Next in Line: Top Ten Goaltending Prospects

Goaltending is always a major theme for most teams. Either they have it or are looking for it, and no other position is a singularly important as a team’s netminder.

This season it has been an especially hot button topic. Coming off a record number of goaltenders being moved by the trade deadline, there are a number of new faces on different teams and no end of storylines. Especially with big name goaltenders like Ryan Miller and Roberto Luongo being moved.

We have also seen some exciting young goaltenders come up and impress in their rookie seasons. Names like Martin Jones, Antti Raanta, Frederick Anderson, Eddie Lack and Darcy Kuemper among others have dazzled at time in their NHL debuts en route to earning a regular role.

So who is next in line? Who are the top young prospects ready to make their mark?

Here’s a look at the top ten goaltenders waiting in the wings.

(Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports)
John Gibson has impressed at every level (Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports)

1. John Gibson

Current Team: Norfolk Admirals (AHL)
NHL Team: Anaheim Ducks

Arguably the top goaltending prospect in hockey, Gibson is the future No.1 in Anaheim. Possesses all of the attributes, skills and mental toughness you could want in a goaltender.

Currently starting for Norfolk but with Jonas Hiller a free agent and Viktor Fasth traded to Edmonton, the writing is on the wall for him to seize a job next season.

He has been impressive at every stop including junior and his first year of pro. He also has a decorated international career with impressive performances at the World Junior Championships and was even named to the USA Men’s World Championship team last year as a 19 year old and did not look out of place.

ETA: 2014-15

2. Malcolm Subban

Current Team: Providence Bruins (AHL)
NHL Team: Boston Bruins
Malcolm Subban, world juniors, Boston Bruins
Subban will get his chance, but will it be in Boston? Charles LeClaire-US PRESSWIRE)

One of the most athletic goaltending prospects since Marc-Andre Fleury, Subban is an intriguing combination of quickness,  athleticsm, positioning and poise. Has all the tools to be an elite goaltender, but is still a couple of years away.

Has had a very successful junior career with the Belleville Bulls and has adjusted to the pro game in Providence better than many had expected.

Currently blocked in the Bruins system by Tuukka Rask, but whether it’s in Boston or another city, if Subban continues to progress as he has so far, he will be a No.1 for a long time. 

ETA: 2015-16


3. Andrei Vasilevski

Current Team: Ufa Salavat Yulayev (KHL)
NHL Team: Tampa Bay Lightning

The play of Ben Bishop this season has halted some of the desperate cries for Vasilevski to get to North America and all of a sudden the Tampa Bay Lightning goaltending goes from a weakness to a potential position of strength. The emergence of Bishop gives Vasilevski the necessary time to mature and progress and and be ready to make the jump.

He has excellent size and mobility, which combined with solid positioning and fundamentals, make him one of the top goaltending prospects in hockey.

ETA: 2015-16

4. Jake Allen

Current Team: Chicago Wolves (AHL)
NHL Team: St. Louis Blues

Looked good when he got into game action with the Blues last season and waiting on his turn to get the call again. Previously blocked by Jaroslav Halak and Brian Elliott, he is now blocked by Elliott and Ryan Miller. Whether or not Miller resigns in St. Louis will greatly affect Allen.

He has been arguably the AHL’s best goaltender this season for the Wolves and is at or near the top in most goaltending categories.

It’s not a question of if he will get his chance, but when.

ETA: 2014-15

Jake Allen
Jake Allen (Scott Rovak-USA TODAY Sports)

5. Philipp Grubauer

Current Team: Hershey Bears
NHL Team: Washington Capitals

Grubauer has already shown in limited action this season what he can do at the NHL level.

The Capitals goaltending as a whole has been disappointing this season, sparking the trade of Michael Neuvirth for Jaroslav Halak amongst other pieces. That doesn’t diminish Grubauer’s stock in the Caps system though and he should be ready for full time duty with the team next season.

Halak is a free agent and aside from an inconsistent season currently, Braden Holtby will likely return as the starter next season. Should he falter though, Grubauer will be ready to assume a bigger role.

ETA: 2014-15

6. Joni Ortio

Current Team: Calgary Flames (NHL)
Joni Ortio (Ross Bonander/THW)
Ortio has already made the jump to Calgary from Abbotsford (Ross Bonander/THW)

Just recently called up and started his fifth NHL game, Ortio has spent the majority of the season tending net for the AHL’s Abbotsford Heat.

With a trade deadline deal of Reto Berra to the Colorado Avalanche, Ortio has been given his opportunity and has a 2.24 GAA in his five starts.

The 22 year old Finnish product was a 6th round pick in 2009, and will have the rest of the season to prove he belongs to stay in the NHL.

ETA: 2014

7. Jack Campbell

Current Team: Texas Stars (AHL)
NHL Team: Dallas Stars

Campbell entered professional hockey with a lot of hype and expectation as a No.11 overall pick in 2011. His transition to professional hockey has taken a little longer than expected, but the 22 year old Campbell is poised to take the next step and is comfortable where he is in his development;

“If you were to ask me when I was 18 and drafted [No. 11], when I thought I would be playing in the NHL, I would have thought I would have been able to make it by now for sure,”

“I know it’s all about growing up,” Campbell said. “Even if I did dominate the last three years, I probably still wouldn’t be out there because it’s all about the process of maturing a goalie and not rushing him … I get that now. I’m just trying to be the best goalie I can be, wherever that may be. I just want to play a lot of hockey this year and wherever that is, I’m ready to succeed.”

The Stars currently have a tandem of Kari Lehtonen and Tim Thomas as they push for a playoff spot. Past this season though Thomas is a rental and Lehtonen, while talented, is often injured. With a spot open on next year’s roster he will have the opportunity to battle with Christopher Nilstrop for the opening.

ETA: 2014-15

8. Petr Mrazek

Current Team: Grand Rapids Griffins (AHL)
NHL Team: Detroit Red Wings

Mrazek has already seen time with the Red Wings over the past two years, primarily due to the injuries to starter Jimmy Howard. In 10 appearances he has a 2.01 GAA and .918 save percentage. With Howard signed through 2018, it would appear top spot in the Red Wings net is locked up for some time. However with Howard’s injury history a lot can happen between now and then.

Of the other options in Detroit, Mrazek has the most upside. Jonas Gustavsson is a pending free agent and Mrazek has soundly outplayed his partner in Grand Rapids, Tomas McCollum.

He may not be ready for full time duty just yet, but he’s not far off.

ETA: 2014-15

(Gary A. Vasquez-USA TODAY Sports)
Mrazek has seen some injury-replacement time with the Wings already(Gary A. Vasquez-USA TODAY Sports)

9. Mark Visentin

Current Team: Portland Pirates (AHL)
NHL Team: Phoenix Coyotes

Another first round pick from 2011, Visentin may not have had the same success in the AHL that he had in junior, but his progression is still right on track.

Seeing the lion’s share of the starts for a last place Portland Pirates team, his numbers are certainly not near the top of the heap, but don’t tell the whole story. He leads the AHL with 43 games played and is in the league leaders in shots against.

With Mike Smith signed through 2019, Visentin will have plenty of opportunity to develop before being promoted. With improved play he could also be a very valuable trade chip for the Coyotes and see an NHL net before 2019.

ETA: 2015-16

10. Zach Fucale

Current Team: Halifax Mooseheads (QMJHL)
NHL Team: Montreal Canadiens

Ranked 10th on this list because of his age and is still years away, being drafted less than a year ago, but has as much potential as anyone here. He has great mental makeup and all the tools you would wish for in a starting goaltender.

He still has a lot of seasoning to go through and is just 18 years old, but will no doubt climb this list in the coming years and could get to the NHL faster than people think.

Blocked right now by Carey Price, there’s a lot that can happen over the next few years which will largely depend on Price’s play and Fucale’s progression.

ETA: 2017-18


 Follow Carl on twitter @carlTHW and Google+ for more articles

5 thoughts on “Next in Line: Top Ten Goaltending Prospects”

  1. Lists are never in the order you want so I almost never pay attention to where they’re ranked, but you nailed it on the head with who’s in your top 10 for sure.

    There are some good kids coming up in goal right now.

  2. Not sure how you can have Vasilevski behind Malcolm Subban. Most lists don’t even have Subban in the same conversation as Vasi or Gibson. KHL is a step up over AHL IMO. Vasilevski’s stats are a little better than Subban and he plays in KHL. He’s been playing all year with his Tampa Bay Lightning mask/gear, his contract is also up after the season. I expect him to split time with Gudlevskis in Syracuse next season. He should get an eventual Call up during the season, because Lindback isn’t very good.

    I don’t think Subban should be #2, as most lists have Gibson and Vasi pretty even, I have seen Gibson in front of Vasi, and Vasi in front of Gibson. What I’m saying is i’m kinda surprised Malcolm Subban is in front of Vasilevski. You might want to check with some scouts. Vasilevski also forced the team to released a veteran KHL goaltender to make a spot for him. 14-8 record with 2.21 GAA .923sv% is pretty good for a team that doesn’t have a KHL superstar on the team. Last 2 days he stopped 91/94 shots to tie their playoff series to 2 games a piece (inlcuding 2 big saves in a 3OT win) Here’s the links to the big saves….

    • Hi Mathieu, thanks for your input. There was a lot of consideration as to where to put the top three and in what order. I felt that what I have seen from Gibson, he got the nod over the previous two. Certainly there is a case to be made for Vasilevski over Subban, and you make a compelling argument, especially with his recent play. Time will tell and we will see what happens in the next few years. I think both will have long NHL careers, I have just been continuously impressed with Subban and his progression and gave him a slight edge on future potential.

Comments are closed.