Ranking Every Calder Trophy Winner Since 2005

Everyone loves when a young, exciting star comes into the NHL and dominates right out of the gate. The Calder Memorial Trophy is given out each year to the league’s best rookie, with many winners later taking home other hardware, such as the Hart Memorial Trophy for the league’s most valuable player.

Substack Subscribe to the THW Daily and never miss the best of The Hockey Writers Banner

So, let’s look back and rank each Calder Trophy winner in the salary cap era since the NHL retook the ice back in 2005.

18. Jonathan Huberdeau – Florida Panthers – 2012-13

The lockout-shortened 2012-13 NHL campaign will always seem a bit weird when looking back on it from a historical perspective. That season’s Calder Trophy winner, Jonathan Huberdeau of the Florida Panthers, played all 48 games but scored 14 goals and 31 points. Even stretched out over an 82-game pace, that’s just 24 goals and 53 points across an entire season. On top of that, he registered a minus-15 rating while skating just a touch under 17 minutes per game.

Read Also: NHL Contracts Are Becoming More and More ‘Lockout-Proof’

Latest News & Highlights

While that may have been enough to win the Calder in 2013, it’s not enough to push him out of last place on this list.

17. Gabriel Landeskog – Colorado Avalanche – 2011-12

As the first of two Colorado Avalanche forwards on this list, Gabriel Landeskog played all 82 games during his rookie season just months after being the second overall pick in the 2011 NHL Draft. Landeskog tied Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, the first overall selection that same year, with 52 points for the rookie lead. However, the Avalanche winger notched 22 goals, four more than his rookie rival while recording an impressive plus-20 rating, helping him edge out Nugent-Hopkins for the award.

16. Aaron Ekblad – Florida Panthers – 2014-15

Just two years after his Panthers teammate took home the Calder Trophy, Aaron Ekblad stepped up and brought it back to the Sunshine State.

Aaron Ekblad Florida Panthers
Aaron Ekblad won the 2015 Calder Trophy for his strong rookie season playing on the Florida Panthers’ blue line. (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

The Canadian blueliner was selected first overall in the 2014 NHL Draft and went straight to the league, sniping 12 goals and 39 points along with a plus-12 rating. This showing made him an instant franchise face for the Panthers while showcasing that he would have a bright future in the league.

15. Tyler Myers – Buffalo Sabres – 2009-10

At 19 years old, Tyler Myers became the first defenseman to take home the Calder Trophy since Barret Jackman during the 2002-03 NHL campaign. Myers tallied 11 goals and 48 points during his rookie season, with both totals still being his career highs as of 2021-22. The massive 6-foot-8 blueliner also notched 133 blocked shots and 89 hits, showing that he was more than just an offensive presence for the Sabres.

14. Matty Beniers – Seattle Kraken – 2022-23

Rarely does the odds-on favorite at the start of the NHL season actually go on to win an award, but entering the 2022-23 season, the hockey world felt that the Calder Trophy would, ultimately, be raised by Matty Beniers. As the first selection made by the Seattle Kraken in franchise history, Beniers lived up to all expectations by posting 24 goals and 57 points in 80 games played. As a team that saw surprising success in their second year in the league, the Kraken will look to their budding star to take that next step in his career after this impressive rookie season.

13. Cale Makar – Colorado Avalanche – 2019-20

Cale Makar’s rookie season will always be one where you ask the question… What If? What if Makar had stayed healthy? What if the season hadn’t been cut short?

Cale Makar Colorado Avalanche
Cale Makar. Colorado Avalanche (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

Even with these questions, there’s no doubt that Makar had a breakout campaign in 2019-20. With 12 goals and 50 points in just 57 games, there was no telling just how high his scoring totals could have been if everything had gone perfectly.

12. Patrick Kane – Chicago Blackhawks – 2007-08

Like several others on this list, Patrick Kane came into the NHL immediately after being drafted. The top pick in the 2007 NHL Draft scored 21 goals and 72 points during his terrific rookie campaign, narrowly leading all rookies in scoring. That same season, fellow Chicago Blackhawks forward Jonathan Toews finished third in Calder Trophy voting after scoring 54 points.

11. Nathan MacKinnon – Colorado Avalanches – 2013-14

Another top draft choice, Nathan MacKinnon was selected with the No. 1 pick in the 2013 NHL Draft and lived up to expectations early. The 18-year-old Nova Scotian collected 24 goals and 63 points, the most he would score until his fifth NHL season.

Nathan MacKinnon Colorado Avalanche
Nathan MacKinnon, Colorado Avalanche (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

MacKinnon took home the Calder Trophy just two seasons after Landeskog, outscoring him by 11 points in their respective rookie campaigns while showcasing how bright Colorado’s future could be.

10. Moritz Seider – Detroit Red Wings – 2021-22

It can be difficult to judge a workhorse defenseman like Moritz Seider, as his contributions to the Detroit Red Wings were so much more than points. In that regard, he posted seven goals and 50 points, which is a lot for a rookie defenseman. However, along with that offense, he also contributed 161 blocks, 151 hits, 41 takeaways, and most importantly, averaged more than 23 minutes of ice time each night in 82 healthy games.

For a 20-year-old defenseman on a Red Wings team that still wasn’t there yet as a playoff contender, those are some impressive totals. The future is bright for Seider, and you can expect the German blueliner to become one of the faces of the sport in his home country.

9. Jeff Skinner – Carolina Hurricanes – 2010-11

Selected seventh overall in the 2010 NHL Draft behind names such as Taylor Hall and Tyler Seguin, Jeff Skinner’s Calder Trophy victory was a bit surprising. The 18-year-old winger was the lone rookie to surpass the 60-point plateau that season but finished third among rookies with 31 goals scored. Skinner’s 63 points remains a career-high, but he’s reached that exact total three times.

8. Elias Pettersson – Vancouver Canucks – 2018-19

Heading into the 2018-19 season, Elias Pettersson was the gambling favorite to take home the Calder Trophy, and he impressively followed through on that hype. Despite missing 11 games with a concussion and a knee injury, the 6-foot-2 center still tallied 28 goals and 66 points, including 22 power-play points. The 2017 fifth-overall pick has cemented himself as one of the best young forwards in the game and should be part of the Vancouver Canucks’ resurgence in the coming years.

7. Artemi Panarin – Chicago Blackhawks – 2015-16

Artemi Panarin certainly didn’t have a standard rookie season. The Russian winger didn’t come to North America until he was 24 years old, becoming the oldest Calder Trophy winner since Evgeni Nabokov in 2000-01.

Artemi Panarin, Chicago Blackhawks
Artemi Panarin had plenty of experience in the KHL before coming in and dominating the NHL in 2015. (Amy Irvin/The Hockey Writers)

Still, Panarin was outstanding, collecting 30 goals and 77 points in 80 games. That same season, Conor McDavid finished third after scoring 48 points in just 45 games and likely would’ve taken the award home if not for suffering an injury.

6. Steve Mason – Columbus Blue Jackets – 2008-09

Steve Mason’s Calder-winning 2008-09 campaign was good enough to land him a second-place finish in the Vezina Trophy voting as well. The 22-year-old led the NHL with a ridiculous 10 shutouts, giving him a 2.29 goals-against average and .916 save percentage alongside a 33-20-7 record. More impressively, no netminder has taken home the Calder since then, making this win a rare occurrence for a goalie.

5. Kirill Kaprizov – Minnesota Wild – 2020-21

Heading into the 2020-21 season, all eyes were on Kirill “The Thrill” Kaprizov as he joined the Minnesota Wild after dominating the KHL in recent years. He was, after all, one of the most electric offensive talents in the world, and he had the potential to reshape the Wild’s core around him.

It didn’t take long for Kaprizov to introduce himself to the NHL, as he scored the game-winning overtime goal in his first start, and went on to post 27 goals and 51 points in just 55 games. If he had continued this pace over a full 82-game schedule, Kaprizov would have scored 40 goals and 76 points, which are both incredible numbers for a rookie forward.

Kirill Kaprizov Minnesota Wild
Kirill Kaprizov, Minnesota Wild (Photo by Nick Wosika/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

As it stands, however, Karpizov’s rookie season is still an incredible feat. Not only is he the offensive face of the Wild, but he will be one of the NHL’s rising stars for years to come.

4. Mathew Barzal – New York Islanders – 2017-18

Mathew Barzal had two games of NHL action prior to his first full season with the New York Islanders, and he was held without a point in those contests. However, the following season the 20-year-old center put the league on notice by running away with the rookie scoring race, totaling 22 goals and 85 points, beating the second-leading scorer, Clayton Keller, by 20 points. Not only this, but Barzal was the first rookie to surpass the 80-point mark since Evgeni Malkin back in the 2006-07 season.

3. Auston Matthews – Toronto Maple Leafs – 2016-17

With the first-overall pick at the 2016 NHL Draft, the Toronto Maple Leafs were looking for a new face of the franchise and got just that in Auston Matthews. The 19-year-old lived up to all the hype, scoring 40 goals (including an NHL-best 32 at even strength) and 69 points.

Auston Matthews Toronto Maple Leafs
Auston Matthews, Toronto Maple Leafs (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

With his absurd scoring potential on full display, Matthews cemented himself as one of the league’s young stars and has continued to prove it was no fluke since.

2. Evgeni Malkin – Pittsburgh Penguins – 2006-07

Evgeni Malkin became the second consecutive Russian forward to take home the award, following in the footsteps of Alex Ovechkin. The 20-year-old notched 33 goals and 85 points, a points total that would not be matched until Barzal’s Calder-winning campaign more than a decade later.

Also of note, this was the same season that Malkin’s new teammate, Sidney Crosby, won his first Hart Memorial award. Of course, those two would go on to become one of the best duos in NHL history, winning plenty of hardware and a few Stanley Cup titles.

1. Alex Ovechkin – Washington Capitals – 2005-06

Alex Ovechkin’s rookie campaign set the path for the rest of his career as an elite goal scorer and one of the game’s top skaters for over a decade. The big-bodied Russian became the first rookie to eclipse the 100-point mark since Teemu Selanne during the 1992-93 campaign.

Alexander Ovechkin Washington Capitals
Alexander Ovechkin, Washington Capitals (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

Ovechkin racked up 52 goals and 106 points on the year, narrowly edging out Sidney Crosby’s 102 points for the rookie lead. Since then, no rookie has reached the century mark for points or the 50-goal plateau. At this point, there may not be a rookie like Ovechkin for a long time.