Goalie Controversy Brewing in Winnipeg

This past offseason, there were many questions and concerns, regarding the goaltending issues of the Winnipeg Jets. Those concerns were raised when general manager Kevin Cheveldayoff said that Ondrej Pavelec would remain the number one goalie at the end of last season. Many fans took to Twitter to vent their frustration on that announcement.

The other concern regarding the men between the pipes was the experience, or lack thereof, for backup Michael Hutchinson. Coming into this season, Hutchinson only appeared in three games, winning two of those games. His .943 save percentage and 1.64 goals against average were excellent, but the sample size was just too small to call him the saviour in the crease.

Hutch Comes Up Clutch

(Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports)
(Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports)

So far this season, Hutchinson has been a revelation for the Jets. In eight appearance, the Barrie, Ontario native leads the NHL with a .947 save percentage and a 1.56 goals against average. Again, the sample size is small but Hutchinson does deserve more opportunities to prove himself.

His best game came on November 28 against the Boston Bruins. The game was a personal one for Hutch, as it was the Bruins who drafted him in the third round back in 2008. Hutchinson was simply brilliant, stopping 36 out of 38 Bruin shots, many of them in the spectacular variety. Sadly, Hutchinson’s teammates didn’t have their goal-scoring sticks with them as the Jets fell 2-1 in overtime to the Bruins.

Hutchinson has been the calm, steadying force for the Jets this season. Whenever the Jets are hemmed in their own zone, it is Hutchinson that comes up with a critical save, or uses his puck handling skills to make the outlet pass, and start the rush up ice.

Improved Pavelec

Winnipeg Jet ONDREJ PAVELEC - Photo by Andy Martin Jr
Winnipeg Jet ONDREJ PAVELEC – Photo by Andy Martin Jr

That isn’t to say Ondrej Pavelec’s play hasn’t improved. Believe it or not, the Czech Republic keeper has posted better numbers so far this season. In 21 appearances this season, Pavelec has posted a .919 save percentage and a 2.21 goals against average. For the sake of comparison, Pavelec has a .906 save percentage and a 2.91 goals against average in his career.

The biggest issue with Pavelec is sustainability. In past years, Pavelec has shown flashes of brilliance, and has teased Jet fans that he has finally turned the corner, only to crash and burn as the grind of the season takes its toll.

Pavelec’s hefty contract also plays a role in terms of playing time. With two years left on a deal that pays him $3.9 million per season, Jets management will make sure Pavelec sees as much ice time as possible, in order to justify that contract. To put it mildly, $3.9 million is way too much to pay a backup goalie.

How Does This End?

In a recent article in The Hockey News, author Jared Clinton suggested this:

“But in goaltending it’s not about what you’ve done in the past, it’s about whether or not you can keep it up. For Hutchinson, it seems as though that consistency is coming around. The amount of games to draw from is still smaller than most goaltenders, but his play has been steady at every professional level he’s played. From the ECHL to the AHL and, now, in the NHL, Hutchinson has only shown that he’s prepared to take on whatever challenge he’s given.”


What Jets management will have to decide at some point is what direction they want to go. If Hutchinson continues to play well, the Jets will have to figure out if they say forget the contract and go with the hot goalie, or continue to ride Pavelec in hopes of getting their money’s worth. Hutchinson’s good play might actually benefit Pavelec in the long-term because it would provide some rest and leave Pavelec fresher for the stretch drive if Hutchinson stumbles.

For now, the Jets will ride two goalies for as long as possible. If the team keeps winning, they won’t mess with the formula. But if a roadblock does rise up, you can be sure the men guarding the net will be at the forefront of the story.