Anaheim DucksBoston BruinsBuffalo SabresCalgary FlamesCarolina HurricanesChicago BlackhawksColorado AvalancheColumbus Blue JacketsDallas StarsDetroit Red WingsEdmonton OilersFlorida PanthersLos Angeles KingsMinnesota WildMontreal CanadiensNashville PredatorsNew Jersey DevilsNew York IslandersNew York RangersOttawa SenatorsPhiladelphia FlyersPittsburgh PenguinsSan Jose SharksSeattle KrakenSt. Louis BluesTampa Bay LightningToronto Maple LeafsUtah Hockey ClubVancouver CanucksVegas Golden KnightsWashington CapitalsWinnipeg Jets

Demidov’s Return Could Force the Canadiens to Make Some Tough Decisions

The Montreal Canadiens have been dealing with their fair share of injuries early in the 2026-27 season, but with some players getting closer to returning, the organization could soon be facing a very different problem.

With Ivan Demidov making progress in his recovery, the Canadiens will have more healthy forwards than available spots. While having too much depth is generally a good problem, it also means some difficult decisions are coming for Martin St. Louis and the rest of the organization.

Owen Beck and Florian Xhekaj were both left out of the lineup on Thursday night, and with Demidov eventually taking another spot, the situation is only going to get more complicated. So, what exactly should the Canadiens do?

A Crowded Forward Group

For much of the season, the Canadiens have been forced to make adjustments because of injuries. However, with players gradually returning, the competition for ice time is becoming increasingly difficult. Thursday night’s decision to leave both Beck and Xhekaj out of the lineup was already an indication of how crowded things have become. Neither player has necessarily done enough to establish himself as an everyday NHL forward, but both have shown interesting things in their limited opportunities.

Beck, in particular, has demonstrated that he can contribute offensively while providing some versatility down the middle. The young centre has recorded three points in his first five games this season, which is certainly encouraging considering his limited NHL experience.

Ivan Demidov Montreal Canadiens
Montreal Canadiens right wing Ivan Demidov (David Kirouac-Imagn Images)

As for Xhekaj, his physicality and energy bring something different to Montreal’s bottom six. However, he has also struggled at times to establish himself defensively, making it difficult for St. Louis to justify giving him a regular spot.

Now, add Demidov to the equation. Unlike Beck and Xhekaj, Demidov isn’t fighting for a spot in the lineup. The Russian winger is one of the Canadiens’ most talented offensive players, and when he’s healthy, there is absolutely no question that he belongs in the top six That means somebody else will have to make room.

What Happens to Beck and Xhekaj?

The most obvious solution would be to send one or both youngsters back to the Laval Rocket. At their respective ages, playing regularly is arguably much more beneficial than spending multiple nights watching games from the press box.

For Beck, the situation is particularly interesting. The Canadiens have been searching for more consistency at the centre position, especially with Oliver Kapanen struggling to produce offensively. Beck has shown flashes of being a reliable NHL player, and his development could eventually help address that need. However, if Montreal cannot offer him consistent minutes, returning to Laval might be the best decision for his long-term development.

The same argument applies to Xhekaj. The 22-year-old forward has the potential to become a valuable bottom-six player thanks to his size, physicality and willingness to compete. But those qualities alone aren’t enough to guarantee a permanent NHL role. He still needs to improve certain aspects of his game, and playing significant minutes in the American Hockey League could help him accomplish that.

Of course, the Canadiens could also decide to keep both youngsters around as extra forwards, particularly considering how quickly injuries can happen. But is keeping young players in the press box really the best solution? Probably not.

There is also the possibility that Montreal could explore a trade involving another forward to create additional flexibility. However, moving someone simply because the roster is crowded wouldn’t necessarily be a smart decision.

A Good Problem, but Decisions Are Coming

Ultimately, the Canadiens having too many healthy forwards is a much better situation than the alternative. Injuries have already tested Montreal’s depth this season, and having multiple players capable of stepping into the lineup is something every competitive team needs. Still, the organization must find the right balance between winning games now and developing its younger players.

Demidov’s return should provide a significant boost to Montreal’s offensive production. His creativity, vision and ability to generate scoring opportunities are qualities that very few players on this roster can replicate. But his return also means one fewer opportunity for someone else.

For now, Beck and Xhekaj appear to be the most vulnerable players when it comes to losing their spots. Both were healthy scratches Thursday night, and neither has established himself as an indispensable part of the lineup. That doesn’t mean their NHL futures are in jeopardy. Quite the opposite, both remain interesting young players who could eventually become regular contributors.

With Demidov getting closer to returning, Kent Hughes and Martin St. Louis will soon have some decisions to make. And considering the Canadiens’ depth, those decisions might not be as straightforward as they initially appear.

Free Newsletter

Get Montreal Canadiens coverage delivered to your inbox

In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.

Subscribe Free →
William Bourget

William Bourget

Writing about the Montreal Canadiens. Wrote and managed a podcast for about 2 years. Huge Penguins fan

More by William Bourget →