With the Toronto Maple Leafs, playing goal isn’t just another job—it’s a full-blown test of patience, skill, and mental toughness. The spotlight here isn’t forgiving, and the crease has often felt like a revolving door. Some goalies survive it, a few thrive in it, but plenty of others barely get the chance. What makes it all sting is that, time and again, the Maple Leafs have crossed paths with goalies who could have changed everything. For one reason or another, those chances slipped away.
Related: Remembering Borje Salming: “King” of Maple Leafs’ Defensemen
These aren’t the stories of goalies who carved out long tenures in blue and white. They’re the ones who, for a moment, seemed destined to, but ended up as Maple Leafs “almosts.” And in this hockey-mad city, those “what ifs” stick around. Let’s look back at three names who never became legends in Toronto, but easily could have.
Bernie Parent — The Star Who Got Away From the Maple Leafs
When you think of Bernie Parent, you picture him in orange and black, hoisting the Stanley Cup with the Philadelphia Flyers. But rewind to 1971, and Parent was wearing a Maple Leafs sweater, sharing the net with Jacques Plante. At just 26, he looked like the next big thing. Skilled, confident, and still improving, he gave the Maple Leafs a sense of stability in goal that they badly needed.
But the timing couldn’t have been worse. The Maple Leafs of the early ’70s were messy off the ice—front office turmoil, ownership squabbles, and no clear direction. As a goalie, Parent wanted stability and a fair contract. He got neither. Frustrated, he bolted for the World Hockey Association (WHA). By the time he returned to the NHL, Philadelphia had acquired his rights. That’s where his legend truly began—two Cups, two Vezinas, two Conn Smythes, and eventually a spot in the Hall of Fame.
Related: Maple Leafs & Matthews Remain Focused Without Marner
In Toronto, he’s remembered as good. In Philadelphia, he’s remembered as great. For Maple Leafs fans, Parent became the poster child of a wasted opportunity, a reminder of how much better the 1970s could have looked with a generational goalie in place.
Tuukka Rask — The Maple Leafs Trade That Still Stings
If you want to make a Maple Leafs fan wince, mention Tuukka Rask. Drafted in the first round in 2005, Rask was supposed to be the long-term answer in the net. Calm, technically sharp, and coming out of Finland’s strong goalie pipeline, he checked all the boxes. The plan was simple: develop him, give him time, and let him grow into the role.
But the Maple Leafs never let it happen. In 2006, before Rask even played a game in Toronto, the team shipped him to Boston for Andrew Raycroft. At the time, the Maple Leafs were desperate for stability in goal, and Raycroft—just one season removed from winning the Calder Trophy—seemed like a safe bet. For a year, it almost worked. Raycroft’s first season in Toronto was solid. But by year two, it was clear the trade was a disaster.
Related: Best Mitch Marner Jersey Replacements for Maple Leafs Fans
Rask, meanwhile, went on to spend over a decade as Boston’s rock in net. He won a Stanley Cup, a Vezina, and became one of the most respected and consistent goaltenders of his era. Maple Leafs fans? They’ve spent nearly 20 years wondering what could have been. This wasn’t just a bad deal—it became one of the bad deals, a textbook cautionary tale. Any time Toronto runs into goalie problems, the Rask trade comes up. It always will.
Olaf Kölzig — A Big Name, a Tiny Maple Leafs’ Footnote
Not every Maple Leafs “what if” is tied to a franchise-altering mistake. Some are just odd little quirks in hockey history—case in point: Olaf Kölzig. If you blinked in 2009, you probably missed it, but technically, “Olie the Goalie” was once a Maple Leafs goalie.
At that year’s trade deadline, the Maple Leafs picked him up from the Tampa Bay Lightning. He was hurt, never played a single game for the team, and retired at the end of the season. On paper, it was nothing more than a salary-dump transaction. In reality, it was still wild—here was a former Vezina Trophy winner, the long-time backbone of the Washington Capitals, and he was, for a hot minute, a Maple Leafs player.
It’s trivia more than history, but it fits the theme. Toronto has always seemed to orbit around big goalie names, sometimes getting close, but rarely holding onto them at the right time. Kölzig’s case is just the lighter side of that pattern.
Maple Leafs Goaltending — There Has Always Been a Story
If there’s one constant in Maple Leafs history, it’s that goaltending never comes easy. Parent could’ve been the steady presence of the ’70s. Rask could’ve been the homegrown star of the 2010s. Kölzig could’ve at least had a cup of coffee in blue and white. Instead, they became reminders of what never was.
Related: Ex-Maple Leafs’ Defenseman Jake Gardiner: Where Is He Now?
That’s the thing about hockey in Toronto: everything is remembered—the wins, the collapses, the heroes, and the almosts. Goaltending here is never dull—it’s either a triumph or a soap opera. And although none of these three became Maple Leafs legends, they’re still part of the story. Because in this city, the story always finds room for those who got away.
[Note: I’d like to thank Brent Bradford (PhD) for his help co-authoring this post. His profile can be found at www.linkedin.com/in/brent-bradford-phd-3a10022a9]
