Anaheim DucksBoston BruinsBuffalo SabresCalgary FlamesCarolina HurricanesChicago BlackhawksColorado AvalancheColumbus Blue JacketsDallas StarsDetroit Red WingsEdmonton OilersFlorida PanthersLos Angeles KingsMinnesota WildMontreal CanadiensNashville PredatorsNew Jersey DevilsNew York IslandersNew York RangersOttawa SenatorsPhiladelphia FlyersPittsburgh PenguinsSan Jose SharksSeattle KrakenSt. Louis BluesTampa Bay LightningToronto Maple LeafsUtah Hockey ClubVancouver CanucksVegas Golden KnightsWashington CapitalsWinnipeg Jets

Hurricanes Can Find More Offense From the Defense Internally

The Carolina Hurricanes are reportedly considering Erik Karlsson of the Pittsburgh Penguins, according to Pierre LeBrun’s TSN report from a couple of days ago. After an unsuccessful attempt to add John Carlson to the team when they traded for his rights in the summer, the Hurricanes are still looking for more offensive production, which makes sense. The top four consists of Jaccob Slavin, Jalen Chatfield, Sean Walker, and K’Andre Miller: four defensive staples, but none provide the high-end offense you are looking for.

The issue is that the Hurricanes already have a third pairing boasting multiple dynamic offensive defensemen. Between Shayne Gostisbehere and the returning Alexander Nikishin, the Hurricanes have one of the best third pairings in hockey. Both can score individually, and together they create a matchup nightmare. So if the Hurricanes want more offense from their blue line, the obvious solution seems to be in-house. Promoting either player could provide the back-end scoring the team currently wants in the trade market.

Russian Rocket

The obvious answer is Nikishin. Carolina missed him when he wasn’t playing because of a contract holdout, but now he’s back and a great option. Young players typically want bigger roles, and this could help Nikishin by giving him more runway to live up to that booming potential. With the left side of the Hurricanes blue line clogged, a move to the right, where Nikishin is equally comfortable, could give him a new chance to develop. Moving Nikishin up to play beside Slavin feels like the clearest solution to both problems. While it’s true Nikishin is still adjusting to the NHL, Slavin offers a security blanket as he continues improving under head coach Rod Brind’Amour.

Nikishin’s talent is abundant, so it shouldn’t take long for him to handle the task next to Slavin. Pairing his booming shot and physicality with the NHL’s best defensive defenseman creates a more difficult pairing to contain in all three zones. It would change how much Brind’Amour could rely on his top pairing, while also spreading the wealth more evenly across all three pairings.

With an expected goals for per 60 minutes (xGF/60) of 3.24 over his NHL career, according to Natural Stat Trick, it’s clear Nikishin can add offensive production. He’ll help generate more chances when the Hurricanes can get set up in the offensive zone, and that one-timer that flirts with 100 mph isn’t something defenders will want to block. That creates another opening, and it makes Nikishin a solid fit on the top pairing.

Phenomenal Phantom

If you want someone with more experience, the answer is Gostisbehere. Across two spells in Raleigh, he has already learned the defensive system the Hurricanes deploy. The Ghost Bear is Carolina’s premier offensive defenseman, and in 21 games this season, he has three goals and 13 assists for 16 points, leading the Hurricanes’ defensemen. The only knock on his production is that he’s a bit more reliant on the power play for his offensive output than you’d ideally like, but given the chance, he can be a 5-on-5 menace too.

Last season, Gostisbehere had 13 goals and 37 assists for 50 points in just 55 games, and, more importantly, 32 of those came at even strength. Gostisbehere can undoubtedly produce at 5-on-5, and his eight 5-on-5 points so far this season could justify moving him up the lineup if the Hurricanes feel like a change is necessary. Gostisbehere is typically integral to driving the offense from the blue line for Carolina, and getting him closer to his totals from last season could benefit the team greatly.

Shayne Gostisbehere Carolina Hurricanes
Shayne Gostisbehere, Carolina Hurricanes (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

Next to Slavin, Gostisbehere would have a simple task: get the puck to the net. It’s what makes him such a compatible fit with this “shoot-on-sight” system the Hurricanes employ. His ability to find a shooting lane through traffic drives his strong offensive output, so pairing that with someone who can help him defensively, like Slavin, would create a pairing where they cover each other’s weaknesses. That balance would make the pairing more effective overall. It feels like a hand-in-glove fit for the Hurricanes.

Why In-House Options Are Better

Carolina tried to land Carlson in the summer. They are being tied to Karlsson again now, if Pittsburgh looks at trading the aging veteran. If the Hurricanes have these offensive defensemen sitting on the third pair dominating from a distance, looking outside the organization for offensive help on the blue line is harder to justify, especially when the alternative seems to be a 35-year-old from a division rival with a long history of injuries. There are justifications for acquiring Karlsson, but without at least looking at the options the team already has, it’s a harder move to explain. If one of the other two can fill the role now, the assets and money it would take to get Karlsson could be spent elsewhere.

Karlsson has been having a good season with the Penguins, but the comparison to Gostisbehere still highlights the performance gap. Gostisbehere has a 4.89 goals for per 60 (GF/60) at 5-on-5 this season. That’s absurdly high, and it goes well with his 3.95 xGF/60. Karlsson has a 2.7 GF/60 and a 3.00 xGF/60. Both are good, but they’re just bettered by Gostisbehere. These are on-ice stats, and the Penguins are a much weaker team than Carolina. It doesn’t mean Karlsson is bad; it just means Gostisbehere is deserving of a look before turning elsewhere.

It doesn’t have to be Gostisbehere; it could be Nikishin. Both are capable offensive defensemen who would add more punch to the top pairing, which is one of the few things lacking from the back end so far this season. If the Hurricanes want more production from the blue line, it makes more sense to look within the organization before turning to external options. The asset cost of a trade for an offensive defenseman like that could keep the Hurricanes from adding elsewhere, so if a viable solution is already on the roster, it makes more sense to exhaust that before making a move for the sake of it.

Free Newsletter

Get Carolina Hurricanes coverage delivered to your inbox

In-depth analysis, breaking news, and insider takes - free.

Subscribe Free →
Conor Power

Conor Power

Conor is a freelance writer that has covered the Carolina Hurricanes, San Jose Sharks, and New York Rangers for multiple outlets. Now covers the New York Rangers for The Hockey Writers, specializing in hockey history and statistical analysis.

More by Conor Power →