History Isn’t on Oilers Side Regarding Slow Start

Saying the 2017-18 season isn’t going according to plan for the Edmonton Oilers might be the biggest understatement of the year so far. Edmonton’s offense has completely disappeared, and the special teams have been disastrous. Even head coach Todd McLellan has busted out Craig MacTavish’s old line blender to no avail. The Oilers dropped another tightly contested game against the Pittsburgh Penguins on Wednesday night.

Edmonton blew a 2-1 lead late in the second, and the special teams once again let this team down. The Oilers are now 3-7-1 through the first 11 games of the season. Not only that, but the team is currently 30th in the league’s standings. They’re also dead last in goals scored with 22 (2.18 goals/game). The power play has fallen to 13.2% (29th), and the penalty kill has dipped to 68.3% (30th).

McLellan McDavid Lucic Oilers
Todd McLellan (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

At the 11th game mark last year, Edmonton was tied for fourth in the NHL with a 7-3-1 record. The power play was mildly better at 15.2% (21st), and the penalty kill was amongst the NHL’s best at 90.9% (2nd). Most importantly, the Oilers were scoring goals (34 goals, 5th in NHL), something that’s been hard to come by this year. There’s rightfully a lot of frustration. The question now is if this slow start ends up shooting Edmonton in the foot.

Historically How Have Similar NHL Teams Finished?

Historically, teams with similar records to the Oilers haven’t fared well. Over the past three seasons, only two of the 15 teams with similar starts qualified for the playoffs. Those two teams were the 2016-17 Nashville Predators and the 2015-16 Anaheim Ducks. Both teams stumbled out of the gate but played near or over a .600 winning percentage (W%) through the final 71 games of the season.

Connor McDavid Oilers
Connor McDavid (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

The rest of the teams averaged a .453 W% through their final 71 games and picked up around 64 points. If you factor this year’s Oilers into that same equation, you’re looking at Edmonton finishing the year with 71 points.


After 11 Games

End of Season

Season Team W-L-OT PTS W% W-L-T PTS W% Final 71 Finish
2016-17 Arizona 4-7-0 8 .364 30-42-10 70 .437 27th
2016-17 Nashville 3-5-3 9 .409 41-29-12 94 .599 16th
2016-17 Vancouver 4-6-1 9 .409 30-43-9 69 .423 29th
2015-16 Edmonton 4-7-0 8 .364 31-43-8 70 .437 29th
2015-16 Buffalo 4-7-0 8 .364 35-36-11 81 .514 23rd
2015-16 Colorado 3-7-1 7 .318 39-39-4 82 .528 21st
2015-16 Anaheim 2-7-2 6 .273 46-25-11 103 .683 6th
2015-16 Toronto 2-7-2 6 .273 29-42-11 69 .444 30th
2015-16 Calgary 2-8-1 5 .227 35-40-7 77 .507 26th
2015-16 Columbus 2-9-0 4 .182 34-40-8 76 .535 27th
2014-15 Edmonton 4-6-1 9 .409 24-44-14 62 .373 28th
2014-15 Arizona 4-6-1 9 .409 24-50-8 56 .331 29th
2014-15 Columbus 4-7-0 8 .364 42-35-5 89 .570 23rd
2014-15 Carolina 3-6-2 8 .364 30-41-11 71 .444 26th
2014-15 Buffalo 2-8-1 5 .227 23-51-8 54 .345 30th

Outside of last year’s 7-3-1 start, Edmonton is otherwise on pace with the starts they’ve had over the past three seasons. In 2015-16, Edmonton went 4-7-0 in their first 11 games and finished 29th overall. In 2014-15, the Oilers started 4-6-1 for nine points and ultimately finished 28th overall. Based off that is it reasonable to say that the 2016-17 Oilers overachieved? Was it a mirage? Is Edmonton actually still a bad team?

Optimism & The American Thanksgiving Theory

Even then let’s consider the Oilers are just off to a terrible start and are better than they appear. Maybe this slow start is a mirage after all, and this team belongs in the same conversation as those Predators and Ducks teams that bucked the trend. Let’s pretend Edmonton regains their form and finishes the final 71 games with last years .628 W%.

That means this team could still pick up an optimistic 89 points the rest of the way. That would give these Oilers 96 points overall, enough to qualify for a wild-card spot based off last year’s standings. If you crunch the numbers on this year’s projected standings, it looks like it’ll take around 90 points to qualify for the playoffs. So, it’s not exactly panic time for Edmonton because there’s still time to right the ship.

Cam Talbot Oilers
Cam Talbot (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

Unfortunately, there isn’t a whole lot of time left. There’s a thought that if a team is well outside the playoff picture after US Thanksgiving, they likely won’t make it. American Thanksgiving fell on November 24th last season, more or less the 20 game mark for a lot of teams. Here’s what the NHL standings looked like. Teams in red were outside the playoff picture at American Thanksgiving.


Atlantic Metropolitian Central Pacific
Team PTS Team PTS Team PTS Team PTS
Montreal 30 NY Rangers 29 Chicago 28 Edmonton 25
Tampa Bay 27 Pittsburgh 27 St. Louis 25 San Jose 23
Ottawa 23 Washington 26 Minnesota 22 Los Angeles 23
Boston 22 Columbus 23 Nashville 21 Anaheim 22
Florida 21 New Jersey 23 Dallas 21 Calgary 19
Toronto 20 Philadelphia 21 Winnipeg 20 Vancouver 18
Detroit 19 Carolina 20 Colorado 18 Arizona 14
Buffalo 19 NY Islanders 16

Of those 14 teams that were outside the playoffs at American Thanksgiving, only three teams successfully turned things around to make the playoffs eventually. The three teams (listed in green) were the Boston Bruins, Calgary Flames, and Toronto Maple Leafs. Ironically, all three would be bounced in the first round. So if history is any indicator, the Oilers are in tough. If they continue to play poorly by the 20-game mark, the likelihood of Edmonton qualifying for the playoffs becomes a very steep mountain to climb.


Atlantic Metropolitian Central Pacific
Team PTS Team PTS Team PTS Team PTS
Montreal 103 Washington 118 Chicago 109 Anaheim 105
Ottawa 98 Pittsburgh 111 Minnesota 106 Edmonton 103
Boston 95 Columbus 108 St. Louis 99 San Jose 99
Toronto 95 NY Rangers 102 Nashville 94 Calgary 94
Tampa Bay 94 NY Islanders 94 Winnipeg 87 Los Angeles 86
Florida 81 Philadelphia 88 Dallas 79 Arizona 70
Detroit 79 Carolina 87 Colorado 48 Vancouver 69
Buffalo 78 New Jersey 70

What Does It All Mean?

The current 10-game stretch the Oilers are on is pivotal and could have dire implications for their season. History is not on Edmonton’s side, and the hill is slowly becoming a mountain. As Thursday night’s games were unfolding, the Oilers were seven points out of a playoff spot. If they continue playing with a .318 W%, they could be more than 12 points out of the playoffs by the 20-game mark.

As each passing game goes by, things become that much more strenuous, especially if you’re not picking up points. Edmonton’s gone 1-3-1 in their last five and picked up just three of ten points in that span. Points in October do matter. There’s time, not an abundance of time, but you don’t need to be hitting the panic button just yet. Everyone should, however, be slowly inching towards it and start opening the glass case around the panic button though.

Connor McDavid of the Edmonton Oilers
Connor McDavid (Photo by Andy Devlin/NHLI via Getty Images)

The league’s worst special teams have to improve. This team needs to find a way to start scoring goals. If they went two-for-five on the power play against the Penguins and maybe killed three-of-five on the penalty kill, they would’ve won. Todd McLellan is banging his head against a wall right now, but the players have yet to respond. You can’t win in today’s NHL without having balanced scoring and half-functioning special teams.

In the end, there are nine-games left until the 20-game mark. If Edmonton picks up 13 of 18 available points (6-2-1), they’ll suddenly be right back in the playoff race. Admittedly a .722 W% over this span might be wishful thinking, but it just goes to show how dire the Oilers season is quickly becoming.

Connor McDavid might be one of the game’s best players, but the rest of the team needs to be better and not rely on McDavid to bail them out every night. The depth of this roster needs to start producing because the fact of the matter is no one wants any of the Oilers’ struggling players. If they do, Edmonton general manager Peter Chiarelli won’t be dealing from a position of strength.

Do you think the Oilers can turn this around by the 20-game mark? Let me know in the comments below!

Check out my latest podcast appearance, this time on the Oilers YYC podcast discussing Edmonton’s slow start. Is it time to panic yet Oilers fans?