To say the Toronto Maple Leafs are off to another disappointing start is an understatement. The team is coming off one of their worst homestands in recent memory and there seems to be no end in sight – with injuries and losses both piling up fast.
Poor play from some of the team’s key players, along with depth uncertainty have both played roles in the team’s overall performance to this point in the season. But adding to that has been some questionable decisions by the team’s head coach – Jim Hiller – at times this season.
McKenna Missing From Maple Leafs’ Powerplay
One of the more perplexing decisions has been the coach’s decision to move off playing rookie Gavin McKenna on the team’s top powerplay unit following the return of John Tavares from injury. Sure, the veteran forward has made a name for himself in front of the net with the man advantage over the past few seasons, but the team’s powerplay was clicking with McKenna out there and has since gone cold.

As of November 15, the Maple Leafs have gone 1-for-10 with the man advantage after pulling McKenna off the top unit – a group that started out the season as one of the team’s strongest assets. Now, it could be argued that the Maple Leafs aren’t getting as many opportunities on the powerplay either, however, the chances they are getting are not resulting in offence – something the team has proven they need desperately on their current slide.
Hiller could shake things up and get McKenna back in the mix at some point, but given his usage of the teenager so far this season, that doesn’t seem likely.
Hiller’s Goaltending Carousel
Early on in the season, it was expected that the Maple Leafs would rotate between Anthony Stolarz and Sergei Bobrovsky in net. Now, 20-plus games into the season, with the team struggling in front of Bobrovsky and the veteran not holding down the fort, it’s surprising that the team continues to go to him.
Sure, he’s making $7 million per season and he’s a Vezina Trophy winner, but his play so far this season hasn’t indicated that he’s comfortable in the Maple Leafs’ net this season. And now, it’s costing the team precious points in the standings.
So far, he’s 3-8-2 in 13 games this season with a 3.47 goals against average (GAA) and .881 save percentage (SV%). Meanwhile, Stolarz is 5-4-0 in nine games this season with a 2.69 GAA and .906 SV%. It’s crazy to think that Bobrovsky won’t be the number one by the end of the season, but right now he’s not playing like one.
With the season slipping away from Hiller and the Maple Leafs, the carousel needs to stop and Hiller needs to run with the hot hand in Stolarz.
Hiller Using McKenna as a Depth Option
Finally, we go back to McKenna and his lack of usage overall – not just on the powerplay. Early in the season, the Maple Leafs’ first overall pick was bench for the majority of the second period and the entire third period of a game with the team on the verge of losing.

Their head coach chalked it up to an oversight after a number of penalties were taken by his team, stating that he simply couldn’t find a good time to get the young star back on the ice. Now, amidst a six-game losing streak, Hiller is still looking past the option of moving McKenna up in the lineup.
Lines at practice on Monday, ahead of the Maple Leafs game against the Blackhawks had no changes from their 1-0 loss against the Edmonton Oilers. McKenna was still lining up on the third line, while Ryan Tverberg got the nod for the second line with Tavares and William Nylander.
Call it a learning curve for McKenna? Sure. But given his production when he gets the opportunities, Hiller needs to reconsider where he puts his young star in the lineup. If for nothing else, to help turn around the Maple Leafs’ cold streak and salvage some possibility in a season that was so promising before their coach made some questionable decisions.
Free Newsletter
Get Toronto Maple Leafs coverage delivered to your inbox
In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.
Subscribe Free →