Anaheim DucksBoston BruinsBuffalo SabresCalgary FlamesCarolina HurricanesChicago BlackhawksColorado AvalancheColumbus Blue JacketsDallas StarsDetroit Red WingsEdmonton OilersFlorida PanthersLos Angeles KingsMinnesota WildMontreal CanadiensNashville PredatorsNew Jersey DevilsNew York IslandersNew York RangersOttawa SenatorsPhiladelphia FlyersPittsburgh PenguinsSan Jose SharksSeattle KrakenSt. Louis BluesTampa Bay LightningToronto Maple LeafsUtah Hockey ClubVancouver CanucksVegas Golden KnightsWashington CapitalsWinnipeg Jets

Red Wings Shouldn’t Turn Simon Edvinsson Into Another Larkin Saga

Simon Edvinsson has made his intentions clear. According to Sportsnet’s Frank Seravalli, the unsigned defenseman turned down chances to sign offer sheets with other teams because he didn’t want to give the Detroit Red Wings a chance to match them.

That leaves Detroit with a trade or a Dec. 1 deadline that could wipe out his season. Seravalli also floated a third path, one that would look very familiar to Red Wings fans. It is essentially the same arrangement the club already has with Dylan Larkin.

Why Simon Edvinsson Passed on Offer Sheets

The reasoning is simple. “He’d love to be signed and playing,” one source told Seravalli. “But he no longer wants to play in Detroit and that would be the risk with an offer sheet,” the source added in Sportsnet’s report on the offer sheets.

Simon Edvinsson Red Wings trade Larkin standoff
Detroit Red Wings defenseman Simon Edvinsson (Kyle Ross-Imagn Images)

History supports his concern. Seravalli noted that 10 of the 14 offer sheets signed in the salary cap era were matched, including the ones for Leo Carlsson and Barrett Hayton last summer. Signing one would likely have kept Edvinsson in Detroit, which is the one outcome he is trying to avoid.

The Workaround Seravalli Described

The deadline is fixed. Edvinsson needs a contract registered with the league before the 5 p.m. ET cutoff on Dec. 1 to play anywhere in the NHL this season, and Seravalli wrote that the trade return could weaken as that date gets closer.

His proposed alternative is unusual. If the deadline arrives without a trade, Detroit and Edvinsson “could theoretically agree on a one-year deal to be registered before the deadline to save his season,” then the club would “suspend him (without pay) until a trade can be executed.” No team or player has tried it, and Seravalli acknowledged that it “would require trust.”

On paper, it helps both sides. The player keeps his season alive, Detroit keeps its trade talks alive, and the suspension means the club wouldn’t pay him while he waits.

How the Plan Mirrors the Dylan Larkin Standoff

The Red Wings don’t have to imagine how that would work. They are living it with Larkin, who left the team in late October and has sat out on an unpaid suspension ever since.

The results haven’t been encouraging. TSN’s Chris Johnston said this week that “there is no end to this standoff in sight,” adding that there “does not seem to be any traction being made towards a trade with any of the teams on Larkin’s approved list,” according to TSN’s Early Trading segment. The former captain is also closing in on $1 million in forfeited salary, the Free Press reported.

The suspension has protected Detroit’s position, but it hasn’t produced a buyer. As we explained when we showed how Larkin’s original wish list fell apart, the market has narrowed rather than opened up while he has been away.

2 Suspended Players Would Leave Detroit Stuck

Using the workaround would put the Red Wings in a rare spot: two core players, both under contract, both suspended, both waiting for trades. That would stretch the front office thin at a time when interim general manager Shawn Horcoff is still trying to prove himself.

It would also send a message to the rest of the league. Teams already know Detroit is struggling, having lost six of its past seven games. Two suspended players would only reinforce the idea that the Red Wings are stuck.

There is a cap problem, too. Seravalli explained that a restricted free agent signed after the season starts carries a daily cap penalty in the first year. In his example, a seven-year, $10 million-per-year deal would carry a $13.21 million first-year cap hit if registered now and about $14.22 million on Dec. 1. “Not many teams could add a $14.2 million cap hit to their roster right now without surgery,” he wrote.

Why a Trade Before Dec. 1 Is Detroit’s Best Option

The workaround should be the last resort, not the plan. Seravalli wrote that “no team is going to trade prime assets for a player ineligible to play this season,” which is exactly why Detroit’s leverage is strongest now, while Edvinsson can still help a buyer this season.

The interest is there. Johnston reported strong interest from the Boston Bruins and San Jose Sharks, with the Toronto Maple Leafs watching from the background. Our Tony Wolak has also made the case that a trade is the likelier outcome for both sides.

The Red Wings have already learned what waiting looks like with Larkin. If a fair offer for Edvinsson is on the table before Dec. 1, they should take it rather than open a second front in the same kind of standoff.

Free Newsletter

Get Detroit Red Wings coverage delivered to your inbox

In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.

Subscribe Free →
Alexander Rosquez

Alexander Rosquez

Alexander Rosquez is a sports writer with over 10 years of experience covering major North American sports leagues. He currently covers the Detroit Red Wings for The Hockey Writers. A passionate hockey fan who also loves baseball, boxing and international soccer, he has previously contributed to outlets such as Bolavip US and Last Word On Sports.

More by Alexander Rosquez →