Revisiting the Golden Knights’ Trade for Max Pacioretty

They say that the best trades in sports come when both teams involved stand to benefit, but try telling that to fans of the Vegas Golden Knights in the aftermath of the Max Pacioretty blockbuster that came a little over three years ago. There’s no question that the 33-year-old veteran winger has delivered since arriving in Vegas, but it’s hard not to look towards the Montreal Canadiens – even as they struggle this season – and feel at least a pang of regret.

Morning Skate newsletter Click To Subscribe

Sensing an open window for Stanley Cup contention, the Golden Knights went all in to acquire a top-line scoring threat and proven leader in Pacioretty, parting ways with then-prospect Nick Suzuki, Tomas Tatar and a 2019 second-round draft pick that became Samuel Fagemo. In that sense, there was always the risk that the deal’s immediate dividends would ultimately give way to long-term losses. Perhaps Vegas brass just didn’t know those losses would be so directly evident in the 2021 Stanley Cup playoffs.

What Vegas Was Thinking

The Golden Knights were fresh off a Stanley Cup defeat when they decided to trade for Pacioretty, the former Habs captain who seemed to be on the outs with his only NHL home to that point. In Pacioretty, they were acquiring a proven goalscorer boasting five 30+ goal seasons in Montreal. Even after expansion breakout campaigns from the likes of William Karlsson and Jonathan Marchessault, the Golden Knights still coveted established top-line talent.

Max Pacioretty Vegas Golden Knights
It’s safe to say Pacioretty is living up to expectations during his time in Vegas (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin)

Benefiting from a treasure trove of draft picks and prospects stemming from the 2017 Expansion Draft, Vegas were dealing from an area of strength to add star power to an already Cup-caliber roster. The same was true of Pacioretty’s subsequent hefty contract extension, which came at a (now unimaginable) time when the organization had cap space to burn.

Not only did Pacioretty represent the team’s first bona fide star forward (Mark Stone would arrive about five months later), but Vegas still boasted a promising prospect cupboard that included the likes of Cody Glass, making Suzuki somewhat expendable.

What Vegas Has Gotten

Injuries and the club’s inability to secure the franchise’s first championship have somewhat obscured just how good Pacioretty has been. After a slight dip in production in 2018-19 that saw him tally 22 goals and 40 points in 66 games, the 2012 Masterton Trophy winner has bounced back with 56 goals and 117 points in 119 games over the previous two full seasons.

More significant has been Pacioretty’s postseason contributions. The New Canaan, Connecticut native has recorded 15 goals and 30 points across 36 playoff contests as a member of the Golden Knights. His top-line wing pairing alongside Stone has proven formidable regardless of who’s at center, and may soon prove unstoppable once a healthy Jack Eichel joins the Vegas ranks (provide a healthy Pacioretty remains).

This season might be Pacioretty’s best to date in Nevada. Despite being slowed by a broken foot early in the year, he has produced nearly a goal-per game and continues to contribute at a high level both offensively and defensively.

What Vegas Gave Up

So, what’s the problem, then? Well, for one thing, Suzuki has looked every bit the part of the franchise cornerstone that Vegas had in mind when they drafted him 13th overall in 2017. Through two full NHL seasons, the 22-year-old has shown promise as both a scorer (28 goals) and play maker (54 assists) while making improvements in the face-off circle.

Nick Suzuki Montreal Canadiens
Nick Suzuki, Montreal Canadiens (Jess Starr/The Hockey Writers)

Under normal circumstances, watching Suzuki succeed in Montreal probably would have been fine for Vegas brass – after all, you put time, energy and resources into developing players and its nice to see them do well even if it isn’t for your team. But then the 2021 postseason happened, and a pandemic-influenced alignment quirk allowed the Golden Knights to meet the Canadiens for a spot in the Stanley Cup Final.

As we now know, the Habs upset the heavily-favored Knights 4-2 during a fairytale playoff run that also saw them topple the Toronto Maple Leafs and Winnipeg Jets en route to the Cup Final despite finishing the regular season with the league’s 18th-best record. Suzuki was an integral part of that, recording 16 points (seven goals, nine assists) in 22 games, including a goal and four assists against his former team.

Montreal Canadiens Tomas Tatar
Tomas Tatar rejuvenated his career in Montreal before joining New Jersey. (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin)

There’s also the contributions of Tatar to consider. The veteran Slovak never quite fit in with the Golden Knights after being acquired at the 2018 trade deadline, but that all changed once he got to Montreal. His first two seasons with the Habs produced 47 goals and 119 points. In fact, Tatar’s career numbers across three seasons in Montreal (149 points in 198 games) are surprisingly similar to what Pacioretty’s done in Vegas (174 points in roughly the same amount of games).

Through draft night wheeling and dealing, Montreal turned Vegas’ second-round pick into defensive prospects Mattias Norlinder and Jacob LaGuerrier. While Norlinder enjoyed a brief stint with the big club last month, he’s since made noise about returning to Sweden upon being sent down. LaGuerrier, meanwhile, is currently developing in the ECHL.

Who Won the Trade?

This deal has clearly evolved over time, taking the type of path you might expect from an established-veteran-for-young-prospect blockbuster. But while age and time clearly favor Suzuki and the Habs, this season has already forced a pause on any “Montreal is the clear winner” argument.

With the Canadiens’ Cinderella Cup run a distant memory thanks to some major 2021-22 struggles, Suzuki’s performance has dipped accordingly. In what was expected to be a breakout campaign for the London, Ontario native, he is trailing Pacioretty in scoring despite having played significantly more games.

You may also like:

That’s not to say that the deal can be declared a full win for Vegas, either. The ebbs and flows in the performance of the two men, as well as their team, speaks to the complexities of trade evaluation and how fascinating this one has been, in particular. We might just have to do this again down the line!

What do you think? Who has come out on top of this trade? Let me know in the comments below!


Sign up for our regular 'Golden Knights Newsletter' for all the latest.