The Inaccuracy of D2: The Mighty Ducks

D2-The Mighty DucksAs a child growing up in the mid-90s, I loved sports and I loved movies, both loves very near to my heart to this day. During the mid-90s there were a lot of children’s sports movies being released, The Sandlot, The Big Green, Space Jam, Angels in the Outfield, Little Giants. I loved them all.

One of my favorites growing up was The Mighty Ducks 1 and 2. I used to watch them all the time whenever it was in cable, almost to the point that it annoyed my parents. Now that I am at an advanced age of 27, I can now look back and realize there were a lot of inaccuracies with these sports movies and none more than “D2: The Mighty Ducks”.

This is Team USA?

So, the plot of D2 is pretty much this: Gordon Bombay is a player who is about to be called up into the NHL, inures his knee, and instead becomes the coach for Team USA in the Junior Goodwill Games. Who did they recruit to play for Team USA? Why, coach Bombay’s Ducks team from Minnesota. You know, the same Mighty Ducks that backed their way into a Pee-wee hockey league playoffs in Minnesota.

You’d think that a country with a proud hockey tradition would have actually gotten some better and more prolific players. Instead, Team USA is full of bumbling players who have a hard time staying in rollerblades.

The following scene is from D3: The Mighty Ducks, but it’s all the same.

USA? USA? USA?

Hockey players are supposed to be graceful on the ice, but these guys make me look like Rocket Richard and this is supposed to be Team USA? Surely there had to be better options.

Iceland and Trinidad and Tobago: Hockey Superpowers?

When there’s a movie about an ice hockey tournament, you’re going to need a antagonist that is the downright superior team. Is it Canada? Russia? Sweden? No, it’s the hockey powerhouse of Iceland.

Yes, Iceland.

The same Iceland that is ranked 33rd in the IIHF World Rankings and played their first international game in 1999, five years after the movie came out, losing to another hockey superpower, Israel, 11-0.

You’d think at the very least they would have used Russia because of a certain game in 1980. I think the reason why they probably didn’t use Russia was because it was 1994 and Russian-US relations were finally on the mend and something as trivial as this could have upset Russia. I know I’m just grasping at straws here, but it’s just a theory.

I n fact, Russia would have been a logical choice seeing as how the Goodwill Games came to be. Billionaire media mogul Ted Turner created the Goodwill Games after the USA’s boycott of the 1980 Summer Olympics in Moscow and the USSR’s boycott of the 1984 Summer Olympics in Los Angeles. So, it would just make even more sense to have Russia be the main antagonist.

Just because Iceland has the word “ice” in it, it doesn’t mean they are superior in hockey.

Also, Trinidad and Tobago’s hockey team was good enough to make group play in the Junior Goodwill Games. All this despite Trinidad and Tobago not having a national hockey team and only three indoor hockey rinks. In fact, only one professional hockey player has ever come from Trinidad and Tobago, the WHA’s Sam Gellard.

“Cool Runnings” had come out a year before D2, so my theory is is that Disney, producers of both films, were trying to still catch that Caribbean feel from “Cool Runnings” as you can see in the video below.

The Knucklepuck No Goal

In the film, Team USA member Russ Tyler, played by current SNL cast member Kenan Thompson, had a very unique shot called the “knucklepuck”. The puck would rotate end over end without spinning on it’s center.

In the Gold Medal game, Iceland did a great job of defending the knucklepuck and blocking his shots, you know something a good defense does.. Team USA really had no answer for Iceland’s defense, except one illegal move.

Russ Tyler disguised himself as Goldberg, the team’s starting goaltender, in an effort to trick Iceland. The clever ruse worked as the US tied Iceland on the last second shot (I’ll get to that part later).

However, many violations occurred in this play. First, I’m almost positive a player cannot impersonate on player on the ice. Secondly, if Team USA had replaced their goalie, in the instance Tyler for Goldberg, it would have had to be announced. Lastly, Russ Tyler quite clearly ripped his helmet off, if a goalie’s helmet is removed at any point during play then play is whistled dead. So, basically Team USA’s game tying goal should have never counted.

Getting back to the last second goal, hockey is unlike basketball and football. In those sports, if you get a shot or play off before the final second ticks away play will continue. However in hockey, a shot needs to be in the net before the last second ticks away. Basically, there is no way Russ Tyler could have ever gotten a buzzer beating shot and there would have been a minimum of 0.1 seconds left on the clock.

Team USA’s Big Jersey Switch

Before the start of the third period of the Gold Medal game, Team USA was struggling and it appeared as if the vaunted Icelandic team would win the Gold Medal. As they prepared to step onto the ice to start the third, Team USA had changed into Ducks uniforms. WHHAAAA?!?!

Those jerseys must have had some magic in it because Team USA roared back on won the Gold thanks to Russ Tyler’s goalie-switcheroo, buzzer beating kuncklepuck.

Now, I looked at the NHL rulebook and there is no discernible rule against changing uniforms mid-match, but I’m pretty sure that it would be frowned upon. That always kind of bugged me when I watched this.

Icelandic Names, or Lack Thereof

Now this one I figured out later on in my life, but still an error nonetheless.

Now, Icelandic names have suffixes that end in -son or -dottir, meaning ‘son’ or ‘daughter’. For example, if Jon Einarsson had a boy named Olafur and a daughter named Sigriour, the last name for his children would be Jonsson for his son and Jonsdottir meaning literally son or daughter of Jon.

Now that the learning lesson is out of the way, we can get on to how D2 messed it up. The star player of the Iclandic team is Gunnar Stahl, a Swedish sounding name. If they wanted to use a Swedish name, then why didn’t they use Sweden as the antagonist and not Iceland. I guess Sweden is too polite to have any real villains.

At least the screenwriters got the coach’s name right, Wolf Stansson. So, Wolf is Stan’s son, see writers, do your research on Icelandic names if you plan on using Iceland.

Having Goldberg in Net is a Liability

The comic relief of the film, Greg Goldberg, is somehow the starting goaltender for Team USA. He’s clumsy, out of shape, and uncoordinated. If this was real life, Goldberg would have a GAA higher than the national debt. Yet, he somehow won a Gold Medal. He’s the Roberto Luongo of D2, a goalie on a good team but his backup is far superior.

Meanwhile, Goldberg’s backup, Julie “The Cat” Gaffney, is faster and more coordinated in net, but is not the starter. Coach Bombay sticks by his own guys way too much, I know he and Goldberg go way back, but Gaffney is the superior goalie and a smarter one at that.

Of course I may be biased because Gaffney hails from Maine, Bangor, Maine to be exact. On second thought, no I’m not biased, Gaffney was a much better goalie.

Growing older has made me much more cynical, but all in all, it is a good movie for kids who love hockey. Just don’t read too much into it like I clearly did.

Did I miss anything else with D2: The Mighty Ducks? Comment below or send me a Tweet, @MarkWGraham

Mark Wallace Graham

Mark Wallace Graham

Mark Wallace Graham has been a writer for TheHockeyWriters.com since March 2013. Growing up in New England, Boston Bruins hockey was in my blood. Follow me on Twitter, @MarkWGraham
Mark Wallace Graham
This just in: Amy Adams is beautiful - 5 hours ago
Mark Wallace Graham

Latest posts by Mark Wallace Graham (see all)

17 Comments

  1. There’s also no way in heck a WOMAN would make that team. No room for them in this great sport.

  2. Not sure if anybody pointed this out already, but even if Gunnar Stahl did score, the goad should have been waved off, because obviously the puck has to maintain it’s forward motion, so when he stopped to set up the puck, the ref should have whistled the play dead.

    I also have to point out that even though the coach’s last name can qualify as patronymic, Stan isn’t an Icelandic name (and neither is Wolf for that matter), so and Icelander couldn’t be Stansson.

  3. Dwayne Robertson says:

    How has nobody mentioned, 2 minutes for “Roping” yet?

  4. My friends and I have actually turned these movies into a drinking game. Drink once if a blatant penalty occurs and isn’t called; Drink twice if Charlie Conway feels betrayed or wronged; Chug if Hans/Jan imparts some old-school wisdom and/or creates a turning point in the movie.

  5. The thing that drives me nuts in these movies is the constant interference that goes on all over the place. Pretty much every scene of them playing hockey, someone is getting crushed and they are no where near the puck. I think there is a part where one of the iceland players takes a run at one of the “bash brothers” completely away from the puck. The bash brother then ducks down and launches him through the glass.

    Also the goalie can not cross center ice to take that knuckle puck shot.

  6. Really wish you pointed out the Triple Deek – Gunnar Stahl’s “unstoppable” signature move.

    It is hands down the worst move I’ve ever seen. Stick handle three times at the blue line (completely baffling the goaltender, of course), stop, wait three seconds, fire a slap shot from the hash marks.

    Thankfully, Julie the Cat figured it out with the help of Coach Bombay: count the deeks.

  7. As far as the D-movies (D1, D2 and D3) go, the inaccuracies began as soon as they showed any training and on-ice scenes and ended at the end of any training and on-ice scenes. The most pathetic, unbelievable and unsportsmanlike movies ever made!!

  8. You missed the part where the fans didn’t even know that Gaffney made a save until she dropped the puck from her glove.

  9. Not only would his impersonating the goalie be illegal, it also would be impossible to do during an only 30-second timeout. They also likely would have been pressed for time changing complete uniforms (and new, not broken-in equipment) during a portion of intermission. I haven’t gone back to analyze it, but I was always skeptical about that play where someone lobs the puck to scoreboard level and another player tips it in at the net. I was curious about whether it was offsides or a two-line pass (although I’m not sure that rule was ever used in kids’ leagues).

    As for D-3, it seems pretty doubtful a high school would recruit a whole team.

  10. DoucheCharlie says:

    And how big of a douche is Charlie Conway? I submit to you that he brought the douchery to un-patriotic levels. When the team is getting there new USA jerseys (ya know, since they are playing for team USA and all), Charlie is the jagoff who gets all pissy. “We’re ducks, this stuff says Hendricks all over it.” Excuse me, ass clown, BUT IT SAYS USA ON IT TOO! Sorry, Team USA can’t be green, purple, and yellow like your previous ugly ducks jersey. Charlie, just STFU and keep on not being able to actually help your team. Sick triple deke in D1, loser. You got lucky.

  11. Also, in addition to Russ Tyler removing his helmet, it is illegal for a goaltender to cross the red line during play. Here’s a good old fashioned Patrick Roy moment to remind us all. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=429QFwN8Yy4

  12. Thought it was illegal for goalies to cross center?

  13. If I’m not mistaken, it was in D2 where they designed the play involving a puck being flipped from one end to another, and Louis Mendoza raced down the ice to have it land at his feet in front of goal crease before he bangs it in (after realizing that he stopped for the first time ever, and decided he needed to point that out to all of his teammates first). That play was clearly offside. Even as a kid I remember yelling at the the TV that it should not be allowed.

    • Captain Duck says:

      I’m also pretty sure that the puck bounced of the jumbotron over center ice. Also, I’m pretty sure that at every faceoff, Iceland’s wingers body checked and knocked over “USA’s” wingers; clearly a blatant interference.

    • Actually, Louis Mendoza’s was one of the few legit goals in that game, he had the fast break goal. The terribly offside play you’re thinking of is Dwayne Robertson to Adam Banks. Also, I’m pretty sure the Flying V was also offside at certain angles of filming.

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required Email Address * Name Email Format html text mobile