Masters of Disaster: The Worst Trade Deadline GMs Ever

Another Trade Deadline has come and gone, its significance not to be fully comprehended for many years to come.

However, while most everybody remembers the particulars from the most infamous Deadline deals, your Matteau/Amontes, few recall the general managers, the traders who jockeyed with each other in the pit.

The better GMs live to fight another Deadline; the worst ones usually weed themselves out quickly. Occasionally, however, an especially incompetent trader lasts long enough to create a true corpse of work.

When it comes to trades, you win some, you lose some. Here are the men who pretty much lost them all.

The worst Trade Deadline GMs ever.

Here’s the fine print: To decide the “winners,” I looked for trades within weeks of that season’s Trade Deadline. Offically, the NHL Trade Deadline began in 1979-80, so that’s where we start:

Dishonorable Mention Ron Caron was St. Louis Blues GM from 1983-94 and 1996-97.

Worst Deadline Deals:

  • Date:  February 1, 1986

St. Louis Blues get: Eddy Beers, Charles Bourgeois, Gino Cavallini
Calgary Flames get: Terry Johnson, Joe Mullen, Rik Wilson

  • March 5, 1991

St. Louis Blues: Garth Butcher, Dan Quinn
Vancouver Canucks: Geoff Courtnall, Robert Dirk, Sergio Momesso, Cliff Ronning, 1992 5th round pick (#110 Brian Loney)

  • February 7, 1992

St. Louis Blues: Craig Janney, Stephane Quintal
Boston Bruins: Adam Oates

  • March 21, 1994

St. Louis Blues: Craig Janney
Vancouver Canucks: Jeff Brown, Bret Hedican, Nathan Lafayette

Perhaps the mercurial Caron was a Canadian double agent? “When he shipped players like Joey Mullen, Doug Gilmour, Rick Wamsley and Rob Ramage to Calgary, Caron was accused of running a Flames’ farm club and helping mould their Stanley Cup champion team.” He also placed a third of the regulars (Brown, Hedican, Lafayette, Courtnall, Momesso, Ronning) on the 1993-94 Vancouver Canucks Stanley Cup Finalist.

And what did the Blues bring back? Scorer Eddy Beers, whose career was cut short by back injury. A couple seasons from veteran physical defender Garth Butcher. And Craig Janney. Twice. All adding up to one fluke Conference Finals appearance during Caron’s stewardship.

Caron’s Trade Deadline record is redeemed solely by stealing Brett Hull from the Flames in 1988.

Key Stats:

Ron Caron Doin' Work

Ron Caron Doin’ Work

George Maguire was Los Angeles Kings GM from 1977-84.

Worst Deadline Deals:

  • March 10, 1980

Los Angeles Kings: Bill Harris, Dave Lewis
New York Islanders: Butch Goring

  • March 10, 1980

Los Angeles Kings: Jerry Korab
Buffalo Sabres: 1982 1st round pick (#6 Phil Housley)

  • March 10, 1981

Los Angeles Kings: Rick Martin
Buffalo Sabres: 1981 3rd round pick (#60 Colin Chisholm), 1983 1st round pick (#5 Tom Barrasso)

It was the deal that “may have started the deadline craze 34 years ago.” The proof that such buzzer-beater swaps could indeed propel your squad to glory. Or more exactly, in the case of Butch Goring and the New York Islanders, four consecutive Stanley Cups.

But this article isn’t about winners. It’s about George Maguire.

For this valuable final puzzle piece of New York’s dynasty, the Kings received steady defenseman Dave Lewis, who captained the team for two years, and Billy Harris, a strong, two-way winger who managed parts of three non-descript seasons in Forum blue and gold. Nevertheless, it’s not as if Goring was going to win anything in LA.

The Deadline deals that cement Maguire’s well-deserved reputation as being one of the worst general managers in NHL history was the chucking of future first-round picks for washed-up veterans. Four games from Rick Martin before he retired? A couple decent seasons from then-31-year-old defender Jerry Korab? Can you imagine how HFBoards 1980 would have coped with these exchanges?

Even the once-brilliant Martin couldn’t figure out why Los Angeles gave up so much for him and his bum knee. “No 29-year-old player is worth a first-round pick for one of the top three players (in the draft)…I didn’t think it was a good deal when L.A. gave up that kind of draft choice.”

Of course, knowing Maguire, instead of a Phil Housley or Tom Barrasso, the Kings would’ve drafted Bryan Trottier’s brother Rocky.

Key Stats:

George Maguire Doin' Work

George Maguire Doin’ Work

Don Waddell was Atlanta Thrashers GM from 1999-2010.

Worst Deadline Deals:

  • February 24, 2007

Atlanta Thrashers: Alexei Zhitnik
Philadelphia Flyers: Braydon Coburn

  • February 25, 2007

Atlanta Thrashers: Keith Tkachuk
St. Louis Blues: Glen Metropolit, 2007 1st round pick (#24 Mikael Backlund), 2007 3rd round pick (#85 Brett Sonne), 2008 2nd round pick (#33 Philip McRae)

  • February 26, 2008

Atlanta Thrashers: Colby Armstrong, Erik Christensen, Angelo Esposito, 2008 1st round pick (#29 Daultan Leveille)
Pittsburgh Penguins: Marian Hossa, Pascal Dupuis

  • February 4, 2010

Atlanta Thrashers: Niclas Bergfors, Patrice Cormier, Johnny Oduya, 2010 1st round pick (#24 Kevin Hayes), 2010 2nd round pick (#54 Justin Holl)
New Jersey Devils: Ilya Kovalchuk, Anssi Salmela, 2010 2nd round pick (#38 Jonathon Merrill)

  • February 9, 2010

Atlanta Thrashers: Ivan Vishnevskiy, 2010 4th round pick (#101 Ivan Telegin)
Dallas Stars: Kari Lehtonen

Aside from ownership issues, Don Waddell is the main reason why hockey failed in Atlanta. Given over a decade to build a winner that might excite a city which was historically cool to hockey, this master of asset mismanagement failed over and over again. Consider the Trade Deadline his favorite canvas.

While ultimately short-sighted Deadline moves to snap up vets like Alexei Zhitnik and Keith Tkachuk for a playoff push are defensible, even if they resulted in a 2007 first-round playoff sweep, Waddell’s true “Ode to Inepitude” was what he pulled in return for the three stars of the franchise’s lone playoff appearance: Johnny Oduya.

The only player Atlanta plucked in respective deals for Marian Hossa, Ilya Kovalchuk, and Kari Lehtonen who’s still taking a regular NHL shift anywhere, Oduya played just parts of three seasons with Atlanta/Winnipeg before being tossed to the Chicago Blackhawks, where of course, he emerged as an integral part of 2013’s Cup winner.

And the now-Jets could sure use Lehtonen between the pipes over Ondrej Pavelec. Well, at least the oft-injured but supremely talented goalie eventually brought back Andrew Ladd (through Vishnevskiy). And no, Waddell did not make that deal.

Key Stats:

Don Waddell Doin' Work

Don Waddell Doin’ Work


Sheng Peng
Sheng Peng plants ideas like Wilt Chamberlain on Twitter and Google+. He covers the Los Angeles Kings for The Hockey Writers.
Sheng Peng
@jollywhiskey What's fainter than faint praise? #InvisiblePraise - 9 hours ago

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required Email Address * Name Email Format html text mobile