Canadiens’ Lack of Leadership to Blame for Slow Start

The Montréal Canadiens are 0-5-0. They’re in last place in the Atlantic Division. They’re in last place in the Eastern Conference. They’re in last place in the league. After this abysmal start, one thing is certainly clear; the team is suffering from a lack of direction. While it’s difficult to say for sure what exactly is causing this confusion, it’s obvious that the team’s identity crisis stems from a lack of leadership with two of their best players out of the lineup and others seemingly missing in action.

Brendan Gallagher, Montreal Canadiens
Brendan Gallagher, Montreal Canadiens (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

In the absence of some of the club’s traditional figureheads, they’ll need someone to step up and be the one who leads them out of this funk.

Traditional Leaders Missing from Lineup

After the Canadiens’ Stanley Cup Final appearance last season against the Tampa Bay Lightning, many assumed the start of this season would be comparatively simple for the team. The majority of the roster was primed to return, and the arrival of new free agents made it seem as though the Habs would continue the dominance they displayed in the first three rounds of last year’s playoffs in this year’s regular season. This prediction was quickly thrown out when it was discovered that captain Shea Weber would be place on long-term injured reserve (LTIR), a move that may mean the end of his career. (From “Canadiens’ Shea Weber allowed to go on long-term injured reserve: Daly” The Athletic. 14/10/2021)

Max Pacioretty Vegas Golden Knights Shea Weber Montreal Canadiens
Max Pacioretty, Vegas Golden Knights and Shea Weber, Montreal Canadiens, NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs Semifinals Game 6, June 24, 2021 (Photo by David Kirouac/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Not long after this, Canadiens’ franchise goaltender Carey Price announced he would be taking a leave from the team to enter the NHL’s Player Assistance Program, just as his teammate Jonathan Drouin did last season. The combination of those two announcements threw the organization for a loop; backup goaltender Jake Allen was thrust into the starting role, the Canadiens lost one of their best shutdown defensemen, and general manager Marc Bergevin was forced to scramble to find a backup goaltender.

With the absences of Price and Weber, the Canadiens didn’t just lose two of their best players, they also lost two players who functioned as the team’s leaders. One the captain, the other the face of the franchise. Price and Weber shoulder the majority of the responsibility for the direction of the team, they field the most comments and criticism from journalists and other personnel, and they play the most minutes. Without the two of them, the Canadiens need others to step up in their place, and no player has chosen to take on that interim role yet.

Brendan Gallagher Seemingly MIA On the Ice

Although Price and Weber remain out of the lineup and will be for the foreseeable future, a player in the mix that hasn’t been as present as he should be in this situation is alternate captain Brendan Gallagher. For his entire career, he has been a player the Canadiens have counted on to step up in the biggest moments.

Canadiens right wing Brendan Gallagher
Montreal Canadiens right wing Brendan Gallagher (11) gains control of the puck as Philadelphia Flyers defenseman Brandon Manning (23) chases him. (Photo by Gavin Baker/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

To his credit, he has stepped up and taken questions on the losing streak from the media, saying that the Canadiens are facing an identity crisis:

“The problem isn’t one single thing. It’s on us to find solutions. It’s not like you can point your finger at one single thing. […] You can probably, to a man in our locker room, do more.”

Montréal Canadiens’ forward Brendan Gallagher on the team’s attempts to solve its losing skid. (from “Ugly loss to Sharks sends Canadiens reeling, scrambling for solutions” Eric Engels. Sportsnet. 19/10/2021)

Unfortunately, like the rest of his teammates, Gallagher hasn’t yet been able to transfer his attitude off the ice to his play on it. In five games thus far, he has no points in five games and sits at minus-2 on the season with four penalty minutes. His struggles mirror those of the team at large, struggling to score and attempting to find a place in the early goings.

Related: Canadiens Still Need Gallagher More than Price Five Years Later

Ducharme and Staff Leading Habs to Purgatory

The Canadiens’ bad start has many explanations, but what can’t necessarily be explained easily are the stats the team has presented to begin the season. The numbers say something is clearly throwing a wrench in the system. The team is 0-5-0, they’ve been outscored 19-4 through those five games, and their power play clocks in at a wretched 1-for-19 and 10-for-18 on the penalty kill. NHL teams count on their coaching staffs to effectively structure play on the ice, and the lack of consistency from head coach Dominque Ducharme and his staff is quickly turning the Canadiens’ promise into problems.

From the sound of his comments during his media availability on Oct. 21, Ducharme doesn’t have a plan yet.

“We’re better than 0-5, that’s certain. It’s a challenge. But, how do you respond to that challenge? So far, we’re still maybe figuring that out. We don’t have the results that we want. But I see signs… I see good things coming up and we’ll get out of that and it’s going to make us stronger and that’s it. Anyone can bury us right now, and we don’t care. Seriously, we don’t care. We’re going to take care of this and we’re going to finish where we deserve to finish. Every night we have 20 guys in the lineup, so we have to find a way as a group. And maybe some guys need to, or a learning or are processing that we need to bring a little bit more in different aspects — in leadership or the way we play, whatever. But we’ll get through and we’ll do it the right way.”

Canadiens’ head coach Dominque Ducharme on how the Canadiens plan to snap the losing skid. (from “Canadiens Notebook: ‘We’re better than 0-5,’ Dominique Ducharme says.” Stu Cowan Montréal Gazette. 22/10/2021)

With tonight’s game coming against one of the worst teams in the league last season in the Detroit Red Wings, the Canadiens can begin righting the ship. If they can’t, it may soon be too late.


Sign up for our regular 'Habs Newsletter' for all the latest.