With the 2026 offseason approaching, the New Jersey Devils enter a familiar challenge: balancing a talented roster with limited salary cap space. After a frustrating and inconsistent season, management is certainly looking to reshape parts of the lineup in hopes of building a team ready to make a serious run for the playoffs.
While blockbuster moves are never guaranteed, there are several players who could realistically find themselves on the trade block this summer. Whether it’s due to cap constraints, roster fit, or long-term planning, three names stand out as potential trade candidates: Dougie Hamilton, Simon Nemec and Paul Cotter.
Dougie Hamilton: Cap Relief & Defensive Reshaping
There has been no shortage of speculation surrounding Hamilton over the past several months. The veteran defenseman found himself at the center of trade rumors earlier in January when he was surprisingly held out of the lineup, a move that many around the league interpreted as a precursor to a potential deal. Despite the noise, no trade materialized, leaving questions about his long-term future in New Jersey unanswered.
Hamilton remains one of the most offensively gifted defensemen in the NHL, capable of driving play from the blue line and contributing heavily on the power play. However, his production has not been at the same level it once was, and some of his underlying numbers raise concerns. He currently sits at a minus-6 rating and has recorded 96 giveaways, reflecting some inconsistency in his defensive game and puck management. While his offensive instincts are still valuable, these dips in performance make it more difficult to justify his impact relative to his cost.
Related: Devils Week Ahead: Schedule & Storylines — Bratt’s Scoring Streak Snapped, Injury Updates, and More
That cost is high, as his sizable $9 million average annual value (AAV) cap hit presents a significant challenge for a Devils team already navigating tight financial constraints. Moving Hamilton would immediately create much-needed flexibility, allowing management to address other areas of the roster.
From a roster construction standpoint, trading Hamilton could also open the door for younger defensemen to take on larger roles. The Devils have invested heavily in their blue line pipeline, and clearing both cap space and ice time could accelerate that transition. While dealing with a player of Hamilton’s caliber is never easy, it may ultimately be a necessary step if the organization wants to reshape its defensive identity and redistribute resources more effectively.
Simon Nemec: A Difficult Long-Term Decision
Trading a young, highly skilled defenseman like Nemec would not come without risk. As one of the organization’s most promising blueliners, Nemec has shown flashes of high-end ability and projects as a key piece of the Devils’ future. However, the business side of hockey often forces difficult decisions, and Nemec’s situation could become one of them.
There have been increasing discussions about how the Devils will manage their defensive depth moving forward, particularly with several players competing for limited roles. Finding consistent ice time for Nemec has not always been straightforward, and if the organization believes it cannot fully maximize his potential, a trade could become a realistic option.
Complicating matters further, Pierre LeBrun of TSN reported in March that Devils management had been fielding calls on the 22-year-old defenseman. It has also been suggested that Nemec’s next contract could come with an asking price of an average annual value of around $9 million.
For a team already pressed tightly against the salary cap, committing that kind of money, even for a highly talented young blueliner, may not be realistic. With significant financial resources already allocated to key forwards and other core pieces, the Devils could ultimately find it difficult to afford Nemec over the long term.
If that’s the case, moving him now might be the most logical course of action. His age and skill would make him an extremely valuable trade asset, potentially bringing back a significant return that better fits the team’s immediate needs. It’s the type of move that could be controversial in the short term but beneficial from a broader roster-building perspective.
Paul Cotter: A Depth Piece Who Could Be Moved
Unlike Hamilton and Nemec, Cotter wouldn’t headline any major trade discussions, but he represents the kind of depth player who could quietly be moved as part of a roster tweak. Cotter has had an up-and-down season, frequently moving in and out of the lineup, which made it difficult for him to establish consistency.
That said, he does bring value in specific areas. His physicality and energy make him a solid option on the fourth line, and he has proven to be particularly effective in the shootout. Those traits can be appealing to teams looking to round out their bottom-six forward group.
However, with Cotter set to become a restricted free agent (RFA) at the end of the season, requiring both sides to agree on a new contract, the Devils may determine that their fourth line needs a fresh approach. Whether the goal is to add more speed, bolster defensive stability, or bring a different offensive element, management could consider moving Cotter for a player who better aligns with the team’s evolving identity.
Pivotal Upcoming Offseason
For the New Jersey Devils, this offseason could be one of the most important in recent years. The team has already established a strong core, but turning that foundation into consistent success will require smart decision-making and, potentially, some difficult roster moves.
Ultimately, the Devils’ front office must determine how to best allocate resources while maximizing the team’s competitive window. Whether that means making bold trades or more subtle changes, the decisions made this summer will likely shape the trajectory of the franchise for years to come.
