Five Things I Think I Think About These New Penguins

In a new season following so much turmoil and turnover during the summer, it’s a little difficult to not get caught up in the hype surrounding the Pittsburgh Penguins and their 11 goals in two games.

(Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports)
New Penguins’ bench boss Mike Johnston (Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports)

Suffice it to say that so far, it would seem as though new GM Jim Rutherford made a lot of good calls in assembling this new Pens roster; and new head coach Mike Johnston is so far pushing all (or at least most) of the right buttons.

By all accounts the new players are fitting in seamlessly. The revamped coaching staff is getting along great, and the plethora of assistant GMs are all on the same page.

Alas, it is still VERY early in this season for Pittsburgh’s professional ice hockey team. For right now, its all hugs and high-fives in the Pens’ dressing room. That’s what 11 goals in your first two games under new management and coaching will do.

With that said, here are five things that I think I think about what this season has in store for hockey in Pittsburgh:

1. I think I think that I was wrong about Mike Johnston

In my season preview I made five bold predictions pertaining to the Penguins. One of those was Mike Johnston not having a job by Christmas (at least not a job in the NHL). So far, from what I’ve heard through the beat-writer grapevine here in the ‘Burgh is that all is well in the head coaches’ office.

The players are happy with Johnston’s style, both on and off the ice. What was perceived by many Penguins’ fans – due to lack of knowledge about the new bench boss – as a weakness, was Johnston not being firm and having little to no respect from the players. This misconception is also what many, myself included, thought led to the hiring of former Penguin tough guy Rick Tocchet. So far, that could not be further from the truth.

Johnston is said to be a no-nonsense coach on the ice during practice. Gone are the days of ending a session with shootout drills, and ultimately, mustache boy of the month. In is a recommitment to system and team hockey. Johnston’s style is all about puck possession and puck support. While Dan Bylsma (and likely every NHL coach ever) stressed the importance of puck possession, there was little in the way of support. Under Johnston, the Penguins break out of their zone as a 5-man unit with options for the puck carrier, not five individual skaters trying to make a long read with the biscuit.

2. But I also think I think that the Penguins will find a way to hire Mike Babcock next summer

(Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports)
Could this man be behind the Penguins’ bench next season?(Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports)

While everything is coming up roses for Mike Johnston right now, the fact remains that current Detroit Red Wings head coach Mike Babcock will be a “free agent” next summer, and his desire to coach Sidney Crosby in the NHL is still very strong.

Johnston can make it very tough on Penguins’ brass to let him go at season’s end with a strong showing in the Stanley Cup Playoffs. Nothing short of a solid effort (think six games, at least) in the conference final will do. But even that may not be enough, considering the allure of bringing in Babcock, who has already won two gold medals at the Winter Olympics with Crosby under his guidance.

I still maintain that Johnston has stepped into a bad situation. Almost a lose-lose. If the Penguins falter at any point, he’ll be vilified mostly due to his lack of NHL head coaching experience. If the Pens flame out in the playoffs once again, he’ll be looked at as the goat who couldn’t get through to the superstars on this team.

And even if he can somehow survive all of that, things circle back around to the allure and appeal of Babcock.

3. I think I think I have a higher opinion of these Penguins than I did a month ago

My expectations were, relatively speaking, low for this hockey team.

Win the division by default. There is no one else who can come close to boasting the talent the Penguins have. In this case, the Pens can win based on talent alone.

Flame out in the playoffs. Second round at best, because I don’t think Jim Rutherford will make the necessary trades (or win the trades he does make), and Johnston won’t be able to reel in the superstar egos on this team.

Well, scratch that. Its only been two games, but these guys are playing. And they’re playing HARD. Crosby looks to be himself again. Letang has looked more responsible in his own end. Overall, the team appears to be having fun out there. Eleven goals in your first two games, with two wins, will do that. Call me crazy, but there just seems to be something there – at least for now – that has been missing for quite some time.

4. I think I think Evgeni Malkin isn’t very happy right now

Evgeni Malkin is recovering from ACL surgery (Tom Turk/THW)
Is Evgeni Malkin unhappy in Pittsburgh? (Tom Turk/THW)

An undisclosed injury during training camp.

A still-undisclosed injury that he is now able to play through.

A summer of nothing but quiet from Evgeni Malkin, in an otherwise noisy summer for the rest of the organization.

Lets face it: no one was happy last summer after blowing a 3-1 series lead to the New York Rangers and being ousted from the Stanley Cup Playoffs sooner than expected.


But “Geno” was particularly absent, and yet strangely talked about all summer long by those closest to the team. While most players go on hiatus after their season ends, they seem to manage to find a way back to their cities and make an appearance or two.

Not Malkin. Not ever.

He returns to Russia and spends his summer on the motherland’s lakes, fishing. So not hearing a peep from him all summer is not whats alarming. Its the way his silence was handled by the media in Pittsburgh, coupled with Mike Johnston’s trip to Moscow in July. That trip, it was widely reported, did not go well.

My best guess here is that Malkin was frustrated at his team’s performance in the playoffs. Then came all of the management upheaval. Followed by the trade of James Neal, and ultimately Malkin’s perceived “demotion” from center to wing.

In the end, it doesn’t really matter why he is unhappy, or the fact that he is unhappy to begin with.

5. I think I think this team is one big move away from being top dog in the East once again

As currently constructed, this Penguins team isn’t far from being a contender for the Stanley Cup. But therein lies the bad news: Not being far also means not being a contender, period.

Right now.

Jim Rutherford can change that with one big move: trade for a top-6 winger.

He has the parts to pull it off. This will come down to whether Rutherford & Co. have the stones to part with what it will take to get this done.

Malkin will find himself back at his natural center position sooner rather than later I suspect; and Beau Bennett should return from a bum knee sometime in mid-November. These two items beg two questions:

  1. What to do with Brandon Sutter?
  2. Who will be the odd forward out?

Sutter will return to his role as the third line center, and the odd man out remains to be seen.

I’m not going to give this away right now, but I have a trade in mind that on the surface may seem almost ludicrous, but it would make sense for the Penguins in both the short- and long-term. Also, it makes a ton of sense financially and long-term for the trade partner. So stay tuned.

I assure you of this: IF Rutherford were able to pull of the trade of which I’m thinking, it would be hard to bet against the Penguins come playoff time.

4 thoughts on “Five Things I Think I Think About These New Penguins”

  1. I think I think I agree with all of you…..except Tannor, as usual. I only read this garbage because I love to see what nonsense he will write next. I literally cannot wait until The Great Tannor Torrao reveals the trade he has in mind. Judging from his writing, I’m sure it’s something like John Tavares and a 1st round pick for Scuderi. I think I think the Pens would go for that!

  2. @Jrcanuck – agreed. I can’t help but take this entire article as mostly garbage…just like the previous one. I also agree on the need to trade a d-man. I doubt the Pens will be able to offload Scuderi during the season but I think a rental for rental trade with Martin leaving and a rental winger coming back is a great idea.

  3. Sorry to say it; but basically this blog is pretty well admitting that the previous blog a few weeks ago was mostly wrong. That was my assessment at the time. Mike Johnston has won every where that he has coached. It was not reasonable to assume that he would be gone by Christmas. It also is not reasonable to say that Babcock will replace him next year. If Johnston has the strong year that I believe that he will have, there is no way that Pittsburgh management will replace him.
    Malkin is already happy again. It is amazing what winning & success will do for the soul.
    Rutherford has not shown that he is unwilling to make a big trade. He made one with Pittsburgh when he brought Jordon Staal to the Canes (I’m not saying that it was a good trade for him).
    Yes, Sutter may go back to the 3rd line soon; but with an inspired Malkin on the wing & the Pens winning… Who knows.
    There almost has to be a big trade coming up. The Penguins can no longer keep the very talented D-men prospects Pouliot & Harrington in the AHL anymore. The Pens have a glut of D-men. They have more talented D prospects in Dumoulin, Ruopp, Samuelsson & McNeil. You have to believe that Rutherford will trade Scuderi, who is a poor fit for the fast skating, possession style that Johnston wants. They may move Martin too, since he has a lot of value & plays heavy minutes, yet, Letang, Ehrhoff, Maatta, Despres & Pouliot can all play as well offensively & probably better under pressure. Young teams with no veteran D-men like Edmonton, Florida & possibly Colorado may be willing to give away one of their talented strong young wingers for these veterans & a secondary D prospect.
    The Pens biggest needs are to add another scoring winger to the 2nd line and to add some toughness with skill to the 3rd & 4th lines. I’m not convinced that Bennett will meet expectations. He has not shown himself to be too resilient, so he too may be part of a future trade.

Comments are closed.