There has been a lot of scrutiny surrounding the Toronto Maple Leafs the last few weeks. From a poor homestand, to porous goaltending, to weak defense, there are a lot of talking points in just a short period of time.
The one that has garnered a lot of debate has been head coach Jim Hiller’s utilization of rookie forward Gavin McKenna. After being slotted in the top-six to start the season, McKenna has been bumped down to the third line and has been playing with lesser quality teammates in terms of skill.
McKenna is continuing to learn the ropes and is adjusting in his first NHL season. There have been some mistakes along the way, but that’s part of the process. If the Maple Leafs are going to succeed, Hiller– who has made a number of questionable decisions already– has to give McKenna more opportunities in order to play a pivotal role on this team.
Hiller Not Keeping His Word
At the start of the season, Hiller made a great comment about the plan for McKenna and putting him in the best position for him to succeed. It was reasonable, it was fair and it absolutely made sense to not put so much pressure on an 18-year-old rookie in a big market.

However, it feels like over the last few weeks, that plan has completely fallen off the rail and Hiller is not keeping his word in order to put McKenna in a position to succeed. While there have been injuries and movement in the lineup, keeping McKenna on the third line is understandable but you also have to extend trust to him as a coach that he can play an important role.
The starting point was where Hiller benched McKenna in a game where they were up against the Buffalo Sabres and didn’t play McKenna for the remainder of the game. His post-game comments were perplexing. That alone was extremely questionable given the circumstances and McKenna would’ve been a player you would want to play to create any form of offense when it went cold in that game.
Even before that, McKenna was bumped to the third line, playing alongside a number of depth players with Nick Paul, Colton Sissons and Dakota Joshua, especially with Paul and Joshua as of late. While they haven’t been on for a goal against, they also haven’t generated much offense either. There have also been moments when he got bumped up to the second.
If you really want him to succeed, you need to utilize him more. Some of Hiller’s decisions to opt for veteran players to make plays or be used in a key situation has failed constantly this season. While McKenna can make risky plays, the veterans are failing at making the simple ones. At this point, if you can’t rely on your veterans with the way they’re playing, why not give him more opportunities.

Even in the game against the Chicago Blackhawks, McKenna was flying on the ice and even earned another chance on the second line. Right when the Maple Leafs tied the game, Hiller went to Joshua. Joshua turns the puck over leading to Connor Bedard’s go-ahead goal. That’s poor mismanagement and opting to rely on a veteran continues to fail him in a key moment.
While it usually is the case with rookies, McKenna is on the short end of things compared to the veterans. However, maybe it’s time to hold some of the veterans accountable like Hiller did McKenna for his mistakes.
A Fixable Problem
For all the mismanagement that Hiller has done with McKenna to this point, he has the ability to change that in two key ways. It’s a problem that is fixable.
Ideally, you would want to keep McKenna on the second line, but the line of McKenna- John Tavares and William Nylander have had awful results with an expected goals percentage of 29.5%. With Tavares and Nylander still continuing to struggle without McKenna, you probably don’t want to do that again.

Even though Easton Cowan has looked great with Auston Matthews and Jack Roslovic, so has McKenna. While you don’t want to mess with chemistry, McKenna- Matthews- Roslovic have an xGF of 54.5%. If you don’t want to put him on the second line, you can easily put him on the first. Cowan has shown to play anywhere so bumping him to the second or third line wouldn’t be a bad thing as he can play a more responsible game.
The second thing you can do is to give him more power play minutes. While McKenna wasn’t too bothered about being demoted back to the second power play unit, the Maple Leafs looked far more dangerous when he was with the top unit than let’s say Tavares. The ability to quickly move the puck and open up the lanes in all areas in the offensive zone was noticeable. The chances and opportunities are more dangerous and it’s not even close.
McKenna is a rookie and needs to show that he has to earn his spot on the team. However, given how the veterans have played, Hiller not going to him when he needs a spark is very concerning. The way that he has utilized him over the last few weeks isn’t ideal and it needs to change.
Statistics from Money Puck.
Free Newsletter
Get Toronto Maple Leafs coverage delivered to your inbox
In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.
Subscribe Free →