We are officially over one month into the 2026-27 NHL season. It feels like hockey’s been on for a while (at least to me), but there still hasn’t been enough of it played to know where each team is at for sure.

In The Hockey Writers‘ Week 5 edition of power rankings, where does your team sit? How does that compare to Week 4?
32-31: Chicago & Vancouver (Again)
32. Vancouver Canucks (No change)
31. Chicago Blackhawks (No change)
These two clubs have become all too familiar with this tier, and it’s doubtful that anything will change. The Vancouver Canucks finally broke their losing streak, only to be defeated twice to close out the week. A moral victory has been Elias Pettersson’s return to stardom.
The Chicago Blackhawks played a strong game against the Boston Bruins, so perhaps they won’t be in this tier for the rest of the season. But they lost that game in overtime. Chicago is at the very least capable of putting together an encouraging performance against a top team, though, which is a plus.
30-23: Probably Won’t Make the Playoffs
30. Winnipeg Jets (-8)
29. Columbus Blue Jackets (No change)
28. Los Angeles Kings (+2)
27. Anaheim Ducks (+1)
26. Philadelphia Flyers (+1)
25. Calgary Flames (+1)
24. Nashville Predators (+1)
23. San Jose Sharks (+1)
These clubs probably won’t make the playoffs, though they always could! The Winnipeg Jets are due for some positive regression—they’re not Canucks-level bad. But they’re certainly not a good team right now, something they could’ve been mistaken for earlier in the campaign. Without Connor Hellebuyck in the fold, it’s looking like a rebuild is imminent in Winnipeg.
None of the other teams in this tier really changed their trajectory in Week 5. There’s a legitimate argument to be made that the Calgary Flames are the best here, boasting a 6-3-0 record and a 52.49% expected goal share at 5-on-5 since the beginning of Week 3. It wouldn’t be all that shocking if they regress a bit, given their on-paper lineup, but their recent stretch could be a sign of things to come.
Speaking of teams turning a corner from Week 3 to now, the Philadelphia Flyers deserve a mention. They’ve been about average during that stretch, going 4-3-2 with a 51.88% expected goal share at 5-on-5, so returning to the playoffs still seems unlikely. But they were never going to be that bad, even if their points percentage hasn’t rebounded much (.375) from the nine-game losing streak.
22-16: Could Make the Playoffs
22. New York Rangers (-4)
21. Pittsburgh Penguins (-2)
20. Toronto Maple Leafs (-6)
19. St. Louis Blues (+2)
18. Seattle Kraken (-2)
17. Detroit Red Wings (+3)
16. New York Islanders (+1)
These are teams that I’m not yet convinced will make the playoffs, but I wouldn’t be totally surprised if they did. The Pittsburgh Penguins probably seem a little high here, as their 12 points in 14 games is tied with Calgary’s output. Interestingly, however, the Penguins have been an excellent 5-on-5 team, posting a 54.80% expected goal share. One of the main culprits for the gap in actual versus expected performance: their play between the pipes, predictably, has been less than stellar.
I also want to focus on the Toronto Maple Leafs. They’re tied for a wildcard spot, but I’ve always been iffy on this roster. Special teams have worked in this team’s favor, ranking in the top five for both penalty-kill (91.1% kill rate) and power-play efficiency (30.0% scoring rate). On the other hand, at 5-on-5, it’s been a return to last season. They could still make the playoffs, but a 1-2-0 week against a very soft schedule eliminated any confidence I previously had.
Finally, the Detroit Red Wings’ placement is probably worth explaining. From Week 2 to now, Detroit is tied for the 11th-best points percentage in the league, at .625. They’re doing it with solid 5-on-5 metrics, too. The sooner the Simon Edvinsson and Dylan Larkin situations are figured out, the better.
15-14: Playoff-Caliber Teams
15. Buffalo Sabres (+8)
14. Ottawa Senators (-1)
These two clubs are between “Cup contender” and “could make the playoffs.” The Buffalo Sabres really turned things around in Week 5, going 3-0-0 against an admittedly light schedule. Still, the team is now tied for 11th in points percentage in the NHL despite some rough goaltending. Getting Alex Lyon back would be huge, but there may be some rust. Especially since there’s been no indication of when he’ll return.
The Ottawa Senators are very up-and-down. They scored four straight goals against the Los Angeles Kings to force overtime after trailing 5-1, but lost anyway, made easy work of the San Jose Sharks with a 5-1 win, then blew a 3-0 lead against a struggling Anaheim Ducks side. Spoiler alert: there are six Atlantic Division teams in this tier or higher, so one of them will have to miss the playoffs. At this juncture, the odd team out is Ottawa by points percentage.
13-2: Borderline Stanley Cup Contenders
13. Washington Capitals (-1)
12. Florida Panthers (+3)
11. Vegas Golden Knights (-2)
10. Utah Mammoth (-6)
9. Dallas Stars (-6)
8. Boston Bruins (-6)
7. Montreal Canadiens (+4)
6. Tampa Bay Lightning (No change)
5. New Jersey Devils (+3)
4. Colorado Avalanche (+6)
3. Edmonton Oilers (+4)
2. Minnesota Wild (+3)
This is the most expansive “borderline Stanley Cup contender” tier to this point. These clubs are all so close together that, in any given power ranking, they could be No. 2. So, my outlook hasn’t changed all that much on the Bruins, Dallas Stars, and Utah Mammoth even though they dropped six spots each.
The Tampa Bay Lightning are the elephant in the room, with Nikita Kucherov‘s desire for a trade being made public on Oct. 30. I have a controversial opinion on the matter, though: depending on the return, I don’t think Tampa Bay is much worse than this ranking without No. 86. Brandon Hagel and Jake Guentzel are capable of leading a contender, and the Lightning are much deeper than they’re given credit for. The only concern for me is that Andrei Vasilevskiy has not played well through double-digit contests.
The race to the top in the Atlantic Division should be tight, though. The Bruins showed cracks in Week 5, and it’s not like they were playing very sustainable hockey to begin with. The Montreal Canadiens have won five straight in spite of Nick Suzuki‘s absence (yes, in spite of—their advanced metrics have been poor without him), Kucherov is still suiting up for the Bolts, and the Florida Panthers won’t go away.
Out in the Western Conference, I think it’s anyone’s game. The Minnesota Wild are the best of the bunch for me, but the Edmonton Oilers seem to be turning things around, and the Colorado Avalanche can’t be ignored as long as they have Nathan MacKinnon doing what he does.
1: Carolina Hurricanes
1. Carolina Hurricanes (No change)
I felt it was fair to put the Carolina Hurricanes alone in this tier. They were the clear-cut best team for me entering the season, and after a 0-1-1 start, they’re 11-1-1. Carolina has the deepest roster in the NHL by a wide margin, and the top of the lineup is underrately dangerous (Jackson Blake is superstar good). The big difference between this Hurricanes team and previous ones, however, is that Pyotr Kochetkov is a Vezina Trophy candidate. Nobody deserves to be uttered in the same breath as the defending champs right now.
In comparison to other weeks, there wasn’t much movement in the rankings, aside from the Cup contenders tier. Can any clubs climb out of the bottom half of the power rankings in Week 6?
Stats courtesy of Natural Stat Trick
Free Newsletter
Get Power Rankings coverage delivered to your inbox
In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.
Subscribe Free →