Blue Jackets’ Inexperienced Roster Not a Factor in Their Struggles

This season, the Columbus Blue Jackets were the eighth youngest team in the NHL with an average age of 26.34. They were also 27th in the league in games played, with only 7,637 combined games. Many have attributed the team’s struggles in 2020-21 to inexperience, but other teams with a similar lack of experience had a more successful season than Columbus.

Here’s a look at how the Blue Jackets compare to those other teams and why their lack of experience was not a factor in a disappointing season.

Blue Jackets vs. Other Inexperienced Teams

For comparison’s sake, I’ve referenced teams with an average age between 26.1 and 26.9 years: the Winnipeg Jets, Philadelphia Flyers, Vancouver Canucks, Carolina Hurricanes, and Florida Panthers.

Andrew Peeke Blue Jackets
With young players such as Andrew Peeke (pictured), the Blue Jackets roster is most comparable to the Winnipeg Jets, Philadelphia Flyers, Vancouver Canucks, Carolina Hurricanes, and Florida Panthers. (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

Per Elite Prospects, below is a chart that features all those teams’ average age, combined games played, the number of players over 30, and the result of their 2020-21 season (some seasons are still ongoing).

TeamAverage Age (In Years)Combined Games PlayedNumber of Players Over 302020-21 Season Result
Columbus Blue Jackets26.387,6738Finished 8th in the Central Division; missed postseason
Winnipeg Jets26.7610,7916Finished third in the North Division; currently in second round of the playoffs after defeating the Edmonton Oilers
Philadelphia Flyers26.688,3377Finished sixth in the East Division; missed postseason
Vancouver Canucks26.4310,4437Finished seventh (last in the North Division); missed postseason
Carolina Hurricanes26.398,7804Finished first in the Central Division; currently in the second round of the playoffs after defeating the Nashville Predators
Florida Panthers26.249,3236Finished in second place in the Central Division; defeated by the Tampa Bay Lightning in round one of the playoffs

According to the above, most teams with a similar level of experience had better seasons than the Blue Jackets; the Canucks are the only other team to finish last in their division.

Analysis

Of the six teams, three made the playoffs, and two are still competing for the Stanley Cup. The Jets are battling the Montreal Canadiens in the second round, and the Hurricanes are up against the Tampa Bay Lightning. The Lightning eliminated the Florida Panthers in the first round.

Latest Blue Jackets Content:

The two other teams that missed the playoffs, the Flyers and Canucks had better records than the Blue Jackets: Columbus finished with a record of 18-26-12 (48 points), the Flyers finished 25-23-8 (58 points), and the Canucks finished 23-29-4 (50 points).

The Blue Jackets may have had the youngest average age amongst these teams and the fewest combined games, but their veterans also balanced it out. Of all the teams, Columbus had the most players over 30, with eight in the 2020-21 campaign, the oldest being Nathan Gerbe at 33.

Nathan Gerbe Columbus Blue Jackets
Nathan Gerbe is the oldest player on Columbus at 33. (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

Oddly, the team closest to Columbus in experience, the Hurricanes, who have a very similar average age at .01 years older, didn’t have these struggles. Carolina finished first in the Central Division, and they are now in the second round of the 2021 Playoffs. It is also worth mentioning that the Hurricanes’ 8,780 combined games played could be the magic number. Every team below that mark missed the playoffs this season.

The Blue Jackets may have been among the youngest teams, but not so young that it would have increased their struggles compared to the other teams.

What’s to Blame for Their Struggles?

Yes, the Blue Jackets were inexperienced, but they had more veterans than the other teams mentioned above. Also, Columbus had a worse record than the teams below them in average age, and combined games played, besides the Buffalo Sabres and New Jersey Devils. This shows other issues were contributing to the team’s struggles.

Columbus’ 2020-21 season was not held back by their young lineup but rather the offseason and deadline trades, a lack of chemistry, consistent defensive struggles, injuries, and a lack of skill. Other teams have shown that a lack of experience is not always an issue. If Columbus can fix the problems mentioned above, they should be better next season despite their age.


Sign up for our regular 'Blue Jackets Newsletter' for all the latest.