Jeff Petry’s Time In Edmonton Is Limited

There have been few Edmonton Oilers defensemen over the last few years that have been debated more than Jeff Petry.

Much of it has been critical. He’s not physical enough. He’s not consistent enough. He’s not a true top pairing guy.

All of it not necessarily wrong, however the fact is he has also been one of the Oilers top blueliners since he became a full time member of the team.

He is also one of the only homegrown players that the Oilers have drafted outside of the first round to pay dividends in the NHL. In fact, he’s really the only one in the last decade.

Jeff Petry Oilers
Jeff Petry (Nick Turchiaro/Icon SMI)

Contract Situation

The reality of the situation, is that good, bad or otherwise, his days as an Edmonton Oiler are numbered.

He’s a pending unrestricted free agent, and there certainly is not a sense that he would take a hometown discount to stay in Edmonton. To the contrary, the Oilers would likely have to overpay to keep him.

Petry is a Michigan native and most reports indicate a move to the East and closer to home is what he wants.

Based on that, it is highly unlikely he will get to free agency to make that decision, and the Oilers will try and trade him by the trade deadline and try and recoup some value rather than losing him for nothing.

Judging from some reports, it’s something the Oilers have been contemplating for some time.

He probably won’t bring a significant NHL piece back, but if the Oilers can get back the second round pick they used to draft him, and perhaps a prospect, they would be happy with that.

There is Plenty of Value

Whether fans love him or hate him, Petry is a solid NHL defenseman.

He’s got good size with a long wingspan, he’s an excellent skater and makes a good first pass out of the zone. He’s also a right-handed shot, which is becoming more in demand.

He’s also only 27 years old and entering into what should be the prime of his career.

Petry may not be a top 2 or 3 defenseman, but on a good team he is a solid second or third pairing guy. Especially in a situation where he doesn’t have to play 23 minutes a night and can settle into the 17-18 range.

It makes you wonder why the Oilers don’t make a push to sign him. The fact is that there have been efforts made, but the sides remain apart and the writing appears to be on the wall.

Is Jeff Petry on the block? (Russell LaBounty-USA TODAY Sports)
Is Jeff Petry on the block? (Russell LaBounty-USA TODAY Sports)

Possible Destinations

Detroit Red Wings

The most obvious and probably the most likely landing spot. Petry wants to go to Detroit and Detroit is in desperate need of a right-handed defenseman.

If the teams can work out a deal agreeable to both, it makes sense for both sides.

Pittsburgh Penguins

A contender in the East and another team looking to upgrade it’s defence, Petry could be a solid second or third pairing defenseman and contribute on the penalty kill.

The two teams have already made one deal, the David Perron one, and could be in line for another.

[See Related, Pittsburgh Penguins Trade Target Profile: Jeff Petry]

Philadelphia Flyers

The Flyers are still looking to make a playoff push and with an injury plagued blue line they are looking for replacements.

Petry’s name has already been linked to the Flyers on multiple reports so it appears there is at least interest in a deal there.

Los Angeles Kings

With the Slava Voynov situation what it is, the Kings find themselves thinner on defense than they’d like to be.

Drew Doughty is still a stud, and partner Jake Muzzin has been good, but to contend the Kings would likely want to add a right-shooting defenseman to fill Voynov’s spot if possible.

Anaheim Ducks

Likely a pure rental situation, but adding another mobile defenseman for a playoff run is no doubt on GM Bob Murray’s to do list.

The Ducks have a solid group on the backend, but they still need some help in their own zone and Petry could also be a valuable addition to their penalty kill.

The Ducks are serious contenders, and one thing those teams can never have enough of is depth on the blue line.


Follow Carl on twitter @CarlTHW for more articles


4 thoughts on “Jeff Petry’s Time In Edmonton Is Limited”

  1. Dear Mr Oiler Contributor perhaps looking into what teams other than Edmonton need would be a good idea. The last thing the Penguins need is another defenseman. They actually looking to move Martin or one of the young defensemen to pick up another offensive piece not more defense. You article had me up to that point, but now I question all that I read to that point.

    • Hi Don, thanks for reading and your input. Pittsburgh may not be the frontrunner, but I believe they are potentially looking for depth on the backend. They are looking to trade Martin but it’s not due to numbers or talent, it’s contract situation and the fact he is going to walk as a UFA. Maatta is also likely done for the year and their young defensemen like Pouliot Harrington or Dumoulin aren’t quite ready for a big role in a playoff run. They may not be desperate for one, but adding some legitimate NHL depth in terms of a rental is possible, especially in the case that they trade Martin, who is their best defensive and PK defender. Legitimate Cup contenders can never have enough NHL depth on defence this time of year. That also doesn’t rule out them moving a young defenseman for more offensive help as well.

      • As a Pens fan, I think you are dead on with Petry being a potential target for Rutherford. Unless Despres or Pouliot really display incredible improvement in the next month leading up to the trade deadline, the Pens are going to be missing a reliable 4th dman for the postseason with Maatta out for the year. You are 100% correct that Martin is the best defensive dman on the roster and even if Maatta were healthy, the return in trading him would have to be very high to warrant losing him for a playoff run. I also think Petry could potentially be viewed as more than a rental as Martin and Ehrhoff are on expiring contracts as well and the team only has a need to retain one of those two (or three) veterans with all the younger dmen they have. Thanks for you article, I look forward to more from you.

Comments are closed.