Detroit Red Wings: Could Matt Murray Be the Answer in Goal?

This season, the Detroit Red Wings’ goaltending duo of Jimmy Howard and Jonathan Bernier were under siege nearly every night. In the case of Howard, he had a ghastly 2-23-2 record and a save percentage (SV%) of just .882%. Bernier fared a bit better, with a SV% of .907%, but was mostly helpless given the ineptitude of the team in front of him.

Related: Steve Yzerman – The Captain

Howard seems to have played his last game with the Red Wings, and perhaps in the NHL entirely. Bernier, who turns 32 years old in August, has one season left on his contract, and is far from the long-term answer the Red Wings seek in goal. Despite his team-MVP status this season, he could find himself wearing another team’s jersey by the time the 2021-22 season comes around.

Jonathan Bernier Detroit Red Wings
Jonathan Bernier, Detroit Red Wings (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

For a rebuilding team like the Red Wings, the long-term answers at each position are far from entrenched. For all we know, current top-line center Dylan Larkin could be a second-line center by the time the team contends for the playoffs again. It is general manager Steve Yzerman’s current task to find players that could become permanent solutions throughout the lineup. Perhaps the biggest hole in the organizational depth chart is in goal.

The Athletic Drops a Bomb

Josh Yohe, who covers the Pittsburgh Penguins for the popular sports journalism site The Athletic, recently interviewed Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford and discussed the team’s situation in goal. Despite employing Matt Murray, who won back-to-back Stanley Cups with the team as their starter in 2016 and 2017, it was fellow 25-year-old Tristan Jarry who took the ball and ran with it for the Penguins this season. Jarry even represented the Penguins at this season’s All-Star competition.

Pittsburgh Penguins Matt Murray
Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Matt Murray (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)

With both goalies needing a new contract at season’s end, the Penguins could find themselves in a financial bind as the salary cap looks to remain flat heading into next season. This is a similar situation to the one that led to the Penguins moving long-time starter Marc-Andre Fleury to the Vegas Golden Knights and keeping the younger (and cheaper) Murray.

Related: Detroit Red Wings – A Tribute to Nicklas Lidstrom

“I’d have loved to have kept them both. Both great goaltenders, both championship goaltenders,” Rutherford told Yohe. “But with Marc-Andre’s cap number, it was just too hard to do without disrupting the rest of the team. And we may be in that place again. The cap isn’t going up. No way is that happening. But we don’t know precisely what it will be. And we know we have very good goalies in our system. So, we have to make some tough decisions coming up.” (From “Jim Rutherford Says Trading One of His Goaltenders Might Be Inevitable” The AthleticNHL – 5/5/20)

Enter the Red Wings

It is incredibly rare that a goalie has two Stanley Cup championships to their name by the time they’re 22 years old. In the case of Murray, he was technically classified as a rookie for both seasons due to the games-played threshold for rookies, a very unique feat that may never be repeated. With just 199 games to his credit, he has built an impressive résumé in a short amount of time.

There’s no doubt that Murray will be the more costly option for the Penguins. He is the one they will be looking to move on from in an attempt to cut costs. Luckily for them, the Red Wings look poised to have plenty of cap space this offseason, as well as a need at the position.

Matt Murray Pittsburgh Penguins
Matt Murray, Pittsburgh Penguins (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

The cost is key here. Given that trading Murray is a near-necessity for the Penguins, they literally can’t afford to be too picky with what they can get in return for him. That’s not to say that they’ll give him away for anything though. Given that they build their team around a juiced-up top six and then cheap depth with upside, they could target guys like Taro Hirose and/or Evgeny Svechnikov from the Red Wings.

Pros and Cons

For the Red Wings, the idea of dealing future assets can leave a bit of a bitter taste in fans’ mouths. After all, the team should be hoarding prospects and picks, hoping that a few of them become something notable for the team’s future. It would be incredibly painful to see anybody the team deals for Murray reach their potential with another team — especially the last team to deny them another Stanley Cup championship.

Murray has also seen his performance slip due, in part to an array of injuries. Thus, his maximum games-played total is a meager 50 games. In fact, Murray missed the first two rounds of the team’s 2017 Stanley Cup run due to injury. There are legitimate worries that he could be too fragile to rely on as a de facto number one goalie.

Related: 5 Best NHL Backups

On the other hand, Murray would give the Red Wings something they currently do not have: an NHL-caliber goalie under the age of 30. With none of the team’s goaltending prospects knocking on the door quite yet, the team could use a young face to carry the load for a few years, with the potential for many more years beyond that. Not to mention, Murray would also bring championship experience to a team that suddenly lacks it.

Steve Yzerman, Christopher Ilitch
Steve Yzerman and Christopher Ilitch, president and CEO of Ilitch Holdings, Inc. after Yzerman is introduced as the new executive vice president and general manager of the Detroit Red Wings. (AP Photo/Carlos Osorio)

Yzerman spent all of the 2019-20 season making deals to acquire players that had the potential to grow into a prominent role with the Red Wings. It was that mentality that saw the team acquire winger Robby Fabbri from the St. Louis Blues, and he quickly found a home in the team’s top six. Murray may have fallen out of favor with the Penguins, but he could find a home with the Red Wings and become the rock the team can lean on in the crease.

Fortune Favors the Bold

It would be easy for Yzerman to simply sign a guy like Cam Talbot to a short-term deal in the offseason, acknowledging that the team is still a while away from making waves in the league. In a perfect world, the team would have a prospect that seemed a year away from challenging for an NHL spot and a guy like Talbot could bridge that gap. Unfortunately, due to Filip Larsson’s struggles in the AHL this season, the Red Wings don’t live in a perfect world.

Instead, Yzerman should pursue an option that has the potential to be more than just a stop-gap. He already tried to do just that this season when he acquired Eric Comrie from the Arizona Coyotes for a defensive prospect. Unfortunately, the Comrie experiment didn’t work out for the Red Wings, but it shows that Yzerman realizes the shortcomings of the team’s depth chart in net.

If Yzerman can work out a fair deal, adding an NHL-proven goalie like Murray would do wonders for the team in the present, and potentially into the future. It’s not everyday that a young, two-time Stanley Cup champion becomes available and he perfectly fills a hole on your team. It would be a bold move, and that’s pretty much Yzerman’s M.O.