• HOME
  • NHL Teams
    • North Division
      • Calgary Flames
      • Edmonton Oilers
      • Montreal Canadiens
      • Ottawa Senators
      • Toronto Maple Leafs
      • Vancouver Canucks
      • Winnipeg Jets
    • East Division
      • Boston Bruins
      • Buffalo Sabres
      • New Jersey Devils
      • New York Islanders
      • New York Rangers
      • Philadelphia Flyers
      • Pittsburgh Penguins
      • Washington Capitals
    • Central Division
      • Carolina Hurricanes
      • Chicago Blackhawks
      • Columbus Blue Jackets
      • Dallas Stars
      • Detroit Red Wings
      • Florida Panthers
      • Nashville Predators
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
    • West Division
      • Anaheim Ducks
      • Arizona Coyotes
      • Colorado Avalanche
      • Los Angeles Kings
      • Minnesota Wild
      • San Jose Sharks
      • Seattle Kraken
      • St. Louis Blues
      • Vegas Golden Knights
  • Headlines
  • NHL Rumors
  • NHL Prospects
  • World Juniors
  • Archives
  • Podcast Network
  • More…
    • CHL
      • Ontario Hockey League
      • Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
      • Western Hockey League
    • Columns
    • Women’s Hockey
    • Other Leagues
    • NHL Entry Draft
    • Books
    • NHL History
  • Log in
The Hockey Writers
  • Site Index
  • NHL Salary Caps
  • Hockey 101: A Beginner’s Guide
  • Join Our Team
  • Free Newsletter
  • Store
  • Log in
The Hockey Writers
  • HOME
  • NHL Teams
    • North Division
      • Calgary Flames
      • Edmonton Oilers
      • Montreal Canadiens
      • Ottawa Senators
      • Toronto Maple Leafs
      • Vancouver Canucks
      • Winnipeg Jets
    • East Division
      • Boston Bruins
      • Buffalo Sabres
      • New Jersey Devils
      • New York Islanders
      • New York Rangers
      • Philadelphia Flyers
      • Pittsburgh Penguins
      • Washington Capitals
    • Central Division
      • Carolina Hurricanes
      • Chicago Blackhawks
      • Columbus Blue Jackets
      • Dallas Stars
      • Detroit Red Wings
      • Florida Panthers
      • Nashville Predators
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
    • West Division
      • Anaheim Ducks
      • Arizona Coyotes
      • Colorado Avalanche
      • Los Angeles Kings
      • Minnesota Wild
      • San Jose Sharks
      • Seattle Kraken
      • St. Louis Blues
      • Vegas Golden Knights
  • Headlines
  • NHL Rumors
  • NHL Prospects
  • World Juniors
  • Archives
  • Podcast Network
  • More…
    • CHL
      • Ontario Hockey League
      • Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
      • Western Hockey League
    • Columns
    • Women’s Hockey
    • Other Leagues
    • NHL Entry Draft
    • Books
    • NHL History
Home
Montreal Canadiens

Subban’s Success Meaningless for Canadiens

By Josh Boulton May 28th, 2017

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp

The majority of Montreal Canadiens fans have been leery/violently outraged since general manager Marc Bergevin traded P.K. Subban for Shea Weber last June. Subban is now going to be playing in his first Stanley Cup Final in his first season with a team other than the Canadiens. This is seen by many as hockey’s biggest “I told you so” in recent memory.

He’s tied for second on the Predators this postseason in points by a defenceman, only one point behind Ryan Ellis. He’s playing arguably his best defensive hockey. He seems to be fitting in quite nicely as a respected teammate as well. All signs point to Subban as the one that got away for Montreal. Or rather, the one Bergevin threw away.

http://gty.im/507649994

You can practically hear the tallies being furiously scratched into the win column on the Nashville side of the great trade debate with every new Predators playoff victory. This needs to stop. Immediately.

A Different Approach

You can compare these two players to each other all you want. Possession. Points. Power-play percentage. Corsi. Fenwick. Pre-game meals. Suit preference. Who cares? It’s like the world’s longest offside review, and it’s just as inconclusive. The reality is, Subban’s performance on any other team means nothing when grading the trade from a Canadiens perspective.

When trading Subban, Bergevin wasn’t trying to upgrade something he already had. It’s not like he swapped one goal scorer for another because his wasn’t scoring. He didn’t swap a goalie for another goalie because his wasn’t stopping the puck. He traded (in his opinion) a risky, offensive-minded defenceman with questionable decision-making skills, and in return picked up a larger, neutral-minded defenceman, who’s slightly more dependable.

Even though they play the same position, they have a completely different approach. For that reason alone it’s unfair to compare them. This doesn’t even count the fact that they played with completely different players playing completely different systems for completely different coaches.

Seizing the Moment

Subban is fitting right in with the Predators, but he’s also surrounded by several other younger, offensively capable defencemen, such as Ellis, Roman Josi and Mattias Ekholm. He doesn’t have to take as many chances, and in moments when he’s struggling, he can take a backseat and do basic things to get back on track.

P.K. Subban and Ryan Ellis (Jeff Curry-USA TODAY Sports)

This isn’t to say he’s got it easy. He’s an amazing talent who isn’t just getting by down in Nashville. He’s a solid presence, logging solid minutes and seizing the critical moments so far in these playoffs.

Again, though, none of this is even relevant to whether, for Montreal specifically, the Subban trade was a success or a failure. Did the St. Louis Blues, for example, lose the Nail Yakupov trade just because the Edmonton Oilers had a triumphant return to the playoffs? No. They lost because Yakupov performed so horribly at times that he was a healthy scratch. If Edmonton had stayed in the basement, would that have made the St. Louis fan base feel any better wasting a roster spot? No.

Nothing Else Matters

It’s the same with Montreal. Looking at it not as the Subban trade, but the Weber trade, is the team better today than it was yesterday? Yes or no? Nothing else matters. The answer to that question is obviously going to vary from fan to fan. In my opinion, the team isn’t any better or worse. It’s just different.

(Jean-Yves Ahern-USA TODAY Sports)

They’re now a little bigger. They’re now a little deeper on defence. Unfortunately, they still lack scoring and, ironically, they now lack that game-changing element Subban used to bring. I do believe Bergevin lost this trade, but he lost it way back when the season started and he did nothing to follow it up.

The First Cut Is the Deepest

I can see why he made the deal. I can see how it could have been a good first move in an overall master plan to help change the identity of the team. Taking away a marquee, one-of-a-kind, offensive defenceman and replacing him with several slightly above average ones is actually not a bad idea. It’s worked for the Pittsburgh Penguins for several years with Kris Letang in and out of the lineup.

It could have been one of the gutsiest, smartest moves of the year. The trouble is there weren’t enough offensive or creative additions up front to complement the move. Why it works for Pittsburgh is because they have the offensive depth to consistently take over the attack once the puck is out of the zone. Letang is just an unfair ace in the hole, like Subban should have been in Montreal. Just like Subban is in Nashville, actually.

(Kelvin Kuo-USA TODAY Sports)

The Grass Isn’t Always Greener

Bergevin did add Alexander Radulov as a great success story, and things may have been different had Alex Galchenyuk been a little more consistent, or if Max Pacioretty hadn’t disappeared in the playoffs. In general, though, there just wasn’t enough of a restructure to make trading away a talent like Subban worthwhile.

Having said that, it’s not like every Nashville win is just one more win the Canadiens would have had if they’d retained him. He’s done well in a new environment, and I applaud that. If he wins a Stanley Cup, I’ll be happy for him. As for grading the trade from the Montreal point of view, it won’t make any difference at all.

  • Tags
  • Alexander Radulov
  • P.K. Subban
  • Shea Weber
  • Top Story
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp

Get theScore App Now!
Recent Posts
Jan 21st 5:55 PM
Edmonton Oilers

McDavid Has the Maple Leafs’ Number and Needs to Keep it That Way

Jan 21st 5:08 PM
Archives

NHLers by Country: On Top of Their Game and the World

Jan 21st 4:50 PM
Edmonton Oilers

Oilers Missing Klefbom and Neal on Power Play

Jan 21st 4:40 PM
Minnesota Wild

Wild’s Soucy & Sturm Look Comfortable Filling Roster Gaps

Jan 21st 4:30 PM
Colorado Avalanche

Avalanche With Career Milestones in Sight in 2020-21 Season

Jan 21st 3:45 PM
Tampa Bay Lightning

The Lightning & Pat Maroon Are a Really Good Fit…For Now

Jan 21st 3:35 PM
Vegas Golden Knights

Golden Knights’ Depth Separates Them From the Rest

Jan 21st 3:15 PM
Columbus Blue Jackets

Blue Jackets’ Alexandre Texier, New Faces Shine to Begin Season

Jan 21st 2:45 PM
Edmonton Oilers

Oilers News & Rumors: Neal, Yamamoto, Tippett, More

Jan 21st 2:15 PM
Column

Senators News & Rumours: Stützle, Norris, Galchenyuk and More

Editor’s Picks
NHL TV Blackouts & Why They Happen?

NHL TV Blackouts & Why They Happen?

The 1979 NHL – WHA Merger

The 1979 NHL – WHA Merger

Masthead

Newsletters

RSS Feeds

Privacy Statement

Contact Us

About THW…

Founded in 2009, The Hockey Writers is a premier destination for news and information on everything hockey. Updated daily with news and features from over 130 writers worldwide. Over 2 million monthly readers now come to THW for their hockey fix.

© The Hockey Writers 2020. All rights reserved.
logo
  • HOME
  • Hockey Headlines
  • NHL Rumors
  • North Division
    • Calgary Flames
    • Edmonton Oilers
    • Montreal Canadiens
    • Ottawa Senators
    • Toronto Maple Leafs
    • Vancouver Canucks
    • Winnipeg Jets
  • East Division
    • Boston Bruins
    • Buffalo Sabres
    • New Jersey Devils
    • New York Islanders
    • New York Rangers
    • Philadelphia Flyers
    • Pittsburgh Penguins
    • Washington Capitals
  • Central Division
    • Carolina Hurricanes
    • Chicago Blackhawks
    • Columbus Blue Jackets
    • Dallas Stars
    • Detroit Red Wings
    • Florida Panthers
    • Nashville Predators
    • Tampa Bay Lightning
  • West Division
    • Anaheim Ducks
    • Arizona Coyotes
    • Colorado Avalanche
    • Los Angeles Kings
    • Minnesota Wild
    • San Jose Sharks
    • Seattle Kraken
    • St Louis Blues
    • Vegas Golden Knights
  • World Juniors
  • CHL
    • Ontario Hockey League
    • Quebec Major Junior Hockey League
    • Western Hockey League
  • THW Podcast Network
  • Store
  • FREE Newsletter
  • Search THW
  • More…
    • Join Our Team
    • The THW Archives
    • Prospects
    • The Goalie Page
    • NHL Salary Cap Information