast, ahead of the Bruins. It can happen again.”

      -Re: Detroit: “despite the team’s less-than-stellar performance last season (eliminated in five games in the first round) and this summer, there is realistic hope the Wings can bounce back. If each of those key players can continue their development, the Wings will be a force with which to be reckoned. If none of them do, Detroit’s front office will likely become ground zero for the reckoning after a presumably horrible season. Chances are good neither scenario will unfold. It will be somewhere in the middle and the Wings’ season will likely play out much like the previous one did, with slight disappointment, promise for the future, and, yes, yet another playoff appearance.”

      Re: Ottawa: “The Senators didn’t fare as badly in the Jason Spezza trade as many might believe. For a player they likely would have lost anyway at the end of this coming season (and Ludwig Karlsson), Ottawa got a potential top-liner in the making in Alex Chiasson and three futures…. Considering the previous season, the Sens allowed just 2.08 goals and 31.3 shots per game with much the same personnel—minus Norris Memorial Trophy winner Erik Karlsson due to injury—it’s very much possible Ottawa rebounds nicely. Unlikely, but possible.”

      Re: Toronto: “Toronto had a decent offseason in all honesty, due in large part to the non-signing of Dave Bolland, who ended up with the Florida Panthers for $5.5 million per year for five seasons.”

      Re: Tampa: “Yzerman nonetheless improved his lineup in other ways, adding depth forwards Brenden Morrow and Brian Boyle on the cheap…All in all, it was a decent, but curious offseason, especially in regard to the acquisition and then trading of Sam Gagner for lack of cap space.”

      I don’t really see how you can argue my bias is showing when I tried to tell both sides for each team in this piece. You’re right though in that I am a Habs writer. However you’re wrong if you are assuming I only write positive things about the team. I’ve come under fire before for criticizing the team when I was writing for Bleacher Report. I tell it like it is, in my opinion. And I legitimately believe Montreal improved the most of any team in the Atlantic. Considering they are only one season removed from a Division Championship and were the last team standing in the division this season, do you really think it’s out of the question that they win the Atlantic next year?

  3. Ryan Szporer Ryan Szporer says:

    Thanks! My inspiration was this piece by Helene St. James of the Detroit Free Press: http://www.freep.com/article/20140717/SPORTS05/307170038/montreal-canadiens-red-wings

    It just struck me as completely… what’s the word? Yeah, “wrong.” Especially the part about: “They haven’t improved their scoring capability, and as a group Montreal’s defensemen don’t stack up to Boston’s or Tampa Bay’s.” It’s funny how one writer can get all the facts right, but have such a different interpretation of them.

  4. Great article couldn’t agree more… So many people are saying that montreal got worse this season and it is just not true so again great article!

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required Email Address * Name Email Format html text mobile