• HOME
  • NHL Teams
    • Atlantic Division
      • Boston Bruins
      • Buffalo Sabres
      • Detroit Red Wings
      • Florida Panthers
      • Montreal Canadiens
      • Ottawa Senators
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
      • Toronto Maple Leafs
    • Metropolitan Division
      • Carolina Hurricanes
      • Columbus Blue Jackets
      • New Jersey Devils
      • New York Islanders
      • New York Rangers
      • Philadelphia Flyers
      • Pittsburgh Penguins
      • Washington Capitals
    • Central Division
      • Chicago Blackhawks
      • Colorado Avalanche
      • Dallas Stars
      • Minnesota Wild
      • Nashville Predators
      • St. Louis Blues
      • Winnipeg Jets
    • Pacific Division
      • Anaheim Ducks
      • Arizona Coyotes
      • Calgary Flames
      • Edmonton Oilers
      • Los Angeles Kings
      • San Jose Sharks
      • Seattle NHL
      • Vancouver Canucks
      • Vegas Golden Knights
  • NHL Rumors
  • NHL Prospects
  • Fantasy Hockey
  • THW Archives
  • More…
    • Columns
    • NWHL
    • Women’s Hockey
    • Other Leagues
    • Long Read
    • NHL Entry Draft
    • Books
    • NHL History
  • Log in
The Hockey Writers
  • Site Index
  • NHL Salary Caps
  • Hockey 101: A Beginner’s Guide
  • Join Our Team
  • Free Newsletter
  • Store
  • Log in
The Hockey Writers
  • HOME
  • NHL Teams
    • Atlantic Division
      • Boston Bruins
      • Buffalo Sabres
      • Detroit Red Wings
      • Florida Panthers
      • Montreal Canadiens
      • Ottawa Senators
      • Tampa Bay Lightning
      • Toronto Maple Leafs
    • Metropolitan Division
      • Carolina Hurricanes
      • Columbus Blue Jackets
      • New Jersey Devils
      • New York Islanders
      • New York Rangers
      • Philadelphia Flyers
      • Pittsburgh Penguins
      • Washington Capitals
    • Central Division
      • Chicago Blackhawks
      • Colorado Avalanche
      • Dallas Stars
      • Minnesota Wild
      • Nashville Predators
      • St. Louis Blues
      • Winnipeg Jets
    • Pacific Division
      • Anaheim Ducks
      • Arizona Coyotes
      • Calgary Flames
      • Edmonton Oilers
      • Los Angeles Kings
      • San Jose Sharks
      • Seattle NHL
      • Vancouver Canucks
      • Vegas Golden Knights
  • NHL Rumors
  • NHL Prospects
  • Fantasy Hockey
  • THW Archives
  • More…
    • Columns
    • NWHL
    • Women’s Hockey
    • Other Leagues
    • Long Read
    • NHL Entry Draft
    • Books
    • NHL History
Home
Toronto Maple Leafs

Dion Phaneuf: On Captaincy and Leadership

By James Tanner April 1st, 2014

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp
(Kevin Hoffman-USA TODAY Sports)

(Kevin Hoffman-USA TODAY Sports)

So it’s come to this: the Leafs have lost eight games in a row and all but giving up on the playoffs, the hockey-mad city of Toronto, one that thrives on negativity, has run out of things to talk about, rip apart and lament. Forget about trying to keep this streak and team in any sort of perspective. Remember, this is the city that once had a controversial firing of a goalie coach. So, with no meat left on the bone, the vultures are now claiming that Dion Phaneuf shouldn’t be the captain.

The argument seems to be that no true captain would let his team lose this many games in a row; that if he was a good leader, he would somehow hoist the team on his back and will them to victory. Unfortunately, hockey being a team game and a game where luck plays such a massive factor in determining outcomes, this is not an argument based in anything resembling reality.

Now, don’t take this as a defense of his captaincy. I don’t know if he’s a good captain or not – I  just don’t care. You could make Colton Orr the captain and I wouldn’t care. You shouldn’t either. Who the captain is, is important for the players, maybe, although I suspect that social dynamics sort themselves out and a “C” given by management probably doesn’t have the cache you think it does. Again, I wouldn’t know. I don’t know Dion. I don’t get to hang out with the team.

What Makes A Good Captain?

Fans love to argue about who is a good captain, who is a good leader, who is deserves the “C” etc. I get it – it’s something to talk about besides the weather. You might as well argue over which company makes the best shin pads. It is my opinion that if you aren’t on the team, if you aren’t in the dressing room, then you can’t possibly know what makes a good leader or captain.

How could you? Leadership is a pretty subtle thing. It comes in thousands of different varieties and styles; different guys take leadership in different situations. It is not something that can be measured. It is the very definition of intangible and is (in the context of hockey) 100% determined by confirmation bias. What that means, is that you think you see something that demonstrates leadership,(a come from behind victory, for  example) so you attribute a causal relationship between that event and your idea of who is a good leader. In another instance, maybe you see something that might cause you to question the previous determination (for example the team blows a big lead) but instead of challenging a previously established narrative, it’s easier to just disregard new information that may contradict your already held opinion.  This type of situation plays itself out over and over again as with any given player the leadership narrative is established at some point and then rarely ever reexamined in a critical fashion.  The point is that our ideas of who is a good leader are not determined in any kind of logical or empirical fashion.

In more practical terms, it means that every year there is a Stanley Cup winner and every year there is a team that comes from behind to win a playoff series or a key game. In every single one of these instances, someone will laud the leadership of whoever that team’s leader supposedly is. The opposite is true for any team that is favored and loses. Determinations of  leadership are derived from situations in which those making the determination do not have anywhere close to the amount of information needed to make a reasonable and/or reliable observation, and so instead, just make that determination based on what they think they see.

There are so many variables in a hockey game that, whether the determinations about leadership are true or not, they are irrelevant because they are awarded on faulty premises and because leadership is something that can’t be measured. It’s an abstract concept like love or patience.

So what you have is a narrative where leadership is attributed to players on teams that win and derided on teams that lose, despite the fact that someone always wins and someone always loses. This is because it’s easy to do, not because it’s accurate.

Bottom line is: the only people who know whether Dion Phaneuf is a good captain play for the Toronto Maple Leafs. Anyone else with an opinion on the subject is not informed enough to make that opinion valid.

  • Tags
  • Dion Phaneuf
  • NHL Captains
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp

Facebook Comments

Editor’s Picks
Martin St. Louis, the Little Big Man

Martin St. Louis, the Little Big Man

9276
'Mr. Hockey' Gordie Howe

'Mr. Hockey' Gordie Howe

9767
Recent Posts
Dec 10th 12:13 AM
Calgary Flames

Monahan’s Goal in OT Gives Flames 5-4 Win over Avalanche

Dec 9th 10:49 PM
News

NHL Commissioner: We Will Not Tolerate Abusive Behaviour

Dec 9th 10:45 PM
Boston Bruins

Duclair Scores Twice, Nilsson Makes 38 Saves as Senators Beat Bruins 5-2

Dec 9th 10:30 PM
Columbus Blue Jackets

Blue Jackets Snap Skid, End Capitals’ Winning Streak at 6

Dec 9th 10:20 PM
New York Islanders

Varlamov, Nelson Lead Islanders past Lightning 5-1

Dec 9th 5:40 PM
Anaheim Ducks

Could Ducks Still Trade for Defenseman?

Dec 9th 5:25 PM
NHL Goaltending

Sharks See Jones’ Struggles Resurface…Again

Dec 9th 5:10 PM
Column

Vegas Golden Knights’ 3 Stars of the Week: Dec 2 – 9

Dec 9th 4:25 PM
New York Islanders

Islanders’ Most Memorable Opening Nights

Dec 9th 4:20 PM
Buffalo Sabres

John Carlson, Tristan Jarry, Jack Eichel Named NHL 3 Stars of the Week

Stay in Touch
Contact Us

Via our Newsletters
RSS Feeds

Privacy Statement

Our Partners
HFBoards

About THW…

Founded in 2009, The Hockey Writers is a premier destination for news and information on everything hockey. Updated daily with news and features from over 130 writers worldwide. Over 2 million monthly readers now come to THW for their hockey fix.

Join over 18 000 Subscribers of our free bi-weekly Newsletter.

© The Hockey Writers 2018. All rights reserved.
logo
  • HOME
  • Hockey Headlines
  • NHL Rumors
  • Atlantic Division
    • Boston Bruins
    • Buffalo Sabres
    • Detroit Red Wings
    • Florida Panthers
    • Montreal Canadiens
    • Ottawa Senators
    • Tampa Bay Lightning
    • Toronto Maple Leafs
  • Metropolitan Division
    • Carolina Hurricanes
    • Columbus Blue Jackets
    • New Jersey Devils
    • New York Islanders
    • New York Rangers
    • Philadelphia Flyers
    • Pittsburgh Penguins
    • Washington Capitals
  • Central Division
    • Chicago Blackhawks
    • Colorado Avalanche
    • Dallas Stars
    • Minnesota Wild
    • Nashville Predators
    • St Louis Blues
    • Winnipeg Jets
  • Pacific Division
    • Anaheim Ducks
    • Arizona Coyotes
    • Calgary Flames
    • Edmonton Oilers
    • Los Angeles Kings
    • San Jose Sharks
    • Seattle NHL
    • Vegas Golden Knights
    • Vancouver Canucks
  • Store
  • The THW Archives
  • Prospects
  • The Goalie Page
  • NHL Salary Cap Information
  • Join Our Team
  • Search THW