Anaheim DucksBoston BruinsBuffalo SabresCalgary FlamesCarolina HurricanesChicago BlackhawksColorado AvalancheColumbus Blue JacketsDallas StarsDetroit Red WingsEdmonton OilersFlorida PanthersLos Angeles KingsMinnesota WildMontreal CanadiensNashville PredatorsNew Jersey DevilsNew York IslandersNew York RangersOttawa SenatorsPhiladelphia FlyersPittsburgh PenguinsSan Jose SharksSeattle KrakenSt. Louis BluesTampa Bay LightningToronto Maple LeafsUtah Hockey ClubVancouver CanucksVegas Golden KnightsWashington CapitalsWinnipeg Jets

How Much Has Maple Leafs Goaltending Cost Them?

After the Toronto Maple Leafs‘ 6-3 loss to the Chicago Blackhawks on Tuesday, they are 8-13-2 through 23 games. That’s not where this team expected to be, and it’s getting harder to explain away the poor start. Toronto has scored 72 goals, averaging 3.13 per game. That’s enough offence to win more hockey games than they have been winning.

The bigger problem has been at the other end of the ice. Toronto has allowed 86 goals. So I wanted to look at the goaltending numbers a little differently. Right now, Anthony Stolarz is 5-4-0 with a 2.69 goals against average (GAA) and .906 save percentage (SV%). Sergei Bobrovsky is 3-9-2 with a 3.65 GAA and .874 SV%.

Sergei Bobrovsky Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky (Sergei Belski-Imagn Images)

What would the Maple Leafs’ record look like if the games Bobrovsky started had received the same GAA Stolarz has posted? Obviously, what readers see below is not a perfect comparison, and a goalie would never give up exactly 2.69 goals every night. But it gives us a way to see how much the results might have changed.

The First 23 Maple Leafs Games

The chart lists the starting goalie and the actual score in every game. For Bobrovsky’s starts, the final column shows the hypothetical result if the opposition had scored 2.69 goals instead. Stolarz’s actual games are left unchanged.

Date and opponentGoalieActual score
(TOR–Opp.)
Illustrative result at 2.69 GAA
Sept. 29 – MontrealBobrovsky2–3L, 2–2.69
Sept. 30 – NY IslandersStolarz2–1—
Oct. 3 – OttawaBobrovsky2–3L, 2–2.69
Oct. 6 – NashvilleStolarz5–4 OT—
Oct. 8 – VegasStolarz3–4 SO—
Oct. 10 – ColoradoBobrovsky6–3W, 6–2.69
Oct. 13 – UtahStolarz4–5—
Oct. 15 – BuffaloBobrovsky4–5 OTW, 4–2.69
Oct. 17 – NY IslandersBobrovsky1–4L, 1–2.69
Oct. 19 – San JoseBobrovsky3–1W, 3–2.69
Oct. 20 – ColumbusStolarz6–2—
Oct. 22 – NY RangersBobrovsky5–4W, 5–2.69
Oct. 24 – EdmontonStolarz7–2—
Oct. 26 – CalgaryBobrovsky2–5L, 2–2.69
Oct. 28 – SeattleBobrovsky4–5W, 4–2.69
Oct. 31 – VancouverStolarz4–2—
Nov. 3 – UtahBobrovsky2–3L, 2–2.69
Nov. 7 – MontrealBobrovsky2–4L, 2–2.69
Nov. 8 – New JerseyStolarz0–4—
Nov. 10 – ColoradoBobrovsky3–6W, 3–2.69
Nov. 12 – MinnesotaStolarz2–5—
Nov. 14 – EdmontonStolarz0–1—
Nov. 17 – ChicagoBobrovsky3–6W, 3–2.69
Maple Leafs Goals vs. Opposition GoalsTotal Goals
Toronto goals scored72
Opposition goals scored86
Total goals in all games158

Here’s the goalie breakdown:

GoalieGoalie StartsToronto goalsOpposition goals
Bobrovsky143953
Stolarz103333
Total237286

Four Games Make a Difference

In the 13 games Bobrovsky started, Toronto has gone 3-9-1. Using Stolarz’s 2.69 goals-against average as an illustrative comparison, those same games could have produced a 7-6-0 record. Four games would have flipped from losses to wins: Buffalo, Seattle, Colorado on Nov. 10, and Chicago. Toronto scored four goals in two of those games and three in the other two. At 2.69 goals against, those totals would have been enough to win.

Anthony Stolarz Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs goalie Anthony Stolarz (Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images)

Now let’s put the two sets of results together. Stolarz’s 10 games remain as they were, while Bobrovsky’s 13 games are adjusted using the 2.69 figure.

Record
Actual Maple Leafs record8-13-2
Hypothetical record12-10-1
Additional wins4
Additional points7

While that’s still not a great winning record, it’s still quite a difference. The Maple Leafs would have four more wins and seven more points. Instead of sitting at 8-13-2, they would be 12-10-1. That still doesn’t set the world on fire, but it’s a whole ton better than their current record.

What Does This Tell Us?

I’m not suggesting that goaltending is the only problem in Toronto. The defence has to be better, and the forwards have to take more responsibility without the puck. But scoring 3.13 goals per game and still sitting at 8-13-2 tells us something isn’t working.

The comparison also raises a pretty straightforward question. If Stolarz is giving the Maple Leafs a better chance to win, shouldn’t he be getting more of the work?

Toronto can’t expect its goalie to steal every game. But the team does need a goalie who gives it a reasonable chance to win most nights. So far, that hasn’t happened consistently enough. And the Maple Leafs are running out of time to find an answer.

Free Newsletter

Get Toronto Maple Leafs coverage delivered to your inbox

In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.

Subscribe Free →
The Old Prof

The Old Prof

The Old Prof (Jim Parsons, Sr.) taught for more than 40 years in the Faculty of Education at the University of Alberta. He's a Canadian boy, who has two degrees from the University of Kentucky and a doctorate from the University of Texas. He is now retired on Vancouver Island, where he lives with his family. His hobbies include playing with his hockey cards and simply being a sports fan - hockey, the Toronto Raptors, and CFL football (thinks Ricky Ray personifies how a professional athlete should act).

If you wonder why he doesn’t use his real name, it’s because his son – who’s also Jim Parsons – wrote for The Hockey Writers first and asked Jim Sr. to use another name so readers wouldn’t confuse their work.

Because Jim Sr. had worked in China, he adopted the Mandarin word for teacher (老師). The first character lǎo (老) means “old,” and the second character shī (師) means “teacher.” The literal translation of lǎoshī is “old teacher.” That became his pen name. Today, other than writing for The Hockey Writers, he teaches graduate students research design at several Canadian universities.

He looks forward to sharing his insights about the Toronto Maple Leafs and about how sports engages life more fully. His Twitter address is https://twitter.com/TheOldProf

More by The Old Prof →