Why Paul Holmgren Doesn’t Deserve To Lose His Job

(Ed Mulholland-USA TODAY Sports)

(Ed Mulholland-USA TODAY Sports)

The NHL is very much a “what-have-you-done-for-me-lately” type of league.

After going 0-3 to start the year, the Philadelphia Flyers canned coach Peter Laviolette.  Many fans wondered why Paul Holmgren didn’t join him.  Not only did Holmgren not get let go, Peter Luukko gave him a vote of confidence as Flyers fans watched in bewilderment.

I’ll be frank with you.  I wanted Paul Holmgren fired last season when the team was down in the dumps.  I’ve been adamant about him being replaced for some time now.  The team is atrocious – there is no denying that.  The team is selling out every game, the fans pay good money, and in return they are watching their beloved franchise slowly harken back to the dreaded 2006-07 season.

However, the more I look at things from an overall perspective, I don’t think Homer should receive his pink slip just yet.  Here’s why:

Tenure

If you take a look at what this team has accomplished under Paul Holmgren as Flyers general manager, you’ll notice he’s been quite successful – believe it or not.  He took over in 2007 when the team was going through it’s worst season in its 40-year history.  The following year, Holmgren shuffled the roster a bit and the team ended up making the Eastern Conference Finals.

Fastforward to 2010 when the Flyers were within one game of winning the Stanley Cup Finals after making it into the postseason.  Not including 2006-07, Homer’s Flyers have missed the playoffs only once (2012-13).  In a seven year span, that’s far from terrible.

Patience is a virtue

One thing I’ve always commended Paul Holmgren on is his ability to not make irrational decisions in the heat of the moment.  In 2010, when both Ray Emery and Brian Boucher went down with injuries, fans freaked.  Homer bided his time, didn’t make any rash moves, and looked to see what Leighton could do.

We all know what happens next, but if you would’ve told me that Michael Leighton could get the Flyers to Game 6 of the Stanley Cup Finals I would’ve thought you were drunk…and that’s exactly what happened.

In last year’s shortened, the team began to flounder, but once again Holmgren was cool, calm, and collective.  Although the Flyers didn’t make the playoffs, they ended the year on one of the best runs of any team and were within six points of the postseason.  Had the season stretched out to a full 82 games, chances are the Flyers would be in the mix for a playoff spot.

If you are expecting the Flyers to make a big trade or two in the coming weeks, you may want to think again.  Homer’s not one to jump the gun.

Trades

holmgrenLavyDo GM’s get raked over the coals in some trades?  Sure.  It’s the nature of the business.  You can’t win every trade you make.  Paul Holmgren has had quite a few questionable – the Versteeg trade, the Eminger trade, the Bobrovsky trade.

But he has pulled a rabbit out of his hat on more than one occasion.  Homer was able to get Chris Pronger, who ended up being the team’s sole leader before going down with an unforeseen injury that would later knock him out of the NHL for good.  Be that as it may, the time he spent in the Orange and Black did wonders for this franchise.

Somehow, Homer was able to flip a 1st round pick to the Nashville Predators for both Scott Hartnell and Kimmo Timonen.  Both are slumping currently, but they were catalysts for a team in need of a jolt for the past six years.  Lest we forget the impact they had early in their Flyers’ careers.

Holmgren outright stole Braydon Coburn from the Atlanta Thrashers in a deal where he traded Alexei Zhitnik.  That would be the first of many boneheaded trades Don Waddell would make before the Thrashers would eventually fold.

The trade that probably goes most unnoticed was a deal Homer made with the Detroit Red Wings.  Prior to the 2010 trade deadline, the Flyers dealt Ole-Kristian Tollefsen and a 5th-round pick to Detroit for Ville Leino.  Leino didn’t click in Philadelphia immediately, but once he played his first game in the playoffs, he – along with Scott Hartnell and Danny Briere – was magic.  They went on to form the most dangerous line in the playoffs.

On paper…

The old saying goes: games aren’t played on paper.

This Flyers team should be much better than their record indicates.  They have a formidable lineup, with a few holes on defense that should’ve been fixed in the offseason.  But even with the current defensive situation, the offense should be driving this team.  To put it mildly, the squad is having trouble finding the back of the net.  Now is that really Paul Holmgren’s fault?

The job of a general manager is to assemble a team and coaches that are capable of competing on a nightly basis.  What they actually do on the ice is beyond a general manager’s control.  I could understand an argument if Paul Holmgren was out on the ice every night showing a lackluster effort, but most of the blame rests on the shoulders of the players he pays to perform.

More blame should be placed on the coach for not inspiring the team night in and night out, however, since the team is under new leadership with Craig Berube, it still needs some time before all the kinks are worked out.  Changing coaching systems isn’t the easiest things for player to do on the fly, you know?

The final straw

Don’t think Paul Holmgren gets off scotch free here.  I was never a fan of the Bryzgalov signing.  I knew he wouldn’t play as well behind Dave Tippett’s defensive system in Phoenix.  I also knew he needed to fill the defensive holes on this team this offseason – and instead signed Vincent Lecavalier and Mark Streit.  Paul Holmgren has made some questionable calls, but in the long run, he’s been a very good general manager for the Flyers.

If by season’s end this team isn’t in the hunt for the playoff spot, then I’ll go along with the rest of the fans in calling for his resignation, but let’s give it some time.  There is still over 60 games left to be played.  For now, let cooler heads prevail.

Follow Shawn Reznik on Twitter: @ShawnTHW

Shawn Reznik

Shawn Reznik

Shawn started at The Hockey Writers in 2011 covering junior hockey/NCAA/European leagues for the site. In 2013, he became the Lead Writer for the Philadelphia Flyers.
Shawn Reznik
Shawn Reznik

Latest posts by Shawn Reznik (see all)

6 Comments

  1. “Somehow, Homer was able to flip a 1st round pick to the Nashville Predators for both Scott Hartnell and Kimmo Timonen.”

    He was able to flip them for a first because they were at the end of their contracts. They weren’t going to resign in Nashville since they needed money, it was a no brainier for them. The Flyers could have saved the first and fought to sign the two of them on the open market, it’s also possible they could have not signed either player and lost a 1st for no reason. It was a gable that I guess paid off.

  2. Actually Shawn I apologize with insults. I do not think you are stupid, crazy, or on drugs. I should have not resorted to low-brow insults. However, you are in the minority with the “Keep Holmgren” camp.

    I do not think he should harness all the blame for the teams woes, but he clearly should be replaced with a new perspective.

    Also, my #8 bullet point should have read Upshal and a 2nd for Carcillo.

    Again, I apologize and if I could edit my previous post, I would remove the mud slinging. We’re all fans and it is an emotional time in the Flyers Kingdom.

  3. Dear Shawn Reznik,

    Either you are [edited as per Burt's request]. Or perhaps you are all of the above.

    While I will agree that early in his tenure, Paul Holmgren looked like a wizard with his GM’ing skills; however, since then he has made some very bad moves.

    Let me run down a very short list:
    1) 1st rounder for Emminger
    2) Scott Hartnell getting the contract he did. Which, by the way, makes it virtually unmovable
    3) Ilya Bryzgalov
    4) Kimmo Timonen getting 6mm a year
    5) The return he got in Mike Richards (he easily could have asked for Bernier which would have never led the Flyers to the Bryzaster, followed by the subsequent buy out)
    6) Giroux getting the contract that was WAY above market value a year prior to his current deal expiring.
    7) not resigning Jagr
    8) Carcillo and a 2nd for Upshall
    9) Striet and VLC getting the length of deals that they got
    10) Throwing an offersheet at Weber basically blackballing him with other GMs, when it is known that Couturier and Schenn and a 1st could have gotten the deal done
    11) firing a coach 3 games in, when he clearly was not the issue. If he was going to fire Lavy why not do it in the off season so the replacement coach could have a full preseason to implement his system?
    12) Craig F’ing Berube!!!!

    Should I go on? This team is maxed against the cap to be in last place and most likely they will miss the post season again and you think the GM should remain?

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required Email Address * Name Email Format html text mobile