The Oilers Want a Better Goalie, But Who?

It’s becoming abundantly clear that any of Ben Scrivens, Viktor Fasth and Richard Bachman aren’t cutting the mustard in Edmonton. Goaltending has long been in an issue in this market. The Oilers just can’t seem to find a viable netminder, one of the most crucial and important positions in the game. Granted, the defence that the Oilers trot out on a game to game basis could probably make Patrick Roy or Dominik Hasek look ordinary, but none-the-less, there’s still a problem.

(Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports)
(Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports)

“We Gave Away Devan Dubnyk!”

I am thrilled to see the success that Devan Dubnyk is having in Minnesota. A guy whos’ career looked dead just a few months ago is now playing his way into the Hart trophy conversation. (No, he isn’t going to win). The old cliche about a change of scenery couldn’t be more true in the case of Dubnyk. But make no mistake, Oilers fans. He wouldn’t be playing this way if he were still in Edmonton. Too many nights of getting hung out to dry, too much of his confidence thrown out the window, too much inconsistency to gain the trust of anyone in the organization.

It doesn’t matter how good he’s been with the Wild. His tenure with the Oilers needed to end. He had to go somewhere else to find his game again. Now, having said that, I really don’t think anyone predicted he would find so good of a game, but here we are. He bounced around a bit before landing in Minnesota, and maybe the realization that he could be on the outside looking in if he didn’t play better sparked something. Maybe it was the goalie coach in Arizona. Maybe it was just a few tweaks to his positioning. Or maybe the Wild just have a better defensive structure. Could be any or all of those things.

Will Dubnyk’s incredible run last? Based on his history, it feels as though this is an anomaly and not the norm. But, for his sake, I really hope he can continue this play. He’s a great story, and it’s fun to watch. The Wild were dead in the water until he came to town. If they make the playoffs, that’s just incredible stuff. Obviously, some Oilers fans wish he could have been their hero. They lament why he couldn’t play like this in Edmonton. But like I said, he wouldn’t have played this way in Edmonton. He needed to move on. Both sides did.

Are There Any Other Options Out There?

You look at the Oilers record, you look at how they’re playing, and it’s easy to say “get a new goalie”. But the reality is, who are they going to get? Elite goaltenders don’t just become available, and if they do, they maybe aren’t as elite as people think. But then you look at a guy like Jaroslav Halak, who was expendable to both the Canadiens and the Blues, and now he’s leading the Islanders to challenge for a division title. Yes, it’s possible to get a real gem in a trade, but it’s the exception, not the rule.

(Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports)
(Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports)

In terms of free agent goalies, it is really slim pickings. Antii Niemi is the only household name out there. Yes, he’s a Stanley Cup champion, but he has regressed since that championship. Karri Ramo, Jonas Enroth and Michael Neuvirth could also be had in the offseason, but are any of those guys really upgrades? In terms of free agency, I don’t see how anyone is decidedly better than what the Oilers have now. That doesn’t mean they don’t take a shot at one of these guys on a short term deal. It could certainly pay off.

In terms of trades, are there any goalies they could deal for? A guy who’s name has bounced around is Jonathan Bernier of the Toronto Maple Leafs. The Leafs are another example of a team that makes goalies look bad. Bernier has had his brilliant moments, but he’s also had tough times. He would likely be an expensive trade target, and the Oilers don’t have a ton of move-able assets at this point.

I’d take a look at Ottawa as well, since the emergence of Andrew Hammond is creating a log-jam in the crease. What if Robin Lehner became available in the offseason? Is he better than what the Oilers have now? And what about if a team like Carolina wants to shake things up and move Cam Ward? Maybe Boston would unload Malcolm Subban for the right price. All these things are speculation, but here’s the problem. If you’re going to trade for a goalie, you have to give something up, and many of the guys I mentioned aren’t really battle-tested.

It’s a risk anyway you slice it, and there may not be any real payoff. It’s a difficult situation for the Oilers right now, especially since they have so many other problems to address. If they do make a trade or sign a free agent, is that guy going to be the savior, or will the Oilers defence claim yet another goaltending victim? Stay tuned.

3 thoughts on “The Oilers Want a Better Goalie, But Who?”

  1. Dubnyk stopped giving a shit in Edmonton. His career was on a fast track to Europe. His value was at an all-time low. He definitely possessed the tools to be an NHL goaltender, but we ended up with a situation where it wasn’t going to be for Edmonton, and Edmonton had to try and get something for this asset.

  2. I’ll have to disagree with the overabundance of flowery things to say about Dubnyk. He was given every opportunity to succeed as a starter with the Oilers. He was drafted in 2004 and despite the criticism directed at Oilers’ management for rushing some of their prospects (which isn’t unfounded at all), the organization brought him along slowly. Guys like Deslauriers and Khabibulin were front and centre before him, but it’s not like Dubnyk was every tossed into a role after one or two years of development in the ECHL or AHL.

    Dubnyk’s time with the Oilers was full of inconsistency. When he was given the chance to “run with the ball” as starter when Khabibulin went down to injury, he performed well at first and then his play became wildly erratic. At the start of the 2011-2012 season, Dubnyk was the undisputed starter for the beginning of the season, but quickly lost that role back to Khabibulin. The latter faltered and Dubnyk came in again. In 2012-2013, he once again was given the opportunity as being named the starter out of camp, but lost the job to Bryzgalov. This happened during the entire tenure of his career with the Oilers – on several occasions, he had the trust of the coaching/management staff to excel and each time, he “dropped the ball”, leaving management to sign guys like Bryzgalov or Bachman.

    I think it’s somewhat of a good redemption story for Dubnyk first in Arizona and now in Minnesota, but he is NOT the answer if a team is seriously looking for a proven, dependable starter. Good goalies don’t bounce around the league for a long time and then “suddenly” become starters. Don’t forget that Dubnyk couldn’t find a role with the Preds or Habs and while both clubs obviously have elite goaltenders, it’s tough to imagine how Carter Hutton or Marek Maraznec now have the back-up positions behind Rinne, especially if Dubnyk is as good as people make him out to be. The Wild will likely make the playoffs as a lower-seed, but if they go up against a team like the Preds or Blackhawks in the first round, they’ll be ousted pretty quick. Every so often a goalie will have an extended, impressive run and they’ll be hyped up quite a bit. Andrew Hammond with the Sens is having a good start to his pro career, but it’s VERY unlikely that he’ll trump Anderson or Lehner in the future for Ottawa and he’ll probably be demoted soon.

  3. I believe that between the GM throwing him under the bus within moments of getting appointed, and a goalie coach (Chabot) who left a string of goalie corpses behind when he was finally canned, that the Oil simply broke Dubnyk. It took decent coaching to help him find his game. It could have been here, but of course, Oilers.

Comments are closed.