Grading Oilers’ 5-Year Contract for Ryan Shea

The Edmonton Oilers made their first splash in free agency yesterday, signing defenseman Ryan Shea to a five-year deal, worth $4 million annually.

The signing came shortly after the team announced that they had traded Darnell Nurse to the San Jose Sharks.

SHEASY 👊

The #Oilers have signed free agent defenceman Ryan Shea to a five-year contract with an AAV of $4.0 million. pic.twitter.com/FtSm3jOSr2

— Edmonton Oilers (@EdmontonOilers) July 1, 2026

Shea, who is 29 years old, scored six goals and added 29 assists for 35 points through 80 games with the Pittsburgh Penguins last season. Throughout his career, he has scored nine goals and added 32 assists for 41 points through 150 games.

After Connor McDavid took a huge discount to remain with the Oilers, it became clear that the Oilers needed to try and make some moves to prove they wanted to remain in playoff contention, and keep trying to push for their first Stanley Cup since 1990, and a move like this shows that they’re serious.

In this article, we take a quick deep dive into the Oilers’ Shea signing, and give it a grade.

Oilers Stabilize Defensive Depth

The Oilers moved Nurse out, and while their plan is likely to move Jake Walman into the second-pairing role moving forward, they seemingly wanted to upgrade on Spencer Stastney on their third pairing, and they have done that with Shea.

Ryan Shea, signed 5x$4M by EDM, is a puck-moving defenceman who did well in a top four role for the Penguins, supporting play at 5v5 and performing on the penalty kill. The production is almost definitely a fluke but he can contribute. pic.twitter.com/kZGTKJ9Pj4

— JFresh (@JFreshHockey) July 1, 2026

Shea provides some insurance on the Oilers’ left side heading into the new season, giving them the option to run with either Walman or Shea on their second pairing. However, the nicest thing about this signing is that they finally have some flexibility for their defensive depth. They can afford to try some different combinations early in the season to figure out what works, which isn’t something the Oilers have had the luxury of in previous seasons.

There were some immediate questions about the term of the contract, considering this deal takes Shea through the age of 34, but even if he starts to decline near the end of the contract, a rising cap hit should allow the Oilers to move his deal fairly easily if it comes to that point.

With the lack of quality defensemen on the open market this offseason, being able to improve on the blue line is a huge win for the Oilers. This is a low-risk, high-reward signing that improves their defensive depth heading into a very important season.

Contract Grade: A

I don’t have many issues with this deal whatsoever. The only thing that could become a concern is if Shea did have a one-off solid campaign and falls off of a cliff at both ends of the ice, and becomes unplayable in any way. However, the Oilers are putting him in a position to succeed, aren’t paying him an insane amount of money, and seem confident that he can be their new go-to penalty kill defenseman.

After a season where the Oilers’ penalty kill wasn’t solid, adding players to fill that role and improve that part of their game is tidy work, and it shows they’re serious about contending.

Even if there is a little trade protection on this contract, it is a solid addition by the Oilers.

The Oilers are in a really good spot heading into the offseason, and they still have some money to play with.

As the 2026-27 season approaches, be sure to continue following The Hockey Writers as your source for news, updates, and more from around the NHL and the hockey world.