Anaheim DucksBoston BruinsBuffalo SabresCalgary FlamesCarolina HurricanesChicago BlackhawksColorado AvalancheColumbus Blue JacketsDallas StarsDetroit Red WingsEdmonton OilersFlorida PanthersLos Angeles KingsMinnesota WildMontreal CanadiensNashville PredatorsNew Jersey DevilsNew York IslandersNew York RangersOttawa SenatorsPhiladelphia FlyersPittsburgh PenguinsSan Jose SharksSeattle KrakenSt. Louis BluesTampa Bay LightningToronto Maple LeafsUtah Hockey ClubVancouver CanucksVegas Golden KnightsWashington CapitalsWinnipeg Jets

The Sky Is Falling: Which of 3 Big Maple Leafs Moves Comes First?

The Toronto Maple Leafs have lost seven straight. Everyone is talking about how things have fallen apart, and it might be time to tear it down to the studs. The sky is already falling, and questions about what comes next have overtaken any other news surrounding the team.

Fans are asking whether something drastic is coming. Some wonder what the realistic options are, given the salary-cap crunch, tagging concerns, and trade-protection clauses built into so many of the team’s top deals.

Three names keep surfacing: Auston Matthews, William Nylander, and head coach Jim Hiller. Here is how each situation looks, and which move is most likely to happen first.

Auston Matthews: Unthinkable, but Not Impossible

Trading the captain would have sounded absurd a few years ago. It’s not so absurd now. Those still calling it a ridiculous concept have already forgotten that just a couple of months ago, the offseason was littered with speculation that Matthews might be rethinking his future. The thought was that he’d need to see how the franchise’s summer moves would pan out. By now he’s got a pretty good idea.

Matthews has just one season left on his contract after this one. He’s expressed confidence that the team can still turn things around, but the odds of even making the playoffs are low.

He isn’t the problem on the ice. At 29, he has 12 goals and 30 points in 23 games. His $13.25 million cap hit runs through 2027-28, and he holds a full no-movement clause, so he decides if he goes and where. There would be teams more than interested if he hit the market.

Insider Elliotte Friedman described him as calm and practical, which suggests he understands where things could head if results don’t improve.

William Nylander: The Trade Talk Is Real

Nylander has the most momentum of the three. He was demoted ahead of Thursday’s game, and critics have questioned his effort and compete level. Nylander pushed back, saying he hasn’t cheated the game this season and just needs to keep playing his game.

William Nylander Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs forward William Nylander celebrates after scoring a goal (Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images)

Nick Kypreos said he has made calls and found nothing concrete, but that trading Nylander is among the options being discussed. Friedman added, “Nylander is a bit more stubborn. He’s got a lot of pride. If he feels he’s been wronged or not treated fairly, it’s very difficult to get him to change his mind.”

How does he feel about being blamed and then demoted? If he’s already checked out, what happens when he realizes he’s become the team’s new Mitch Marner?

Jim Hiller: The Easiest Change to Make

Hiller is a new hire, which is exactly why his name is surfacing as a scapegoat for what’s going on. Daily Faceoff’s Matt Larkin argued that a coaching change, and the “new coach bump” that can come with it, may be the team’s best remaining shot at the playoffs.

But can the Maple Leafs really fire a coach they just hired after a summer of interviewing countless candidates? He might not be a fit stylistically, but he’s not the sole reason for the team’s lack of success. The roster looks poorly constructed, the defense is aging, and the summer gamble on Sergei Bobrovsky hasn’t paid off. Firing a coach two months in doesn’t fix any of that.

So Who Goes First?

Let’s be clear; there’s no guarantee any of these three are moved. But, if one were, who would go first?

If the losing continues, the order probably runs opposite to the headlines. Hiller is the most likely to go first because he’s the cheapest and simplest move, even if it solves the least. Nylander comes next, but only if the Leafs can approach him carefully and find a partner. Matthews, the player who matters most, would be the last domino.

Honorable Mention:

Dumping Sergei Bobrovsky would have made the list, but he isn’t because he can’t be traded, sent to the minors, or waived without his consent. As Scott Wheeler points out, because he’s on a 35+ contract, Bobrovsky’s full cap hit also counts against the salary cap in a buyout.

Free Newsletter

Get Toronto Maple Leafs coverage delivered to your inbox

In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.

Subscribe Free →
Jim Parsons

Jim Parsons

Jim Parsons is a senior THW freelance writer, part-time journalist and audio/video host who lives, eats, sleeps and breathes NHL news and rumors, while also writing features on the Edmonton Oilers and Toronto Maple Leafs. He’s been a trusted source for six-plus years at The Hockey Writers, but more than that, he’s on a mission to keep readers up to date with the latest NHL rumors and trade talk. Jim is a daily must for readers who want to be “in the know.”

Other content contributions include: NHLtradetalk.com, The Sportster and hosting weekly video casts, THW News and Rumors Rundown, plus Oilers Overtime.

For interview requests or to provide content info, follow Jim on Twitter or his social media accounts. They appear under his photo on articles like this one.

More by Jim Parsons →