Revisiting Capitals’ Trade for Anthony Mantha

On April 12, 2021, the Washington Capitals acquired forward Anthony Mantha from the Detroit Red Wings in exchange for Jakub Vrana, Richard Panik, a 2021 first-round draft pick, and a 2022 second-round draft pick. The trade deadline acquisition was a shock to many fans, as Vrana was having a solid season with the Capitals, and seemed to be the stronger player compared to Mantha. Trading away Panik was solely to free up money, but giving up one of the team’s core future pieces with two high-level draft selections seemed mind-boggling at the time.

Vrana Joins Rebuilding Red Wings

Immediately, the Red Wings felt the impact of Vrana’s presence. During the 2020-21 season, it was clear they were in full rebuild mode. Bringing in draft capital on top of one of the Capitals’ best players at the time was genius. He seemed to be a core piece the Red Wings planned to build around for the foreseeable future, as the only other real “star player” they had at the time was Dylan Larkin.

Related: Capitals Depth Proving Team Is More Than A Power Play Team

Vrana finished the 2020-21 season with the Red Wings playing 11 games, averaging a point per game with eight goals and three assists for 11 points. The opportunity seemed greater in Detroit than it was in Washington for Vrana, as his ice time saw an increase. He was playing on the power play and was being rewarded for his sound two-way game with some time on the first line. At first glance, this trade looked dumb from the Capitals’ point of view.

Mantha Joins Cup Hopeful Capitals

Stanley Cup hopefuls acquiring star players from struggling teams has become an expected practice every year at the trade deadline, so for the Capitals to go out and snag Mantha from the Red Wings, who were second last in their division, was not a huge shock apart from the trade package. Mantha was able to score four goals and add four assists for eight points in 14 games before the playoffs. His presence was also felt immediately by his new team, as they seemed to have found a depth scorer to take some of the pressure off their top six.

Anthony Mantha Washington Capitals
Anthony Mantha, Washington Capitals (Photo by Patrick McDermott/NHLI via Getty Images)

With only two assists in five playoff games, Mantha didn’t have as big of an impact as the Capitals hoped for, but he was going to be a project. They invested plenty of assets into him and they were willing to wait a season or two for him to break out.

Did Either Player Pan Out?

Vrana has been battling injuries since his days with the Capitals, so his career has been overshadowed by them. In only 26 games with the Red Wings in 2021-22, he was able to score 13 goals and put up six assists for 19 points. On a struggling Red Wings team, that was good enough for 12th in team scoring. All in all, he was never able to get his game going with his new team. The Red Wings dealt him to the St. Louis Blues at the 2023 Trade Deadline and he finished the 2022-23 season with 16 points in 25 games.

Mantha also battled injuries, so it took toll on his overall impact with the Capitals. In 2021-22, he played 37 games and scored nine goals with 14 assists for 23 points, also good enough for 12th on his team in scoring. He, like Vrana, wasn’t fully able to get his game going. He was healthier in 2022-23 with 27 points in 67 games.

Neither player had the impact either team would’ve expected out of the two. They are both skilled players and it showed when they were on the ice, but injuries for both of them meant they could never showcase their true value.

Where Are They Now?

Unfortunately, neither player is with the team that acquired them. Vrana was sent to the American Hockey League (AHL) in 2022-23, while Mantha was traded to the Vegas Golden Knights at the 2024 Trade Deadline. He was overtaken by the new players the Capitals brought in and found himself in the bottom six with only 92 points in 174 games played. While still a strong player, he fell out of favor with the Capitals. He signed a one-year contract with the Calgary Flames in the 2024 offseason.

Vrana is in a similar boat. He was assigned to the Grand Rapids Griffins of the AHL and struggled offensively. After a stint in the NHL/NHLPA Player assistance program, he returned for two games where he put up a goal and an assist with the Red Wings before being placed on waivers. The Red Wings traded him to the St. Louis Blues in March 2023 and he spent most of 2023-24 in the AHL.

Jakub Vrana St. Louis Blues
Jakub Vrana, St. Louis Blues (Photo by Zac BonDurant/Getty Images)

Both players have struggled to live up to their hype. At the end of the day, I think it’s easy to say the Red Wings won the trade, as they added two prospects with the picks they acquired from the Capitals. So, even though Vrana was pushed out, they have two more players in their system that could prove to be more valuable than him.

Substack The Hockey Writers Washington Capitals Banner