Lightning Domination No Guarantee of Playoff Success

Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Mike Babcock said in December it looked like the Tampa Bay Lightning were better than every other NHL team.

About a month later, not much has changed.

The Lightning are running away from the competition in the overall standings.

Tampa Bay Lightning
Tampa Bay Lightning celebrate (AP Photo/Chris O’Meara)

Following a 2-0 victory in Dallas over the Stars on Tuesday, Tampa had 74 points — 10 better than the Calgary Flames in the race for the Presidents’ Trophy and 16 clear of Toronto for first in the Atlantic Division.

The Lightning (36-9-2) have the league’s best home and road records, and have suffered just two regulation losses since the end of November (19-2-1).

They average an NHL-best four goals per game, have a power play that clicks at more than 29 per cent, and are on pace for 129 points. That would fall short of only the 1976-77 Montreal Canadiens (132 points in 80 games) and the 1995-96 Detroit Red Wings (131 points in 82 games), and equal the 1977-78 Habs (129 points in 80 games).

Related THW Content – Lightning Weekly: Kucherov, All-Star Snubs & the Streak

The NHL’s best finish in the salary cap era following the lockout that erased the 2004-05 season is the 124 points Detroit earned in 2005-06.

But a great finish in the regular season in no way guarantees playoff success.

Season Success vs Playoff Success – One in Four

The Presidents’ Trophy, awarded to the team with the best regular-season record, has been handed out 32 times since 1985-86, but just eight of those clubs have won the Stanley Cup, while three others made the final.

Six have been bounced in the first round, and four of the last five have gone out in the second.

Of the last 15 Presidents’ Trophy winners, just two have lifted the Cup — Detroit in 2008 and Chicago in 2013.

The Nashville Predators had the best record last season with 117 points, but lost to the Winnipeg Jets — their Central Division rivals — in seven games in the second round.

Predators head coach Peter Laviolette said his team never focused on the Presidents’ Trophy. It just happened as a result of the daily grind.

“We’re such short-term people — short-term goals, short-term teams,” Laviolette said. “It’s all about tonight, playing well tonight, trying to do the right things tonight.”

Peter Laviolette Predators Bench
Peter Laviolette, Nashville Predators Oct. 19, 2017 (Amy Irvin / The Hockey Writers)

While leagues like the NBA have moved towards resting stars and veterans with an eye towards the bigger picture, that hasn’t happened in hockey.

“We are trying to win (each) game,” Laviolette said.

Babcock won the Presidents’ Trophy with Detroit in 2005-06, but his Red Wings were dumped out of the playoffs by the Edmonton Oilers in the first round that spring.

Detroit secured the best record again in 2007-08 and won the Cup.

Early Playoff Exits & Wanting to Win Every Game

Babcock, whose Leafs visit Tampa on Thursday, said he didn’t change his approach to the regular season after the sting of the previous early exit.

“I like winning,” he said. “I like coming to the rink and winning every single day. We didn’t push to win the trophy. We just came to work.”

Leafs winger Patrick Marleau was a member of the San Jose Sharks team that won the Presidents’ Trophy in 2008-09 only to be stunned in the first round by the Anaheim Ducks.

The 39-year-old said there was some reflection that summer about how the group went about its business.

“It was disappointing,” Marleau said. “You definitely look at things afterwards and figure out what you could have done differently.”

But Nashville defenceman P.K. Subban said hockey players aren’t wired to ease off the throttle.

“I don’t think you could ever to do that,” said Subban, who made the Cup final in 2017 with the Predators despite Nashville finishing as the second wild-card team in the Western Conference. “You have to play the right way going into the playoffs.”

A well-oiled machine up to this point, the Lightning have yet to experience a downturn in their play.

Nikita Koutcherov Victor Hedman Steven Stamkos

Unfortunately for a number of past Presidents’ Trophy winners, that often doesn’t come until the post-season.

“They haven’t gone through any slumps yet,” Marleau said. “If they don’t, then good on them.”

The Lightning have, however, endured recent playoff heartbreak.

Related THW Content: Lightning Are Primed for a Deep Playoff Run

They were beaten by Chicago for the Cup in 2015 and lost in Game 7 of the conference final two of the last three seasons — including on home ice in May against the Washington Capitals, who went on to win it all and know a thing or two about getting knocked out early after great regular seasons.

Those experiences could serve the Lightning well this spring.

“Their maturity level to play every night and find a way to win seems to be there,” Babcock said. “They’ve had disappointment at playoff time and they look like they’re battled-scarred.”

Hats Off

Nashville’s Viktor Arvidsson and Tomas Hertl of the San Jose Sharks each recorded hat tricks Tuesday. There have been 55 hat tricks in 2018-19, the most through Jan. 15 since the 65 scored in 1992-93.

Jets Join Flames at 30

The Winnipeg Jets picked up their 30th victory Tuesday to match the Calgary Flames. It’s the first time Canadian teams are two of the first three franchises to 30 wins in a season since 1988-89 when Calgary and Montreal joined the Pittsburgh Penguins.


Follow @JClipperton_CP on Twitter

Joshua Clipperton’s weekly NHL notebook is published every Wednesday

Joshua Clipperton, The Canadian Press