Garth Snow: The NHL’s Most Underrated GM?

Honestly, we don’t care what league they come from — college, juniors, Europe. If they can play, they can play for us. Every player is unique.”

– Garth Snow, General Manager of the New York Islanders


It was the summer of 2006. Neil Smith had been the General Manager of the New York Islanders for 41 days before being relieved of his duties with the team. While Smith’s dismissal certainly shocked some Islanders fans, the hockey world was probably a bit perplexed when Charles B. Wang announced that Garth Snow would assume GM duties after Smith’s ouster from the position.

Despite the fact that Snow had no prior professional managerial experience, his Bachelor’s and Master’s experience in Administration lent some credence to the promotion of the ex-goalie to such a post. Transitioning to a new style of play in the post-lockout (2004-2005) era wouldn’t be an easy task for the New York Islanders or a new General Manager, but Snow quickly gained notoriety in hockey circles by making a 2007 NHL Trade Deadline splash by acquiring Ryan Smyth. Even though Smyth couldn’t help New York advance during the 2007 Stanley Cup Playoffs and ultimately left Long Island after his short stint with the Islanders, Snow’s introductory season saw him make a number of shrewd moves to better his team – a trend that would certainly be reinforced as the years passed by.

The Draft Strategy

John Tavares Captain
John Tavares was one of many draft picks that Garth Snow put stock into for the future. (Charles LeClaire/USA TODAY Sports)

After battling all the way until the last day of the 2006-2007 NHL season in order to secure a playoff berth, the New York Islanders were dispatched by the Buffalo Sabres in five games during the first round of the 2007 Stanley Cup Playoffs. While New York’s big ticket trade deadline acquisition (Smyth) chose to sign with the Colorado Avalanche during the 2007 offseason, Garth Snow decided to embark upon a journey that has only recently begun to shown some signs of fruition.

Starting in 2007, Snow decided to rebuild the Islanders through the NHL Entry Draft – a long and arduous task that could be daunting for any GM, much less one that was fairly new to the job like Snow. Regardless of any perceived lack of experience, Snow started to restock the Islanders’ pipeline and build a team from scratch.

Mike Milbury’s imprint on the Islanders was certainly felt when Snow assumed GM duties for New York as there was a dearth of viable prospects remaining in the franchise’s farm system. While Milbury did leave Snow with very few prospects in the Islanders’ pipeline, he also left the team with an image that carried over into the Snow era. Not only was Snow forced to figure out how to manage New York’s youth movement, he often received labels that didn’t apply to him as some hockey fans wrongly attributed moves such as Rick DiPietro’s contract signing to Snow’s earliest doings as an NHL GM.

Young players and future draft picks didn’t have much of a shelf life under Milbury, but Snow’s tenure brought about a new form of business – one that would eventually see the Islanders build up one of the most formidable prospect systems in the NHL.

The 2007 NHL Entry Draft didn’t produce many players that became everyday fixtures in the Isles’ lineup, but there surely was a plethora of drafting success to be had in future drafts. In particular, the 2008 NHL Entry Draft saw the Islanders make thirteen selections. Out of those thirteen selections, Matt Martin, Travis Hamonic, and Josh Bailey have had a significant impact at the NHL level for New York while Kevin Poulin, Aaron Ness, Matt Donovan, and Kirill Petrov continue to be held in high regards as they develop overseas or in the Isles’ farm system.

While the Islanders undoubtedly stocked up on talent during the 2008 NHL Draft (courtesy of Garth Snow’s maneuvering through trades), the organization’s subsequent drafts only saw the team stockpile more promising players for the future. Picks such as John Tavares and Ryan Strome were viewed as obvious no-brainers, but selecting the likes of Calvin de Haan, Anders Nilsson, Casey Cizikas, Anders Lee, Nino Niederreiter, and Kirill Kabanov in between the Tavares and Strome selections has been the key to New York’s rejuvenated youth movement.

The 2011, 2012, and 2013 NHL Entry Drafts were certainly no different for Garth Snow and the Islanders as the franchise managed to pick a number of promising defensemen (Mayfield, Pedan, Reinhart, Pokka, Pelech, & Pulock) and forwards (Sundstrom, Persson, & Strome) over the last three summers. Of course, it will undoubtedly take a while to see which of the aforementioned picks pans out for New York in the long run, but there is definitely enough reason for optimism as more and more Islanders draft picks are showing signs of progress and maturation. Rebuilding through the draft has been Garth Snow’s agenda since Richard Zednik, Ryan Smyth, and Jason Blake jettisoned from Long Island, and after six years the fruits of Snow’s labor are finally beginning to show.

Playing the Waiver Wire

Michael Grabner, Andrew MacDonald, and Colin McDonald illustrate Garth Snow's moves perfectly as they are the perfect mix of waiver-wire pick-ups, low-risk free agent signings, and home grown talent that have worked out very well for New York. (Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports)
Michael Grabner, Andrew MacDonald, and Colin McDonald illustrate Garth Snow’s moves perfectly as they are the perfect mix of waiver-wire pick-ups, low-risk free agent signings, and home grown talent that have worked out very well for New York. (Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports)

To many NHL GMs, filling out parts of a professional hockey lineup by plucking players off of the waiver wire might not seem like a very appealing option. For Garth Snow and Islanders fans, the waiver-wire has been a splendid choice that has yielded quite some favorable results for the franchise.

Players such as Thomas Hickey, Michael Grabner, Evgeni Nabokov, Keith Aucoin, and Brian Strait have all played important roles with the Islanders in some capacity. While Hickey and Aucoin could be viewed as depth players at their respective positions, Grabner and Nabokov have become integral parts of the Isles’ everyday lineup, and Brian Strait has certainly rounded out New York’s defensive units.

As previously mentioned, the waiver wire might not be a GM’s first choice when building up a contender, but Snow has found a few gems that have fit perfectly into the Isles’ current plans. Not only has Snow found a number of steals through the waiver wire, he has locked up these players (Hickey, Nabokov, Strait, & Grabner) to very responsible and manageable deals – something that is hard to say for other teams around the NHL that are handing out long-term big money contracts to free agents. Despite that many have looked down upon Snow’s waiver-wire dealings, the GM has certainly proved, as cliche as it may sound, that one man’s trash can be another man’s treasure.

Shrewd Trades

Over the years, Garth Snow has not only picked the waiver-wire and the NHL Draft for some gems, he has also had success when it comes to trading and handing out contracts. Snow might not have had the best trade chips available, but he has certainly made do with the resources at his disposal.

Starting in 2007, Snow swung a few deadline deals that netted him Marc-Andre Bergeron, Richard Zednik, and Ryan Smyth. While such dealings did cost draft picks, Snow’s deadline acquisitions helped the Islanders make the 2007 Stanley Cup Playoffs and even helped the GM garner “Executive of the Year” honors for the 2006-2007 hockey season. Despite the fact that Snow hasn’t swung any deals for superstars since trading for Smyth, his track record in the trade market has been quite impressive.

During the next three seasons (2007-2010), Snow chose not to dabble in any blockbuster deadline deals, but he did move around some picks in order to better position the Islanders in the NHL Draft from 2008-2010. Dealing away players such as Chris Campoli, Mike Comrie, and Andy Sutton might not have been regarded as important moves being made by Snow, but they provided the Islanders with better positioning in future drafts.

Much the same can be said about the GM’s moves from 2010 onward as Snow improved his draft positioning through trades and even managed to get a better return for James Wisniewski when he dealt him away in late 2010. While fan favorites such as Dwayne Roloson were also moved during the 2010-2011 NHL season, Snow displayed an ability to accurately gauge a player’s value – especially if a player seemed likely to want or make an exit from Long Island.

Savvy Deals

Playing the waiver wire and drafting top talent through the NHL Draft has been a strong suit for Garth Snow, but New York’s GM has also locked up his core talent to very responsible deals. If one takes a look around the NHL and the trends that have been occurring in regards to some long-term contracts being handed out, then it might become apparent that some teams are investing big money and years into high profile free agents. This is not to say that some long-term contracts have not been well deserved by some players, but in days of lavish spending it is sometimes harder to find a General Manager that will commit himself to the utmost fiscal responsibility.

Aside from locking up newcomers such as Brian Strait and Colin McDonald to manageable deals, Snow has also locked up his core players to solid deals that fall right within the team’s finances at the moment.

Player Contract Length Contract Value Yearly Cap Hit
John Tavares Six Years $33 Million $5.5 Million
Travis Hamonic Seven Years $27 Million $3,857,143 Million
Josh Bailey Five Years $16.5 Million $3.3 Million
Frans Nielsen Four Years $11 Million $2.75 Million
Michael Grabner Five Years $15 Million $3 Million
Kyle Okposo Five Years $14 Million $2.8 Million

Islanders fans have certainly been aware of the fact that Charles Wang has been bleeding money since taking over as owner of the hockey franchise, so it is all the more impressive to see Snow keep his core players intact while remaining inside of his budgetary limits. Of course, if a free agent was available at a reasonable price, then there is no reason to think that Snow wouldn’t pursue that player. However, if New York’s GM has shown hockey fans anything over the last several years, then he has displayed a patient approach to committing to multi-year contracts on certain players.

Mark Streit certainly gave the Islanders his all during his tenure with the team, but the free agent’s desire for one last NHL contract proved to be too steep of a price to pay for an aging defenseman. Considering the fact that Snow initially signed Streit to a very friendly five-year contract ($20.5 Million) in 2008-2009, it would be unfair to expect the GM to break bank and match a contract offer such as the one given out by the Flyers (Four Years at $21 Million) – especially since he had already signed Lubomir Visnovsky to a two-year deal worth $9.5 Million.

Not only has Snow shown a willingness to keep his young players around, he has given them a fair reward when it is properly due. The New York Islanders have begun to show many signs of improvement as a collective unit, and it wouldn’t be a surprise to see the same core members of this team rewarded in the near future if they keep on consistently improving.

Garth Snow – The Right Guy For The Job

Garth Snow and Charles Wang have taken the Islanders through a slow and steady rebuilding process over the last several years.
Garth Snow and Charles Wang have taken the Islanders through a slow and steady rebuilding process over the last several years.

Many hockey fans and analysts might still have their respective opinions of Garth Snow, but I believe that the GM has done the most that he can do with the Islanders, and then some. After taking over a team with little to no assets in the pipeline, Snow has slowly built up a team that is showing signs of maturation and growth. Nobody said that the rebuild would be easy for the franchise or its fans, but then again when are rebuilds ever easy for a team and its fan-base?

Instead of mortgaging the future and making a trade for a high profile player, Snow has stuck to his guns and has let his young players develop as a group. The core players that comprise the New York Islanders have been signed and re-signed for a reason. Of course, it could be easier to spend money and bring in players, but Snow has opted to take a route that will see his core players share the ups and downs of NHL life as a group. Nobody can predict how well some players will grow and play together, but there is no doubting the fact that Snow is trying to build a product from the ground up.

Over the years, Garth Snow has received a good amount of criticism from hockey fans for a number of reasons. While fans will still make their jokes and critiques, one could look at New York’s situation through a “ten-year” lens and start to see a positive reversal of trends. Mike Milbury brought in high profile players to Long Island, but some of those moves were done at the expense of New York’s future. Not only has Garth Snow reversed the trend of trading away young and promising players, he has managed to identify and undertake a number of low-risk moves that have paid off their dividends for the franchise.

As previously stated, pushing forth with a full-scale rebuild is usually a lengthy task, but it has been one that Snow has dedicated himself to to the fullest degree. Value deals, waiver-wire transactions, and developing draft picks might not have been the ideal scenario for Islanders fans in 2006, but the fruits of Garth Snow’s labor are finally starting to show. With the Islanders set to move to the Barclays Center in the very near future, there is no telling what kind of opportunities will be presented to the team with an influx of new marketing opportunities and fans. One thing is for certain though, the New York Islanders’ prospects as a team are looking as bright as they ever have, and Garth Snow should certainly be given credit where credit is due.

12 thoughts on “Garth Snow: The NHL’s Most Underrated GM?”

  1. Great article. Agree with all of your points. Garth gets bashed for letting PAP walk in UFA instead of trading him at the deadline, but other than that, his resume is packed with shrewd and savvy moves. At least now, with the team on the rise and the move to Brooklyn, his job may get a little easier, as players around the league will want to play here with one of the league’s best in Tavares.

  2. Great article. It is about time that Garth got some credit.
    Thanks for writing something that I have wanted to scream out loud for a very long time.
    He is one of the best GMs in the league.

  3. The Islanders have had the best GM in the history of the NHL, Bill Torrey, as well as the worst, Mike Milbury. While Snow may be underrated, I hope he is closer to Torrey than to the unmitigated disaster who bloviates on NBC.

  4. I think it is about time Snow gets some credit. I am a Sharks fan and have been impressed with the way the Islanders are turning it around.

    There is one thing I wish they mentioned in this article and that is his way of talking/negotiating with players. I want to know what he said or did to Nabokov and Visnovsky to get them to stay. These were two players that initally refused to come to the team after waiver pickup/trade. Players that did not want to play for the Islanders and they both end up signing extensions (Nabokov has signed two now!). I think it’s amazing you can get players who pretty much wanted nothing to do with the Island, turn around in one season and sign on for more years.

    He is definietly underrated as a GM, but great story

    • It’s because Long Island is a great place to play, regardless o the jokes and dump arena comments. If you got $$$$ Long Island is one of the best places to live! Beaches, NYC close by, the Mountains of upstate a few hours away, great schools for the kids, NO BRAINER!

      • Oh btw, when the team is playing like last year, the Old Barn, aka “Madhouse off the Meadowbrook” is one of the LOUDEST buildings in the sport! Gonna enjoy the last two years, go out with a CUP! Drive for Five is back on!

    • I’m a native of the San Francisco Bay Area who has followed the Sharks off and on over the years, but I have been living on Long Island since 2010 and this year I decided to start following the Islanders. I don’t have the perspective of a long-time fan who has suffered through the Wang/Milbury/DiPietro years, but it was still a lot of fun watching the team blossom in 2013.

      It seems to me that Garth Snow has built a team that not only has a lot of young talent, but is also tight-knit. They’ve suffered through the bad years together, but now they are being rewarded with success. That’s why I had no problem trading Nino Niederreiter for Cal Clutterbuck. Sure, I don’t think it was Snow’s intention to draft Niederreiter using the fifth overall pick in the draft and essentially get a third liner in return, but Clutterbuck’s style is a good fit for the team, which no longer has to deal with any Niederreiter-related drama. Evgeni Nabokov at first balked at the idea of having to play for the hapless, cheap Islanders, but it seems like he’s learned they’re a pretty cool team to play for.

      I do think a six, seven, or eight seed will be the team’s ceiling in 2013-14, but I’m glad Snow hasn’t made any dealt any prospects (besides Niederreiter) to help the team win now. With Tavares, Hamonic, and Bailey locked up for a long time, they can build around that core. I think Ryan Strome is going to be a great addition to the team once he’s ready, either as a winger on the first line or maybe as a center on the second line.

    • I know that this might probably be buried in the comments section, but I wanted to thank each and every one of you for reading and commenting. B Mayer basically summed up everything that I was going to say about Snow being able to sign veterans such as Nabokov and Visnovsky – individuals who did not want to sign on and play with the Isles initially. Like Mayer said, Long Island is a great place to live if you have the money necessary to sustain yourself there. Not only is LI close to the city, it also offers a number of great schooling options and opportunities to live in a serene type of setting. I guess that Long Island, for some, is one of those places that has to grow on them before they start to like it. Maybe Nabokov and Visnovsky had their apprehensions about playing in Long Island, but they certainly weren’t the first players to change their mind about this part of NYS after acclimating to the team and the surrounding environment. I think that after playing with and seeing that the Islanders are dedicated to building a winner (as well as enjoying what Long Island has to offer), veterans such as Nabokov and Visnovsky became more open to re-signing in New York at a cost-effective price as both veterans could’ve explored other options if they didn’t feel as though the Isles were serious toward building a future contender. I feel that the Long Island environment, Snow’s ability to stick to a solid rebuilding plan, and a genuine hunger to win/succeed from the current on-ice product/players has forced otherwise apprehensive veterans to reconsider their initial stance on playing for the Islanders.

  5. Hands down the Most Underrated! With what he has had to work with in terms of the Cap, the Arena, Nassau’s Political BS and Wang’s Delusions, he is a PIMP!

    In Garth We Trust!


Comments are closed.