It is highly agreeable that within the first three years of the NWHL there have been three different Isobel Cup champions. The natural parity of the league is both enticing and even endearing at the same time. It is a good product for those who have long supported the NWHL, as well as those who have just recently caught the itch. The exclamation point was added when the Isobel Cup Final between the Metropolitan Riveters and Buffalo Beauts became a sellout.
Successful times in women’s hockey such as we are seeing these days have to bring about pause where we not only look back on where things have come from, but we give thanks to those who got it going. There will only ever be one first NWHL season, and only a select few were inaugural members of the founding four teams. It may sound odd to talk about three years ago as being so distant, but much has transpired between the NWHL’s 2015-16 season and that of 2017-18. There is importance in recalling the league’s initial trailblazers. After all, they gave the league credence to begin with.
THW had a chance to get caught up with original Buffalo Beauts defender Kelly McDonald. She was kind enough to talk about those early beginnings of the NWHL, what she has been up to since, and her current thoughts on where the league stands. It was rather nice to get reacquainted with an old friend of NWHL proponents, and we hope that you will feel so too.
Coming to Buffalo With Brownie
One of the original NWHLers Harrison Browne just got his name on the Isobel Cup for the second straight season. An original member of the Beauts himself, Browne won the Cup with Buffalo during 2016-17. He then hoisted it again in the league’s third season after coming out of retirement, but this time as a member of the Metropolitan Riveters. Browne also happens to be a best friend of McDonald, and was paramount in the two of them ending up in Buffalo for the first season.
“This is actually sort of a funny story,” McDonald explained. “I graduated from Maine in 2014, but the NWHL’s inaugural season wasn’t until 2015 so I had an entire year off between D1 and pro. I had considered playing in the CWHL during that year off, but unfortunately it wasn’t a feasible option as I had to leave my nights and weekends available for work.”
McDonald had a very successful career as a Black Bear at the University of Maine. A defender out of Ancaster, Ontario, Canada, she played four years of NCAA hockey in Maine, including her final two years as a teammate of Browne’s. In 130 games for Maine, McDonald compiled eight goals and 21 assists for 29 points, plus 76 penalty minutes.
“When the NWHL came about,” McDonald continued to explain, “playing again crossed my mind because it would be able to provide income, but that was about as far as it went. It wasn’t until the Buffalo tryouts were happening when my friend ‘Brownie’ begged me to go with him, primarily to support him. We were roommates at Maine and, of course, I love to support him in all endeavors. So I attended the scrimmage on the second day of the camp. I got a call from Linda Mroz (original Beauts GM) not long after that and then things just took off from there.”
Playing That First Season With the Beauts
After learning that she had made the squad and would forever be an original Beaut, McDonald compiled an admirable first professional season. Between regular season and playoffs, she appeared in all but one of Buffalo’s games that first year. In her 17 regular season games, McDonald finished third among Beauts’ defenders in scoring with no goals and nine assists. Those nine helpers were second most on the team after a three-way tie for first by Olympians Meghan Duggan, Megan Bozek and Emily Pfalzer who each had 10.
“There were many aspects of that first season that I cherish,” McDonald recalled to THW, as she looked back. “The best part had to have been the team and getting the opportunity to play with some incredible talent and wonderful people. I still maintain those friendships and manage to see many of those players every so often. Another great aspect of that season was simply the raw excitement of being part of something new and potentially great. The fan base in Buffalo and the support for the league was incredible.”
Buffalo would ride that support into the NWHL postseason. They finished third overall in the inaugural year with a record 5-9-4 and scoring 56 goals in 18 games. Facing the Whale in the opening round, the Beauts were able to dispel Connecticut in a hard fought, best-of-three series that went the distance. Reaching the championship round against Boston, Buffalo would lose in two straight.
“The semi-final series against Connecticut was huge,” McDonald explained, still recalling the series with much fervor.”We had struggled against them throughout the entire regular season, but we really came together to grind it out against a really good team. We earned our ticket to the Isobel Cup Final where we gave Boston a really tough fight.”
What an Isobel Cup Means to Buffalo
The Buffalo Beauts are the only team in NWHL history to have played in each Final since the league’s inception. While they would suffer losses in McDonald’s season with the team and again in the third year, Isobel was all Buffalo’s in the sophomore year of the league. The victory created a love affair between the team and the city that has blossomed more and more ever since.
Many of McDonald’s teammates from the first season helped bring the Cup home to the “City of Good Neighbors”. Inaugural Beauts Browne, Pflazer, Bozek, Kelley Steadman, Kourtney Kunichika, Paige Harrington, Devon Skeats, and goaltender Brianne McLaughlin all returned in Season Two to capture the trophy.
“It was great to see Buffalo take the crown in the second season.” McDonald shared. “I still had many friends on that team and I knew how passionate they were and how passionate the city of Buffalo was, so it was fantastic that they were able to bring the Championship home. It was a very deserving group. The fact that there have been three different champions over three seasons is also very telling of how competitive this league is. It’s great for the game.”
Would McDonald Ever Lace ‘Em up Again Professionally?
After the Beauts won the 2016-17 Cup a number of those aforementioned players retired, including McDonald’s good friend Browne. Oddly enough, some of the retirements would not last very long. Skeats would come out of retirement to suit up for the CWHL’s Markham Thunder for the 2017-18 season and ended up winning that league’s Clarkson Cup championship trophy. Browne’s retirement was shortly lived too. Having announced it in Mar. 2017 after winning the Cup with Buffalo, he joined up with the Riveters that August. Thankfully he did, as it brought Metropolitan their first Cup and Browne his second.
— Buffalo Beauts (@BuffaloBeauts) March 29, 2018
Just 26 years old at the time of this interview, McDonald herself is still plenty young enough that she too could put retirement on hold and return to professional playing. It was not surprising when she informed THW that offers had been out there as recent as this season. McDonald is a heck of a good defender and her understanding of the game would be paramount in any defense corps she would be part of.
“I was actually asked by a number of people to go out for the CW this year,” she shared, “but I really wanted to commit to coaching. That’s where my involvement with hockey is now and I am very happy with it. Plus, it was hard enough recovering from that year off between University and the NWHL – I don’t think I my body could handle doing that again,” she half-joked, half-seriously stated.
Kelly McDonald the Hockey Coach
So let’s talk a bit about McDonald’s coaching, especially since this is where her passion lies and where she is already helping to foster youth. It takes a special person to become a coach and a special person to be a teacher. Interpersonal relationships, imparting knowledge, teaching a skill to others – these are not natural undertakings for everyone. These are important matters of both the heart and the mind.
“Since my retirement from the game, I have been teaching at a private school for elite athletes,” McDonald told us. “It’s a great atmosphere for me as I am able to relate to my students and share my experience as a former elite student-athlete. My students respect my experience as a hockey player and it allows me to form a fantastic relationship with them.”
McDonald is an integral educator at Everest Academy in the Toronto-area. It is considered one of the fastest growing K-12 private schools in the nation, and it promotes excellence among sports, music, arts and academics among its student populous. Outside of teaching, McDonald coaches and assists young women in one of the top women’s leagues for young girls throughout the world.
“I also coach in the PWHL (Provincial Women’s Hockey League), which is the top minor league for Girls’ hockey in Ontario,” McDonald explained. “My players have ambitions to play hockey in University and beyond, so my experiences are also valued in this atmosphere. It has been such an enriching experience to share with these passionate players and it is something that I plan on sticking with for a long time. ”
Current NWHLers including Kelly Babstock, Cydney Roesler, Hayley Scamurra, and a number of others are PWHL alums.
The Forward Path of the NWHL and CWHL
It is obvious when conversing with Kelly McDonald that not only does she still follow the NWHL very closely, but that it remains near and dear to her heart. Furthermore, she is all for the betterment of women’s hockey if you have not gathered that by yourself already. Whether that is supporting a best friend in Harrison Browne, coaching young women who are approaching that apex of where she once played, or being a tremendous educator for young people. McDonald is still very much “growing the game”. She is a prime example of what makes so many women’s hockey players such good people both on and off the ice.
THW asked McDonald what she hopes to see for the NWHL going forward. Her point was well-taken.
“I would love to see the NWHL and CWHL come together to form one league,” she said concisely. “I know there are many moving pieces, and I could only imagine how difficult it would be to work out, but every single player and fan knows that it has to happen for the good of women’s hockey.”
McDonald speaks from experience. After all, she was a pioneer for one of those two leagues. The experience played a major factor in who she is today.
“My time in the NWHL gave me the opportunity to work for something bigger than myself,” McDonald expressed. “It really was about creating a platform and opportunities for future generations. The community involvement aspect was fulfilling on a personal level, but the purpose was to increase visibility, garner support, and pay it forward. It felt as though the actual hockey piece came second to the outreach aspect and that was fine because it served a greater purpose.”
Kelly McDonald helped lay the foundation for many great steps ahead. The best is yet to come.
General Manager of the Buffalo Beauts (NWHL). Hockey history writer “The Hockey Writers”. Credentialed media for the NHL Combine and 2018 IIHF World Junior Championships in Buffalo, NY, USA. Born and raised in Buffalo, NY. Lifelong hockey fan for over 40 years. Proponent of the women’s game.