Jordan Staal has not looked like himself this season. He struggled in the first six games before the Hurricanes captain partially tore his calf and missed a month. In the two games since returning, the Thunder Bay, Ontario, native hasn’t looked like the dominant force the Hurricanes expect. He’s played only eight games this season. Still, the sample size is only part of the story, if anything, for the lower level of play fans have become accustomed to from the 38-year-old veteran.
A Slow Start
Staal’s top speed is only 21.59 mph this season, below the 50th percentile of NHL skaters, according to NHL Edge. He’s gotten above 20 mph only eight times, and in bursts between 18 and 20 mph, Staal has just 50, both below league average. He’s in the bottom half of the league for skating speed. Now, some of that is because he missed time due to injury, definitely. However, is it all of it? That’s open to debate, and the concern gets worse if it isn’t entirely the calf problem he dealt with.
Staal has never been the fastest skater, but he wasn’t this slow last season. He was in the 87th percentile for top speed, at 23.11. He only got above 22 mph three times, but he was getting up to that speed. Staal had 72 bursts between 20-22 mph and 447 bursts between 18-20 mph. Both of those numbers dwarf what he’s doing now. He looks like he’s lost at least a step based on what we saw even a season ago.
Underlying Regression
Staal’s underlying numbers are deeply concerning. According to Natural Stat Trick, he has a goals-for per 60 (GF/60) of 0.66. He has never been expected to provide offense, but that low is suboptimal. His goals against per 60 (GA/60) is 1.99, which is good, but it still leaves him with a 25% goals-for percentage. Essentially, the Hurricanes score 25% of the goals that occur when Staal is on the ice; they give up the other 75%. That’s not ideal in a goal-scoring competition like hockey. He had a GF/60 of 2.49 last season. It’s not outrageously high, but it’s a huge gap from where he is now.

Counting stats are no better for the Canes’ centerman. Staal has no points in eight games and is a minus-2. He dominated the Vegas Golden Knights in the Stanley Cup Final six months ago, posting the highest faceoff percentage ever recorded in a Stanley Cup Final: 68%. Now, he’s still performing in the faceoff dot, but he’s losing some of that responsibility. In overtime against the Montreal Canadiens, Staal didn’t take his typical faceoff to open the bonus frame; Sebastian Aho did. It’s a single faceoff, but it is symbolic of where he is right now.
Short-Term Struggle or Permanent Decline?
Carolina must find a solution. Staal is supposed to make $4.9 million against the cap next season, but his performance bonuses could raise that to $10 million. If this is a temporary struggle and he gets through it, that’s not something that needs addressing. However, Staal is 38. At some point, age catches up with everyone. If this isn’t a slow start to the season, compounded with the remains of a calf tear (which it definitely could be), then the Hurricanes have decisions to make. Their cap situation is so good that it wouldn’t change much on the roster, but that much money for someone playing the way Staal is does create issues for other potential additions if he doesn’t turn it around.
If Staal is still dealing with issues from his injury, there aren’t many reasons to keep him in the lineup. Jesperi Kotkaniemi played superbly while Staal was out. Kotkaniemi isn’t necessarily better than Staal, but he is clearly capable of helping the Hurricanes get into the win column. If Staal is still struggling, letting him sit is better for everyone than forcing him to accelerate on a calf that isn’t up to the task. The Hurricanes have the depth to let their captain rest and keep him healthy for when the games become important in April and May.
Whether it’s eight bad games, injury, age, or a slight Stanley Cup hangover, the Hurricanes need to find a solution. Staal is more than capable of pulling himself out of this slump, if that’s what this is. If it’s an injury, the Hurricanes can let him rest and recover. Ultimately, we only see the end product. Whatever the cause, it needs addressing so Staal can get back to his best as soon as possible.
Free Newsletter
Get Carolina Hurricanes coverage delivered to your inbox
In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.
Subscribe Free →