Anaheim DucksBoston BruinsBuffalo SabresCalgary FlamesCarolina HurricanesChicago BlackhawksColorado AvalancheColumbus Blue JacketsDallas StarsDetroit Red WingsEdmonton OilersFlorida PanthersLos Angeles KingsMinnesota WildMontreal CanadiensNashville PredatorsNew Jersey DevilsNew York IslandersNew York RangersOttawa SenatorsPhiladelphia FlyersPittsburgh PenguinsSan Jose SharksSeattle KrakenSt. Louis BluesTampa Bay LightningToronto Maple LeafsUtah Hockey ClubVancouver CanucksVegas Golden KnightsWashington CapitalsWinnipeg Jets

Red Wings Report Cards: Forwards at the Quarter Mark 

With 21 games in the books, the first quarter of an already nightmarish 2026-27 season is over for the Detroit Red Wings. The team hasn’t solved either of their most glaring problems with Dylan Larkin and Simon Edvinsson still sitting out, and missing two of the team’s five most talented players has taken a clear toll on the team standing-wise.

Lucas Raymond Detroit Red Wings
Lucas Raymond, Detroit Red Wings (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

With 25% of the new 84-game schedule already past, let’s look at all of the forwards to play for Detroit so far this season and give them a letter grade based on their performance. Players will be graded not just on success but on their success relative to expectation. For example, a star player with 15 points and a second liner with 15 points would earn very different grades. 

Without further ado, let’s hand out some grades at the quarter mark of the 2026-27 season.

Mason Appleton: D-

I’m being a little generous on the grade here because Mason Appleton hasn’t had the chance to get into the swing of things this season, playing only two games before going down with an undisclosed injury. He has re-joined the team to play another two games but hasn’t done much of anything yet. Zero points is forgivable in such a small sample size, but Appleton’s underlying stats are horrendous in the early goings with a Corsi For percentage of 43% and an Expected Goals rate of 45% (stats via NaturalStatTrick).

Victor Arvidsson: A

Victor Arvidsson was given the unenviable task of replacing Patrick Kane’s production on Detroit’s second line and their powerplay. In the early going, he has done an excellent job with 15 points in 21 games, a 60-point pace. Kane scored at a 71-point pace last season, so if Arvidsson keeps it up he’s going to do an admirable job of giving Detroit offense from someone not named Raymond or DeBrincat.

Michael Brandsegg-Nygård: A

Michael Brandsegg-Nygård (MBN) has had a really strong rookie year so far, with 11 points through 21 games and a remarkable 99 hits which ranks second in the entire NHL despite averaging just over 15 minutes a night. MBN has shown flashes his potential as a two-way play driver with good skill and a great shot, and his play as a 21-year-old gives me faith that he will at least be a great middle-six driver for Detroit, with a chance to become a gritty top-line winger.

Michael Brandsegg-Nygård Detroit Red Wings
Michael Brandsegg-Nygård, Detroit Red Wings (Gerry Angus-Imagn Images)

J.T. Compher: C

Despite missing seven games in October, J.T. Compher is on pace for his second highest scoring season in his Red Wings tenure with seven points through 14 games. His shooting percentage is inflated currently, which is to be expected in a small sample, and Compher is getting demolished in the faceoff circle so far to the tune of a win percentage south of 43%. Compher is still an able middle-six center and hopefully he can get some more talent to play with if Detroit ever deals Larkin and/or Edvinsson.

Andrew Copp: C+

Andrew Copp has had to play 2C minutes in Dylan Larkin’s absence, a role that he has handled well despite taking more defensive zone starts than anyone not named Michael Rasmussen. He could probably be expected to have some better luck offensively going forward, with the Red Wings scoring on just 6.7% of their shots when he’s on the ice. 

Nate Danielson: C

Nate Danielson was justifiably sent down to the Grand Rapids Griffins after scoring just two points through 13 games to start the season. However, I would argue that bad luck has factored into that much more than normal and I think there’s a case to be made that Danielson has played better than Compher. Through 13 games, Danielson’s PDO (a rough measurement of luck in the NHL) sits at an abysmal 0.911, the 19th lowest mark among all NHL players to play at least 100 minutes so far.

Nate Danielson Detroit Red Wings
Nate Danielson, Detroit Red Wings (Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images)

Let me re-phrase, out of 597 NHL players to play at least 100 minutes this season, only 18 have had worse luck than Danielson so far. Hopefully earning more points in Grand Rapids helps to bolster his confidence as he inevitably returns to Detroit later this season.

Alex DeBrincat: A-

Alex DeBrincat, as a surprise to no one, has been great to start the year. With seven goals and 16 points through 21 games, DeBrincat is still a good bet to pick up his scoring. Over his 700+ game, 300+ goal career, DeBrincat has scored on roughly 14% of his shots, so far this year he’s scoring on just under 10% of them. With a little correction there, it’s safe to assume DeBrincat to score 30+ goals and 70+ on the season despite Detroit’s top center playing just 10 games before sitting out.

Sheldon Dries: D

Sheldon Dries is an excellent AHL player who scored 17 points with the Vancouver Canucks back in 2022-23, the only time he has exceeded 10 points. It’s a testament to Detroit’s lack of depth that he has played about 10 minutes a night for 15 games this season. Dries has just one point in that time, and is losing the advanced stats battle heavily in his somewhat sheltered role.

Emmitt Finnie: A

18 months ago, very few Red Wings fans had heard of Emmitt Finnie, and even fewer considered him seriously as a future Red Wings player. After he broke into the league last year with 30 points at age 20, it seemed like Finnie was going to top out as a good middle-six forward, a huge development success for a recent seventh round pick. 

Emmitt Finnie Detroit Red Wings Kevin Lankinen Vancouver Canucks
Detroit Red Wings forward Emmitt Finnie scores on Vancouver Canucks goalie Kevin Lankinen (Bob Frid-Imagn Images)

However, this season Finnie has taken another massive leap, becoming a legitimate top-six center and playing as Detroit’s first line center even before Larkin walked out. I wouldn’t say he has excelled to this point in that role, but if Finnie can continue developing in the next few years, he could become one of the league’s best development stories in years.

Marco Kasper: B

Marco Kasper missed all but one game in October with an upper-body injury and only just re-joined the Red Wings’ lineup in the past week. In a sample of just four games so far this season, Kasper looked solid, with only one goal to show so far offensively, but some great numbers under the hood. His 58.6% CF% leads Red Wings forwards at even strength and he leads in xGF% as well with a staggering 64.8% through a small handful of games. If he can maintain anything resembling these numbers while holding onto the second line center minutes he has been given since returning from injury, then Kasper will have an incredibly successful season. 

Keegan Kolesar: D

Among the seven Red Wings forwards to play in all 21 games so far, Kolesar ranks seventh in scoring (just one point so far), seventh in shot share (SF% 47.3%) and seventh in expected goals percentage with 44.2%. He has done an alright job filling the role expected of him with his 52 hits in limited ice time ranking 38th in the NHL, but there’s not a lot more to his game so far. 

Dylan Larkin: N/A

Despite still officially being a member of the Detroit Red Wings organization, Dylan Larkin is no longer a Red Wing and won’t be receiving a grade as a result. He was playing fine before opting to sit out in an attempt to force Detroit’s hand in a trade, but even before his absence, Larkin was losing minutes on the top line to Finnie which wasn’t a great look.

John Leonard: D

John Leonard has had a phenomenal season in the AHL so far this year with the Grand Rapids Griffins, scoring 11 goals and 14 points in just nine games. In the NHL, however, he has been largely outmatched with the worst advanced metrics results of any forward on the Red Wings in his three games. Expectations aren’t super high for Leonard when he does check into Detroit’s lineup, but he has to do more than this if he wants to continue to earn games. 

Carter Mazur: C+

Carter Mazur has had a ton of injury trouble in his young career, playing just 53 total games between the AHL and NHL between the 2024-25 and 2025-26 seasons. Mazur’s health has been great to see this year, though he has still missed a handful of Red Wings games so far as a healthy scratch. Through 14 games, Mazur has scored his first career NHL goal and added four assists. Mazur still has a ways to go as Detroit is being outshot and outchanced significantly in his even strength minutes so far. 

Michael Rasmussen: C-

Michael Rasmussen is being used as a shutdown defensive center in Detroit right now, with the most defensive zone starts among all forwards. Rasmussen starts just 37% of his shifts in the offensive zone, which means he’s being expected to make defensive stops in tough matchups. There are no forwards on the team who have been scored on more than Rasmussen so far this season, and while some of that comes down to the tough minutes and role, I think it’s fair to say some of it is him being miscast in this shutdown role. 

Michael Rasmussen Detroit Red Wings
Detroit Red Wings center Michael Rasmussen and Toronto Maple Leafs defenseman Oliver Ekman-Larsson fight for position in front of goaltender Dennis Hildeby (Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images)

Lucas Raymond: A

Lucas Raymond leads the Red Wings in goals with eight and points with 21 through as many games, putting him on pace for his second 80 point season. That’s happening despite Detroit not having Raymond’s frequent running mate Larkin in the fold, which is all the more impressive. This Detroit team is in dire need of an injection of talent, but you can’t blame Raymond for the team’s shortcomings though, with his three game winning goals ranking seventh among all NHL players. 

Free Newsletter

Get Detroit Red Wings coverage delivered to your inbox

In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.

Subscribe Free →
Logan Horn

Logan Horn

Logan is a prospect writer for The Hockey Writers, and he's also a part of the Detroit Red Wings writing team. He loves reading about statistics and advanced analytics, and discovering how they can enrich his hockey analysis and writing.

More by Logan Horn →