How the Maple Leafs Could Build the Best Fourth Line in NHL History

In this post, I am going to make a case that the Toronto Maple Leafs might have a unique opportunity to create the best fourth line in NHL history by keeping Jason Spezza and by signing two restricted free agents (RFAs) – Joe Thronton and Wayne Simmonds. Might it be possible to utilize the experience, desire, and skills of these aging players to create something unique in NHL history and push the team toward a Stanley Cup at the same time?

The Maple Leafs’ Recent History with Aging Players

Over the course of my two seasons covering the Maple Leafs for The Hockey Writers, the team has had two players on the roster who are NHL legends – Patrick Marleau and Spezza. Those players provided both general leadership both to the team and specific mentorship to individual younger players. They also impacted team cultural in a positive way and, by doing so, helped the team immensely.

Related: Maple Leafs News & Rumors: Kapanen, Hallander, Pietrangelo & More

Both Marleau and Spezza are class acts. They are true professionals who supported team values, added to team chemistry, and provided leadership and value on the ice.

The Impact of Patrick Marleau

Marleau had special relationships – almost fatherly – with a young Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner. Matthews and Marner became part of Marleau’s family, even to the point of participating in family holiday gatherings. The depth of their relationship was obvious when Matthews skated in the NHL All-Star Game in San Jose and during warm-ups removed his own jersey to reveal a Marleau #17 jersey in the city where his mentor had played for so many seasons. It was a tribute from a young player to an older one.

Marleau’s problem in Toronto was not his person or his play; it was more the size of his contract signed by former Maple Leafs general manager Lou Lamoriello wasn’t good for the team. At $6.25 million for three years, it was too rich and became an albatross.

The Impact of Jason Spezza

Three moments during the 2019-20 season showed me the professionalism and the value of Spezza. First, Spezza’s season got off to a bad start under former head coach Mike Babcock. Given what seemed like a questionable reason – not enough time working on the special teams – Spezza was a healthy scratch against his former Ottawa Senators in the first game of the season. Spezza took the high road.

Jason Spezza Toronto Maple Leafs
Jason Spezza, Toronto Maple Leafs (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

Second, when Nick Robertson was called up for the team’s Phase 3 training camp, a video showed Spezza working with Robertson after practice on his one-timer. That extra attention had to help Robertson in two ways – by improving both his skills and his sense of belonging.

Third, during the Columbus Blue Jackets play-in series the Maple Leafs eventually lost, Spezza – who’s not known to drop the gloves – fought the Blue Jackets Dean Kukan to give the team some energy. That the teammate other Maple Leafs players call “Vintage” would engage in such out-of-the-ordinary activity showed how much he wanted to win.

Could the Maple Leafs Use More “Vintage” on their Fourth Line?

Spezza made it known that he wanted to win a Stanley Cup and prior to the 2019-20 season signed a league-minimum contract with the Maple Leafs to do that. After this season was concluded, he let the organization know he’d like to return.

Related: 10 Reasons Hockey Is the Greatest Sport on Earth

An article in August reported that the team loved Spezza and thought he went “above and beyond” team expectations. He was “an incredibly positive influence. That article also noted the professionalism of Spezza. The point is that the Maple Leafs really liked and appreciated what Spezza brought to the team. In other words, we know what Spezza brings and I for one hope he’s re-signed so he can continue.

The Possible Addition of Joe Thornton

Rumors since February suggest that the Maple Leafs are interested in San Jose Sharks center Joe Thornton. In one of his 31 Thoughts articles, Elliotte Friedman shared that rumor and later, in a Sportsnet podcast, he repeated it.

Joe Thornton San Jose Sharks
Joe Thornton, San Jose Sharks (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

About three weeks ago, it was again rumored that, because Thornton was still chasing his boyhood dream of winning a Stanley Cup, he was upset not to be traded at the trade deadline when the Sharks were no longer contenders. He’s now an unrestricted free agent (UFA) and he’s looking for a Cup-contending team.

The rumor then suggested that Friedman believed Maple Leafs fans could expect Thornton to sign a $1-$2 million contract with the team, noting that Thornton remained an elite playmaker who could be an asset to the Maple Leafs both in terms of his play and meeting the team’s salary-cap issues.

Friedman, in a “thought” shared several months ago, believed the Maple Leafs would do well to sign and use NHL veterans like Thornton (and he named Ron Hainsey as well). I share the same position. However, Friedman doesn’t believe the team could have both Spezza and Thornton at the same time. I don’t share that position.

In fact, in this post I’ll go even further.

Wayne Simmonds Is Interested in the Maple Leafs

Earlier this week, forward Wayne Simmonds spoke with Pierre LeBrun of The Athletic about his future as a UFA this offseason. Simmonds, once considered one of the best NHL power forwards, could score, skate, play special-teams, and throw a punch or two. (from “What does the future hold for Wayne Simmonds in new NHL economy?, The Athletic, 08/09/20).

Wayne Simmonds Buffalo Sabres
Wayne Simmonds, when he was with the Buffalo Sabres (Photo by Michael Martin/NHLI via Getty Images)

Over recent seasons, he’s been an NHL gypsy moving from team to team. After playing several strong seasons with the Philadelphia Flyers, he’s played for the Buffalo Sabres, New Jersey Devils, and the Nashville Predators. But, he’s struggled to stay the player he was. Now, it seems Simmonds is looking for a chance to showcase what he has left. Although he’s now 32 years old, Simmonds believes he can still play.

He told LeBrun, “All I have in my mind is that I’m ready for this upcoming season whenever it does happen. I’m looking to make a huge impact wherever I go. Obviously I know I didn’t have the best of years last season. I’m looking to prove a lot of people wrong and show that I can still play at the level that people are accustomed to seeing me play at.’’

Related: Maple Leafs Hit a Home Run With Kapanen Trade

Here’s what we know. Simmonds is dropping hints he’ll sign a team-friendly contract. During the LeBrun interview, he admitted it had “crossed my mind” about playing for the Maple Leafs. In fact, he just moved back to Toronto and likes the city. Simmonds also said he knew the team was in “a salary cap situation,” but then mentioned that “Toronto’s got a great core of players and I think that’s definitely a team where I could go in and make an impact right away.”

If that isn’t asking to be invited to a party, I’m missing something. Simmonds ended the interview by announcing “I’m open to everything, It’s up to the teams. Whoever wants to choose me, I’ll be waiting. I’ll definitely be ready to go.’’

Is there a Creative Possibility?

In this post, I’m asking a radical question. Could the Maple Leafs leverage the attraction to RFAs of playing with a Cup-contending Maple Leafs team to create a fourth line of aging veterans who’d relish another chance for a shot at the Stanley Cup and who would use their veteran experience, skill, desire, and leadership to positively impact this young team?

Related: Maple Leafs News & Rumors: Keefe, Matthews & Spezza’s Leadership

A fourth line of 32-year-old Simmonds on the right wing, 41-year-old Thornton at center, and 37-year-old Spezza on the left wing might be the strongest fourth line in the history of the NHL.

From what it sounds, general manager Kyle Dubas appreciated what Spezza brought to the team at a league-minimum contract last season. We hear that Dubas has Thornton on his radar – again, for an inexpensive contract. So, why not triple down with Simmonds at a league-minimum contract? It’s certainly salary-cap team-friendly, and it might be a win-win-win for the Maple Leafs and these players.

Toronto Maple Leafs general manager Kyle Dubas
Toronto Maple Leafs general manager Kyle Dubas (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Christopher Katsarov)

Given the experience, pride, and desire these veterans could bring to the team, offering an opportunity could make the 2020-21 season exceedingly interesting for fans in the Toronto area.

Sign up for our regular 'Maple Leafs Newsletter' for all the latest.