Jack Eichel: Hockey’s Ultimate Consolation Prize

by Eldon MacDonald (edited by @ChrisRalphTHW)

NHL Draft War Room: Jack Eichel

Jack Eichel
Jack Eichel: destined to be the number two selection in the 2015 NHL Draft; American hockey superstar potential (Photo: Dan and Margaret Hickling )

THW’s NHL Draft War Room Rankings – Jan-14: #2

  • Hashtag: #TheNextGreatAmericanHockeyPlayer
  • Team: #9, Boston University, Hockey East
  • Position: Centre
  • Shoots: Right
  • Height: 6’2
  • Weight: 194 lb.
  • Born: Chelmsford, MA, 28-Oct-96
  • Twitter: @Jack_Eichel11

 Other Rankings

  • 2 – FC – Top 60, Mid, Jan-15
  • 2 – HP – Top 30, Feb-15
  • 2 – ISS – Top 30, Feb-15
  • 2 – NHL Central Scouting Combined – Top 305, Mid, Jan-15
  • 2 – McKeens – Top 30, Jan-15
  • 2 – THN – Ryan Kennedy – Top 30, Jan-15
  • 2 – THW – Christopher Ralph, Top 30, Mid, Feb-15
  • 2 – TSN – Bob McKenzie’s Poll of NHL Scouts – Top 60 – Mid, Jan-15
  • 1 – TSN – Craig Button – Top 100, Feb-15 (Tied at 1 with Connor McDavid)

From the War Room

Eldon MacDonald, THW:  A few words on Jack Eichel:

The Next Great American Hockey Player: The big story so far for the 2015 NHL draft, the one that dominates the draft columns, is the competition between Jack Eichel and Connor McDavid for the number one overall pick. TSN even has a Mac or Jack column that gives you game-by-game updates. However, as important and as fun as the Mac or Jack saga is, I think the real big story, the story that is missing from the draft page, is the effect that Jack Eichel along with his compatriot, 6’2”, 194 lb. Auston Matthews (a pre-draft favourite to be in the hunt for number one pick in 2016) will have on USA-Canada rivalries in the future. Until now, USA generally has been the weaker sister in this rivalry. Yes, the U.S. generally has had better goaltending. Yes, the U.S. defense has been very good – one that is likely to even get better as Jacob Trouba and Seth Jones mature. Yes, the U.S. were okay on the winger side of things too. However, at centre, the U.S. was no match for Canada. The US centres have been very good (Backes, Kesler, Stastny, Stepan) but the Canadian centres (Crosby, Getzclaf, Tavares, Toews) are superstars. However, that Canadian dominance at centre is likely to end three or four years down the road when Jack Eichel and Auston Matthews emerge as big 6’2-6’3, 205-215 lb. centres with NHL star qualities and abilities.

Editor’s Note: While north of the border rival Connor McDavid is worthy of The Next One moniker, Jack Eichel is the complete package with ridiculous upside and it’s only a matter of time when he will be in contention for hockey’s top American player.


Five Reasons Jack Eichel May Go Number One

  • Big man game: Size, explosive first step, acceleration, top speed, team first, big man mentality, strong on the puck and relentless in its pursuit – what you are looking for in a big man top franchise centre.
  • Difference maker: Jack is a leader with a team first mentality that his teammates draw energy off of. Jack is aware of this and tries to set the example and be the difference maker for his team. He is at his very best when the game is on the line. One trait that Jack Eichel has which is shared by his rival Connor McDavid, is that he appears to be able to retain that normal guy persona, the persona of a guy who could be your next door neighbour’s son.
  • Zen: Has a zen-like low panic threshold that allows him to hold onto the puck in the face of an opposition defender only to dish it off at the last second before being hit. He seems to use an x-ray vision to see opposition formations from behind the net before exploding out into the scoring areas to exploit their weaknesses.
  • Vision: Sees the game in slow-mo; plays the game in fast-mo.
  • Athleticism: Jack is almost always the best athlete on the ice; he can do almost anything.


  • Skating: Elite first step, first-class acceleration and top speed, very good balance. Excellent agility, known for his tight turns in confined spaces. His feet are always on the move, which makes it very difficult for the opposition to tie him down or hem him in.
  • Shooting: Elite release on his wrister, heavy shot that is almost always on target. NHL level backhand. And most important of all, Jack can finish too.
  • Passing: Adept at the soft or crisp pass. Tends to be pass first but can really shoot as well.
  • Stickhandling: Big man, phone booth stickhandling ability, protects the puck very well.
  • Vision: Plays like the famous Wayne Gretzky quote, A good hockey player plays where the puck is. A great hockey player plays where the puck is going to be.” Jack has the vision and hockey sense to be a great hockey player.

Defense: Jack’s defensive game still could some improvement. However, it is not so much a matter of physical skills as it is of having the mindset to be the difference maker on defense that he is on offense; this will come with maturity.

Awards and Achievements:

  • 2013 – World U17 Hockey Challenge – Bronze Medal with Team USA
  • 2013 – U18 Worlds – Silver Medal with Team USA
  • 2014 – U18 Worlds – Gold Medal with Team USA
  • 2015 – U20 Worlds – Captain for Team USA13-14 – USHL – Second team all-star

Improvements to make: In addition to the mindset improvements referred to above on defense, Jack has to use his teammates more in certain big game situations where he tries to carry the whole team on his back to be the difference maker. Again, this will likely sort itself out as Jack and his game matures.

NHL Projection: The big man, number one, franchise centre that most NHL teams sought out for probably twenty years.

Draft placement: It is going to be number one or two for Jack Eichel. Most lists including mine have Jack at number two currently but there is still a lot of hockey to be played. Also, let’s not discount the big man centre syndrome. Most teams want that big man franchise centre. Jack Eichel is the epitome of just that. If he does go number two, he is indeed hockey’s ultimate consolation prize.


  • Quote 1: NHL.com – Dan Marr, Director of NHL Central Scouting: “Eichel is proving to be an amazing game breaker; relentless and driven on the play, and he has the smarts, speed and skills to deliver a needed scoring drive to tie up or win a game. He has many Jonathan Toews-type traits in his game.”
  • Quote 2: New Hamphire Union Leader – Dick Umile, University of New Hampshire coach: “He’s (Eichel) the real deal. Just watching him on tape, it’s scary how good he is. Big, strong. His stickhandling span is incredible, and he can control it with a lot of speed, strength. He’s got Kariya-like awareness on the ice. He’s looking over here and he’ll put it tape to tape over there. Everybody knows about him and he’s still doing what he’s doing. It’s hard to play against him one-on-one. He’s strong, he’s fast, he’s powerful, he’s skilled. He’s got it all. And he’s a great kid on top of it all.”
  • Quote 3: The Toronto Star – Dick Young, Director of Hockey Operations at Boston University and former 16 year NHLer: “Jack has the same vision of the game, the same hands, and he also possesses the calm that Mario had. There’s nothing that bothers him. He can do it all. I saw him play when he was younger, and already it was clear enough. He has an excellent vision of the game, incredible hands, a powerful shot. He loves passing, but if he sees an opening, he won’t hesitate to shoot. Like I said, he can do it all . . .”
  • Quote 4: WEEI 94.7 FM – Danton Cole, Jack Eichel’s coach at the USA U18 NDTP: “He just wants to be a better hockey player. The guys that have a lot of talent and also have that passion and that drive to get better, they’re the ones that are really dangerous. They’re the ones that become elite players. Jack has all that.”


YouTube player



  • Profile 1: THW’s Jack Eichel Tracker – Bill Schoeninger – 09-Feb-15
  • Profile 2: Toronto Sun – Mike Zeisberger – 30-Dec-14
  • Profile 3: New England Hockey Journal – Andrew Merritt – 10-Oct-14

11 thoughts on “Jack Eichel: Hockey’s Ultimate Consolation Prize”

  1. Watching all first round players this year at their levels, this kid will be the most dissapointing pick for the team that chooses him or the other U.S. born player ahead of Marner, who is the actual second overall talent in the draft that will transcend the team that selects him. Five years from now that will be the consensus of most of the low hockey IQ management in hindsight that listened to the media and picked this low character player instead of Marner. Just ask the 19 teams whom bypassed Marner in the OHL entry draft. If Eichel played in the O, he wouldn’t have anywhere near the numbers c-Mac and Marner do, and he would be despised by his team mates. Look for him to go to Edmonton to be with similar type players as himself.

    • Thanks for the comment Dirk. I agree that Marner is underrated even given his high ranking on many services (stay tuned for a profile on him very soon!) – I have to disagree regarding Eichel though – it would be an interesting comparison, but I think he’d also thrive in the OHL – what he’s doing in the NCAA is impressive as well. Again, stay tuned for Marner in depth piece.

  2. Never seen a number 2 guy pumped so much who is so far below the generational superstar and Gretzky like talent of concensus number 1 McDavid. His boozing doesn’t help much either.

    • McDavid is unbelievable and I believe has separated himself. I think Eichel is still an exceptional player and have no doubt he’ll be a very influential player at the next level. I think it’s probably a bit harsh to judge the lad on post Beanpot winning celebrations.

      • When you are under the microscope everything gets judged so being judged for drinking as a minor is fair game. He could have chosen not to drink and if he had done so this would also have mattered . Choices give insight into character and Eichel chose to drink. McDavid chooses not to. It matters…

          • Disappointing to see someone post something so negative about an individual who they have know so little about. To judge someone based on one incident is unfair and to use it as a base to label someone is, plainly put, dumb.

  3. Don’t forgot about Tyler Johnson too, he’s one of the best centre-men in the league atm…Man, team USA is looking dirty

  4. I would certainly like to see Eichel play more. I have the privilege of watching Connor McDavid play nearly every home game in his final junior season and he is simply amazing. His speed, vision, and hands are incredible and it is so fun to watch him play. Hockey will benefit from both of these young men in the very near future.

    • Thanks for stopping by – you are indeed in an ideal situation to be able to see McDavid this season. Eichel is an explosive player as well. The two will add some dynamite talent to the big league and all of hockey will be the beneficiary.

Comments are closed.